Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Vote Labour, kick out the Tories

Socialist Organiser no. 316, 4 June 1987 · scan p. 8 · about 1,980 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

If the entire labour lovement had backed the heroic miners' strike, then we could have defeated the Tories the election Socialist Organiser no.316 4 June 1987 Page 8 WHEN THE General Election campaign opened, a gleeful press was predicting that this election would see the eclipse of the Henceforth the Labour Party, if it survived at all, would hold the position in British politics held for many decades by the Liberal Party, that of a fringe party in Parliament. The party of organised labour was about to be relegated to the Third Division -to the level it was at 70 years ago.

Roy Jenkins reviewed James Callaghan's book of memoirs in one of the Sunday papers, and used the occasion to suggest smugly that Callaghan had been the last-ever Labour prime minister. The Labour traitor Jenkins, who has some standing as a political historian, argued that the near-century of working-class political energies invested in the Labour Party had now ended in an ignominious debacle.

Things don't look like that at all ten days before the election. Labour is plainly the alternative government, and the Alliance campaign so far has been a resounding flop.

That is no small achievement for the Labour Party leadership around Neil Kinnock, and even their political critics inside the Labour Party should recognise the achievement for what it is. A Labour victory in this election will check the victorious march of Thatcherism.

But it would be stupid to pretend that the election has anything directly to do with socialism. The Labour Party is not fighting for a socialist transformation of Britain. It is fighting to end the government of a brutal, hard-faced and stone-hearted party which has inflicted immense misery on million of peopie, and for a more decent, more humane running of the existing system.

Workers' government What the working class needs Is a workers' government - a socialist government which is accountable to the labour movement, which puts the interests of the working class above everything else, and which cuts down capitalism. That is what Socialist Organiser wants. We want socialism.

But the working class would benefit greatly and directly from even a limited change of government such as the replacement of the Tories by the present Labour Party. At the very worst, the working class will be better able to defend itself against the new government.

More than that: the defeat of Thatcher and the Tories would revive the self-confidence of millions of workers who are now too disheartened to fight directly for their own interests, millions now overawed bv the no.316 4 June TEEI and turned the tide. brutal determination of the Tories to beat them down, millions who know that mass unemployment and a relentlessly hostile government are a ditticult combination to beat in struggle where only a few, or a few thousand, workers are involved.

At the next stage the newlymobilised workers might well find the Kinnock government trying to subdue them. But that is the next stage.

A Labour election victory would change the political climate to the advantage of the working class. A vote is the most potent weapon millions of workers are likely to want to use in the period ahead.

This election campaign is being fought as a national debate - but one in which the scales are heavily weighted in favour of the Establishment and its first choice of government, the Tories. The Labour leaders have made great headway against very big odds.

They have done that in part by taking on board many of the assumptions and premises of Thatcherism. They talk about the national interest — as if the working class has a common national interest with those who own and control British industry. Their programme of creating one million jobs in two years is vague, timid, and inadequate. They propose to run the present system more humanely at a time when the dynamics of that ruthless system leave little scope for humane runnsocialists have to make is a long one. The list of criticisms that Not least of them is this: we shouldn't be faced with these limited choices at all. The Alliance and Thatcher need not have been allowed to attain their present level of strength and power. The leaders of the labour movement, both trade unions and Labour Party, should have fought back from day one.

When Thatcher came to power in 1979 and launched her murderous offensive against the working class, inemployment was about a third of what it is today, and industrial militancy was still a great force. A sustained campaign to drive the Tories from office would have roused the majority of the British people, and could have done what the miners did in forcing Edward Heath to an TE SHIA The serious alternative but in the election everything we election in February 1974.

In the three years up Falklands War, the Tories w unpopular in the polls. The have lost any election.

Dithered

Instead of organising a concerted fight back, the labour movement dithered and dawdled, allowing the bosses, encouraged by the government, to drive millions out of the factories and offices.

On the basis of the demoralisation created by the slump, by Labour's weakness and by the bosses' VICtories, Thatcher was able to build a spurious popularity out of her shoddy little campaign in the Falklands.

The Thatcherite juggernaut continued to roll. Right-wingers like Callaghan openly sabotaged Labour's 1983 General Election campaign. Those paler-blue Tories, the SDP, thought their time had come. Short-sighted leaders of the Labour Party and the trade unions refused to back the miners in 1984-5, and the miners were defeated.

Labour went into this election as the underdog, to take part in a rigged debate many of whose terms of reference were determined by seemingly triumphant Thatcherism.

Things did not have to develop like that. If the policies that Socialist Organiser and others argued for after June 1979 had guided the labour movement, the Tories would have been driven out long ago.

But the labour movement has to start from where it is now, and we must stubbornly defend every position, however limited it may be. That is the only way to prepare for future advances.

Socialists should not pretend that we are somewhere other than where we are. Right now Neil Kinnock's Labour Party is the best option the working class has.

Steer right

left therefore has n to 'steer to the righ campaign — to thro have into securing the very Duld Labour victory, while knowing full well Labour's and Neil Kinnock's limitations and not renouncing our own ideas.

Kinnock and his team are in command in this battle: let's see what they can do. If Labour wins the election, it will be of great benefit to the working class. If not, then it will not be the fault of the serious left.

This is the only honest approach for socialists who want to avoid kidding themselves about the situation we are in and to avoid political fantasies.

The worst crime that the left could commit against the working class in this election would be any act or any refusal to act which would in any wayhelp the Tories or their Alliance understudies, or in any way weaken Labour.

Loonies and Euros The badly misnamed sect the Revolutionary Communist Party offers a perfect model of what not to do - it is standing candidates against Labour. But in fact these sinister fools are not competing with Labour, still less with the Tories.

They compete with the Monster Raving Loony Party - and at the Greenwich by-election did even that unsuccessfully. This is jokesville, The Communist Party allowed its widely circulated journal Marxism Today to advocate voting SDP/Liberal tactically, while the party itself is standing a dozen or so candidates of its own - including one in Greenwich. The putrid decay and senility of British Stalinism today could not be more clearly expressed!

Socialist Worker Socialist Worker limply and opportunistically mouths 'Vote Labour' slogans while refusing to throw itself into the campaign to get Labour elected. It is gulity of weakening Labour's campaign by omission, and therefore of helping the Tories.

That is not what SW wants, but that is what it does in the real world it operates in (which is not the one it wants to operate in).

They snootily dismiss Labour's telectoralism' because, they say, eleccons inevitably involve the lett in trying to copy the right and diluting their politics. Thus the most the 'principled socialist should try to manage is a flaccid 'Vote Labour" and abstract socialist propaganda as usual.

Now it is right, and even essential, to point out the non-socialist: character of Labour's election cam-: paign and to argue for socialism. But to concentrate on the limits of Labour's election policies is simply stupid.

To say, as they do, that the key task is to warn workers against a future right-wing Labour government, is not to know what world you are living in, and not to know what item on the agenda the labour movement is now dealing with. It is a case of the story much quoted by Lenin, facing similar political idiocies, about the man who laughed at funerals and cried at weddings.

Now this article, in its own way, warns SO readers about a future Labour government... But we have got to get our priorities right.

If workers don't vote Labour, why will it be? Because they find Labour's policies too right-wing? No, overwhelmingly it will be because they find policies like unilateral nuclear disarmament, or Labour's limited commitment to restore union rights, too left-wing. Workers think like that in large part because of Labour's failures in campaigning over the last 8 years; but we can't undo that now.

Against what better alternative do the SWP measure Labour's campaign? Mass industrial action? We're for mass industrial action. But right now that is even more limited than electoral action, if only because it is not happening, and for it to happen a working-class revival is first necessary. (And anyway mass industrial action short of a revolutionary general strike is not an alternative to elections).

Fantasies

Labour's election campaign even on Neil Kinnock's limited politics — is not counterposed to industrial action, or revolutionary working-class action. It is counterposed by the SWP to a fantasy of mass industrial action.

And why is the Labour campaign so limited? Because of the outcome so far in the struggle between left and right in the Labour Party over the last 8 years - from which the sectarians of the SWP stood aside, as they now stand aside from the General Election.

Socialist Worker wants to be very left-wing: but they agree, from the outside, with the dogma of the right. and the soft left, that left-wing politics cannot win elections, But the left can win elections. If the labour movement had campaigned vigorously, building up to the election, then we could be challenging Thatcher with full-blooded socialist If the SWP are right, and elections. inevitably mean moving to the right, then how is the left ever going to win? Can we win socialism without the support of a majority of the working class?

Minority socialism?

The idea of socialism being made by a 'militant minority" over the heads of the working class sometimes seems to be implied in the SWP's opposition on principle to ballots, but it is unlikely that the organisation would argue this. So what then? Socialist democracy will get majority by a different route, in strike committees and in workers' councils which will replace Parliament.

In other words, in institutions that don't exist yet, which may not exist. for a long time, and towards the creation of which we can do little Turn to page 10

----- pull-quotes -----

MELA TORON DONT DOVN/THE PIT AND LEAVE THE REST IN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 316

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →