A truly tragic love
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-06-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Edward Ellis reviews "Prick Up Your Ears".
The death of Joe Orton had an almost fictional quality. Orton was just rising to the peak of his fame, after many years almost penniless and unsuccessful.
By 1967, following big hits with his hilariously funny plays, Orton was the hottest property on the London stage. He was writing the script for a Beatles film. His future seemed set for greater and greater fame and fortune.
Then one morning in August, 1967, Orton was found in his little flat in north London with his brains bashed out. His gay lover, and murderer, Kenneth Halliwell, had also killed himself. It was a tragic end to Orton's brief career.
Halliwell had been his lover for fifteen years, sharing this sordid room and a life together that had included six months in prison for obscenely defacing library books. Why did Halliwell do him in?
John Lahr's excellent biography, 'Prick Up Your Ears' ('ears' is an anagram) gives a fairly cut-and-dried answer, and this film is based very closely on Lahr's account. Halliwell was older than Orton, and for years they had shared the attempts at literary success. But it was Orton who made it. Halliwell became deeply depressed and jealous, lost in Orton's shadow. Orton was loved, applauded, desired; Halliwell was considered by everyone to be an insipid mediocrity.
"You do everything better than 1 do. You even sleep better than I do, Halliwell moans in Alan Bennett's screenplay. Yet he felt he had taught Orton everything he knew.
His jealousy was also sexual. Despite their long-standing affair, Orton was incorrigibly promiscuous, often seeking satisfaction in public toilets. So in jealousy, envy and despair, Halliwell killed him. In even Orton and Halliwell greater despair, he killed himself.
The film of the book includes Lahr himself as a character seeking out evidence of Orton's life - and treating his wife almost as badly as Orton treated Halliwell. (Although the biography is meant to be a joint effort, his wife doesn't do much more than the typing). So Orton's life recounted by witnesses.
Gary Oldman (previously
Vicious in "Sid and Nancy') gives a tremendous performance as Orton, and Alfred Molina is convincing in Lahr's version of Halliwell.
Orton here is as charismatic and witty as you would expect him 1o have been — and as sexually aggressive. Director Stephen Frears has managed once again the tasteful gay sex scenes of his widely acclaimed "My Beautiful Laundrette'. Once again, also, he has managed 1o deal with the issue of homosexuality with a sense of humour.
Of course Orton lived and wrote before the passing of the Sexual Offences Act, and the film gives a brilliant feel for homosexual London at that time. Orton's plays are irreverant farces that poke merciless fun at sexual morality. He was a sexual rebel, and the challenging openness of his sexuality in those repressive times gives particular force 1o both his art and the story of his life.
In early editions of his collected plays, his sexuality was not even mentioned in the learned introduction. The film shows vividly how absurd it is to ignore the central aspect of Orton's life.
As a film, therefore, Prick Up Your Ears' is excellent. The relationship between Orton and Halliwell is touchingly affectionate, and with a sense of impending doom about it. Orton's strained relationship with his working class family in Leicester is carried off credibly and sympathetically as well.
My criticism is of Lahr's explanation. In the book, and in the tilm, Halliwell comes over as pompous and unexceptional, neither physically at(ractive nor intellectually very inspiring. Orton loves him — but like a pet dog, or perhaps an oafish elder brother. The question arises, why did Orton - so witty, so attractive -stay with him for so long, trapped in an apparently claustrophobic relationship and a certainly claustrophobic room?
The inequality that Lahr portrays in this relationship is very unconvincing. Orton must have felt much more sexually for Halliwell over all those years; and Halliwell cannot have been so one-sidedly dependent on him, his devotion so unrequited. So the film and the book both fail as a why did it"; they don't really answer the question, Perhaps it is impossible to answer. For certain, whatever the more precise reason Halliwell killed Orton out of love. And so their story is a truly tragic love story. With such marvellous performances, such a good script and such fine direction, 1l makes for an excellent film.