Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The left and the election

Socialist Organiser no. 316, 4 June 1987 · scan p. 10 · about 1,191 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no.316 4 June 1987 Page 10 now. In the meantime, when workers vote, the exercise is dismissed as inevitably dominated by the pressure of the ruling class.

They escape in their fantasies from the difficulties and pressures the labour movement feels from the ruling class and its agents in the labour movement, into a future world where things will be easier. Meanwhile they fail to do the tasks of today, fail to do what can and must be done now to help the working class develop towards the future the SWP can only appropriate in fantasy. Calling for a Labour government, they do nothing to achieve it.

The politics of the SWP, too, are essentially the politics of jokesville — tempered and diluted by opportunism and a willingness to take into account the attitudes of working-class militants who would never take them seriously against if they didn't call for a Labour vote in this vital confrontation between the political party of the working class and the government of the ruling class.

Militant

Less pernicious in its effects on the lection campaign, but no less preposterous, is the approach of Militant, which fights for a Labour netory under the slogan Labour to ower on a socialist programme. It's good idea, but it has nothing to a inh realityLabour as not fignung, on socialist programme, nor is it going to. An irreplaceable precondition for Labour to fight for socialism is that the labour movement be renewed from the bottom up, and that socialists lead the Labour Party. We don't.

Not the least objection to the slogan is that by way of vapid fantasies it obscures the work still to be done by socialists in the labour movement, and reduces socialism to an administrative blueprint. At the worst, the slogan is simply a lie - though the aim is more to console Militant than to deceive ordinary Labour voters. It is unworthy of people who say that they are Marxists.

Power?

From the same school comes Briefing's 'Labour take the Power!' Slogans should indicate clearly what they mean. By power, the people who put out this slogan mean state power. They think they are advocating working-class state power, the dictatorship of the proletariat.

But to the average Labour activist the slogan just means: Labour form the government.

Well, the Labour leaders want to form the government! But that won't be the taking of power by the working class in the sense in which the Briefing comrades understand it.

"To face reality squarely... to tell the truth to the masses" , that was Trotsky's advice on such matters. It • a lot better than fantasising.

Socialist Action Suciahst Acuon cannot be faulted • commitment to Labour's camaign. It is essentially right when it plains that: "What significant about Labour is not what it is pledged to but what it is based on" • We must vote Labour to defend the labour movement and what the movement has won over the decades.

But Socialist Action has its share of fantasy. It retrospectively condemns the "many socialists" who "during the last four years... have concentrated on building a 'left to the left of Kinnock'." Apparently - this is not quite clear - SA believes that nothing but defensive struggle is possible now or has been possible for years, and moreover that defensive struggle is doomed to defeat: "there is not going to be a Labour government" , it said on 8 May, throwing in the towel before the election campaign started.

Accordingly, Socialist Action never (neither now, nor before the election) really argues tor socialism (collective working-class control of the economy). Its criticism of Labour's leaders is that they have not built an 'alliance' (rainbow coalition) with blacks and women by following the example of the GLC and other left councils.

They redefine socialism as the *self-determination of oppressed groups. Despite the justice of most of the demands they champion on this basis, it means dissolving 'socialism' into a conglomerate of radical pressure-group politics. This boin chops down socialism, and, by disconnecting the particular causes from the general working-class aim, makes it more difficult to win workers' support for those causes In any case SA doesn't even ing much. Rather than trying to make its pages a weapon in the struggle, it talks to itself, concerned above all to convince itself of its own 'correctness' SA chops its own politics down to 'rainbow-coalition' politics; and then justifies those politics on the basis that nothing else can defend the labour movement, and nothing more positive than defence is possible.

A new SCLV?

Back before the 1979 election, when Labour was in power and since 1976 had begun, rather timidly, to pioneer some of the key policies that have since in a full-blooded incarnation become known as Thatcherism, SO supporters initiated the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, SCLV. The SCLV organised leftists to support Labour and fight the Tories, while making an independent and parallel socialist election campaign.

It was possible to draw fairly large numbers of leftists and a number of CLPs into the campaign. It was essential to do so, for socialists could not endorse the politics of the Callaghan-Wilson government even. while fighting to keep out the Tories and put Labour back in.

Today it is impossible to organise such a campaign. The forces don't exist tor it. The activists want to line up behind the official campaign, even if they add their own slant here and there. They do not want to give the Tories and the Alliance the chance to use any independent campaign 10 undermine the official campaign when Labour is challenging the inFrom page 8 cumbent Tories with alternative and better policies, however limited they are from a socialist point of viedw.

This time SO has put out a pamphlet, The Case For Labour, under the SCL V name. We think it is useful propaganda, but that is all: it would be futile and probably counterproductive to try to organise a broad campaign.

Marx

Back in 1864, when Karl Marx wrote the manifesto of the International Workingmen's Association, he described the Acts of the British Parliament (passed with the support of the Tories) which limited the hours. that children could work in Victorian factories as a victory for the political economy of the working class.

Marx had no illusions about the limited character of those Acts of Parliament, or about their effectiveness in ending the abuses they tackled. Yet he was right about the tendency.

In the same way, it can be said thai in Labour's election campaign Neil Kinnock and his team are confronting Toryism and expressing workers' anger, frustration and desire for at least a series of modifications in the capitalist system. For now they stand against the Tories for the interests of the working class.

When a Labour government begins. to act against those interests, we will have to fight it. Right now every serious socialist should use the remaining week of the election period to do everything he or she can to kick out the Tories and put in a Labour government.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 316

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →