Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why we lost

Socialist Organiser no. 317, 13 June 1987 · scan pp. 2–3 · Colin Foster · about 1,321 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

ROY LYNK of the UDM has come out publicly and said what he's been saying in private for He has never been a Labour supporter. He has never been a trade unionist, if it comes to that.

Now he has said publicly that miners should not support the Labour Party — they should not support the labour movement.

But the picture we are getting from the pit is that even his own members are telling Lynk: 'You're not going to tell us how to vote'.

At my own pit, the NUM has put out stickers saying Miners for Labour', and substantial numbers of UDM members are proudly walking around the pit with 'Miners for Labour' stickers on their helmets.

I think miners know that the Tories have never been friends of the mining industry — except where it can be hived off into the private sector, which only lines the pockets of a few individuals.

The threats to their own jobs, future, and security, looming closer and closer, are persuading people who a couple of years ago rejected the advances of the NUM to fight for the survival of the industry and of their own jobs and communities.

At that time, closures seemed a long way off, and not really an issue to them, but now they are beginning to realise that they backed the wrong horse.

This, on top of the recent debacle of the UDM's supposedly negotiated pay rise, shows that after the present problems have been sorted out you are going to see members rolling back into the NUM in increasing numbers.

The Coal Board are pulling out all the stops to prop up the UDM, but in spite of that it is crumbling at its base!

The Coal Board's fight to remove rom the NUM control of Ollerton and Bevercotes miners' welfares is going to court this week. It has taken TwO years The Coal Board had to go to the government to get them to change the law of the land, putting a Bill into andament They had to go to the High Court to get some sort of settleStOMS DOM desperate cause, of course, the courts are go ing to bend over backwards to ac commodate the UDM and the employers. But we'll re-take contro within the next couple of years.

It will seem like a defeat for the NUM if we lose the welfares, but it is a victory that we have managed to old on to them for so long.

Paull Whetton is secretary of Bevercotes NUM. Notts, Orders to PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 90p per copy plus 20p postage.

Organiser no.317 13,Ju Fall-guys IN 8 years to win a third consecutive term in London sade British History today, becom of the Left STATE OF Len 11t 1591 Neil Kinnock sa lid that Labour just starter I too far behind to make up the ground and win on 11 June. He's right.

Given our starting point, the Labour leaders did not make a bad job of the campaign itself. There were some good ads and television broadcasts, and Neil Kinnock defended nuclear disarmament and the right to secondary picketing with more vigour than we've heard for a long time.

The Alliance was marginalised, and Labour managed to present the election fairly clearly as a choice, if not between capitalism and socialism, at least between raw capitalism and capitalism tempered by a dose of the political economy of the working class'.

But four weeks is too short a time to convince many people of anything, let alone of ideas which in terms of the spectrum presented by the press and TV are radical and left-wing. Labour needed to have campaigned vigorously for health and education services with proper resources, tor publicly-provided housing, tor trade union rights, and for nuclear disarmament for years before the election.

Vigorous

And Labour's leaders hadn't done that. For years previously their most vigorous speeches had been against Labour's own left wing!

If Labour had campaigned, we could have convinced more peopie. And such a campaign would nave meant active official Labour support for dozens of workers' struggles — from the grean miners' strike to small hospital occupations — which could have made the difference between losing and winning those struggles, and between a rise and a decline in the morale of the working class.

The other factor in our defeat was more deep-seated: the political core of Labour's programme. The Tories replied to Labour's call for more spending on welfare by saying that such spending might be desirable but would cause economic ruin, Labour's leaders conceded the case in principle and argued only that the increased spending was modest and had been 'carefully costed'. Labour came nowhere near to presenting a different principle for running the DAILY NEWS SPECIAL THE LONL Maggie makes it a hat-trick 20 THE RESULTS Disaster for Alliance NATIONAL A-Z 1100 RESULTS GUIDE ELECTION NEWS BIG 56451 Pages 2,3,5.8,9,56 economy. Labour did not counterpose planning for need to production for profit, but only asserted that a bit more tinkering with the system of production for profit was possible without disrupting that system. With economic crisis raging all around, it is no surprise that this was unconvincing. The economic arguments got presented as a dispute on techniques for running the Tories' own system, not as a clash of class interests.

Weakness

This has long been a weakness. When Labour's left was strongest, in the early '80s, it still did not face the economic arguments squarely.

Since then, as the left has retreated, radical policies on women's, black and gay rights have been left as the high-profile issues of left-wing Labour coun cils, like rocks stranded by an ebMAGGIE'S Sun ELECTION AMAZING HAT-TRICK MAN 18 bing ude. On the principle of seeking the path of least resistance, they have become the channel along which Labour radicalism sought expression once it was stymied in direct class struggle and tied into managing the system.

Worsen

The result has probably been to lose the ear and even worsen the prejudices of many workers who are not bigoted but who find the business of women's committees, race-relations units, and gay### TODAZ RESULTS IN FULL S-PAGE SPECEM equality projects indicative of odd priorities from Labour councils that can't manage their basic functions like housing and education very well and can't even get up a consistent campaign against Tory cuts.

Probably the immediate result of the election within the Labour Party will be a boost for the Kinnock leadership and a further retreat by the left. But what was best about the election campaign was that Labour's leaders did shift from their approach of the last few years, and begin to challenge the Tories on the central economic issues, if only in very limited terms.

Boost

The positive thing we have to build on from the election campaign was the degree to which voters did polarise on the lines of unrestrained dog-eat-dog economics versus the principle of public welfare. From that base the left needs to relaunch the STR THE SPECIAL ELECTION HON NATION VOTED TORIES ARE IN AGAIN ід нен. HATAll tife *drama Britain puts Mrs.

Thatcher back in Downing Street MIE THE LADY IS THREE L THE LAD Photo: John Smith fight for working class That is the way to arm the labour movement for the necessary industrial figthback in the years to come, and for Labour victory in the next election. Mirror DALLY Sam LATEST THATCHER WINS BY 100 SEATS Pages 4,16, 17 and Back Past

Scan page 3

- FO NO COVER NOTFIGHT

----- pull-quotes -----

face of the UDM Whettons

Arabs, Jews and socialism

Daily Hall SPECIAL History is made as the Tories head

THIRD THATCHER

Maggie's massive majority destroys Kinnock and Owen

Thatcher storms her way to historic hat-trick ON AND JON AND ON

TRICKY MAGGE

YOU'VE GOT FIVE YEARS OF HER

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 317

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →