The family that watches A-bombs together
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-05-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
The bomb is only a backdrop to a family story: Rose's aunt Belinda Weaver 'Desert Bloom' "DESERT Bloom' is ersatz nostalgia. This film is about the tribulations of a Nevada family in the 1950s - the time of A-bomb testing in the Nevada desert.
The family live in an almost unrecognisable 1950s Las Vegas — the neon signs are there, and the gambling places, but they're small and tatty, not the glittering high-rise palaces of today.
The film isn't certain what it is trying to be — social history or personal history — so it wobbles around with bits of humour and tragedy all jumbled up.
The humour is largely self-conscious - look at us quaint people getting all excited about the A-bomb! The film-makers haven't registered any kind of feeling about the bomb at all through the characters, so when a little girl says at the end It's beautiful!' about the mushroom cloud, we're not shocked or horrified. The moment passes - it's a nothing.
The film is narrated by the adult Rose, who's actually 13 years old at the start of the film. She's looking back on events, but her age has given her no perspective, no hindsight. She's telling it like it was, no more.
The device seems pointless since it adds absolutely nothing to the film, except to tidy up a few details of what happened to whom later on. They could have had an epilogue on the screen for that.
War Rose is the eldest of three sisters who live with their mother and stepfather in Vegas. The stepfather, Jack, played by Jon Voigt, is a crazy - haunted by memories of World War 2. He is paranoiac, a drinker, and intensely moody.
He's also the kind of guy who doesn't know much but likes to think he knows more than other people. He goes on at great windbag length about the secrets he could tell, only of course his lips are sealed classified information, you know.
He is also violent and unpredictable. He bullies the girls and their mother lets him do it. We can't understand why, since we get no insight much into what makes her tick.
Rose says her mother sees only what she wants to see, and that appears to be true, since she wouldn't put up with Jon Voigt for five minutes if she really had a good look. He's a dead loss.
But the mother wants to have the American dream, so she puts a good face on everything and backs up her man even against her own children. Previously deserted by one husband, she doesn't want to lose the shelter of this one.
She calls him Daddy, but he isn't much of a bulwark against the world At the end, Jack tells Rose he just wanted to protect her and she snaps back 'From whom?' The point is well in's Jack who is a threat, A-be The some for the ci 10 talk about. The film is full of details about it - children in classes doing drills once the warning signal goes, blood tests, people getting issued dog desert. tags - but it never becomes a reality Documentaries in the lives of the characters. Cafe" treated the The bomb has been used as a didn't clog it up with the fictional backdrop, but no more. The film story. If fiction is to be made of the would probably have been richer period, especially fiction with a without it, since the family drama in character looking back on events, it the foreground would have had to needs to take in what has been learn20 20 i since then, and Vite scrup • the spread of nuclear ariters musin t have known how to weapons.
Finish it, so they just plant the family, united once more, watching the Backdrop mushroom cloud billow over the like the Atomic same material, but But the film cops out on that score. And it shortchanges the drama too.
Many women stay with brutal husbands who terrorise them and their children because they either can't afford to leave, or because they fear being on their own to face a orld hostile to women. But all this drama is tidied up for the nonending.
Once Rose and her stepfather seem to be getting on better, then that makes everything fine for Mum and the rest of the family as well. The family that watches A-bombs together stays together?
Scan page 10
national NO• JOE CRAIG and I clearly disagree on many things. He has still made no attempt to explain why imperialism is the central problem in Ireland. His definition of imperialism would seem to be self-fulfilling, too: imperialism is whatever Britain does and has done in Ireland.
His portrayal of Protestant politics reduces the source of all their power to their 'alliance' with Britain. That saves us from going any deeper into their history, their role in Ireland, and their attitudes.
"The demand for [class] unity"
says Joe, "has never come from them" . Well, the demand for class unity has never come from any religious side: it has come from socialists and trade unionists. Joe's history is Catholic history, and it is symptomatic of a general lapse into Irish nationalism throughout the British and Irish left.
In the early years of this century and in the 1930s unemployed struggles in Belfast, the Protestant militants had a proud record of involvement in and initiation of united class movements. In 19l1 the Unionist leadership tried to break a powerful strike movement in Belfast by labelling its leader James Larkın as a Catholic Fenian. Larkin agreed to resign in favour of a Protestant, in the interests of unity, but the mainly Protestant strikers refused to allow it and he remained leader.
I don't want to overblow the episodic history of working class unity in Ireland. The truth is that there has been too little of it. But we don't do any service to our class by lying about its history — not for any purpose.
Division
Joe Craig claims that "the most important division inside the Irish working class is between north and south, and the most important task, creating this unity" • The most important division, in my opinion, is very obviously between Protestant and Catholic workers.
Workers north and south may be organisationally divided, or divided by being part of different economies, but they are not immediately divided along sectarian, religious, political, sexual or any other lines simply because they live in different states.
The only thing I can imagine Joe means when he talks of North-South unity as the key is unity between nationalists, not between workers as workers.
Southern workers, by and large, do not see the national question as central to their immediate concerns, though they do have sympathy with the Northern Catholics. For Northern Catholics the national question is the central issue. From the point of view of the Catholics and all those of us who support their just revolt it is important that the Southern working class take their struggle more seriously.
But let's call that what it is -pannationalist unity, albeit between workers. It won't solve the central S-'-F Organiser no.315 28 May political divide affecting the Irish working class, the ProtestantCatholic divide, and no amount of left-wing gloss can hide that.
Before 1920 the Irish working class was organisationally united, very powerful, and involved large numbers of Northern Protestants.
That alone was not enough to deal with the communal division in the North between Protestant and Catholic around the national question.
Democracy
Joe Craig is not wrong to say thai Protestant-Catholic unity is unlikely to occur simply through the dynamics of what happens in the North, nor to focus on the importance of the Southern workers. But what is crucial is not juggling with numbers or allocating different roles to different labour movements, but what all socialists in the Irish and British labour movements say about the national question.
Should we have a coherent, independent programme which stands above nationalism, loyalism and British chauvinism, or should we allow all these forces to beat out our programme for us? We have our own world view or we have nothing, Joe, and it tells us that in conflicts between nationalities we are for the fullest democracy, for a consistently democratic programme.
I think that such a programme for Ireland has to attempt to conciliate and accommodate the Protestants as a distinct community within a united Ireland. Of course, no democratic programme guarantees success, and nothing short of socialism can guarantee equality. But the Marxist programme is distinct because its starting point is the interests of the working class and the need to create the conditions whereby class politics can best develop. It does not start by choosing the least culpable nationalism.
My central argument, originally, was that Republicans and socialists currently have no alternative to Northern Ireland and the troops. That is an argument, Joe says, for strengthening the Republican struggle. However many times you repeat this. to yourself, it just doesn't follow.
We think that the Republican strategy and the politics which inform it are wrong. At best, in my view, it will keep up the pressure for Britain to concede reforms to deliver goods to the Catholics.
Military
As Joe said in his letter, what we need is a movement "strong enough to boot them [the British army] out" The Republican movement based narrowly on the nationalist community, with its primarily military struggle, can never do that.
If the Republican movement has no political alternative to Northern Ireland which makes Troops Out a realistic possibility, then one must be developed. To simply strengthen the Republican struggle or conduct it more militantly again evades the pro 1987 Page blem. In short: why has the current • Republican struggle, the longest continuous military campaign in Irish history, achieved so little?
It is time to start asking this quesrion on the left and expecting sober and serious answers.
The fact is that the Republicans are only one part of the picture, and they take no real account of the major actor in the drama, the Protestants. This stubborn refusal to take Protesrant politics at all seriously is one of the most unnecessary and debilitating weaknesses of non-reformist socialism in Ireland.
We have argued that Troops Out Now without any political programme for a united Ireland will mean civil war and repartition. Therefore the priority is a democratic programme which proposes an answer to a complex national ques tion.
It is valid for socialists to disagree with the programme we propose, or to challenge it. But Joe Craig's asser tion that we 'demand' that the British army stay until we achieve adequate class unity is just absurd. The British army will stay until a force which can Photo: Derek Speirs (Report) throw it out is created. Most nationalists want, and have Like his rhetoric, "Will na- always wanted, reforms within Nortionalists support a democratic solu- thern Ireland leading to a tion which allows the British army to Ireland. united tion which we don't hold and have remain, etc" , it is an attack on a posi- socialists, should be constrained by I don't think that we, or any that Troops Out is wrong, but that on never argued. We have argued not titudes of the Protestants, or the lack this Catholic position, at- the its own it is inadequate, and that it is of interest of the Southern workers. far less important than demands But we should start from reality, not which actually point the way to self- fantasy. determination. We start there not because we accept it as unchangeable, but because we know that the force which can change things will be made up of the ugly, unprepared, divided, working-class communities which actually live f there is no contradiction bet- there, and not the heroic horny ween Troops Out and self- handed sons of Erin who live only in determination, then convince us in a few socialist and Republican heads. argument, refute our claims! It is Whether those communities do isn't enough simply 1o observe that change things or let stronger forces sell-determination isn'i possible as continue to shape them is something long as the troops stay. We agree, which socialists can influence. The and we are for British withdrawal, record up until now is bad. In fact, to but will that lead automatically to use Joe Craig's phrase, it is "a terriTrish unity? ble mess"' In any case most nationalists It doesn't have to be, and our class. already do support a programme can no longer afford it to be. which doesn'i call for British Patrick Murphy withdrawal, the SDLP's programme. Leyton, East London.
----- pull-quotes -----
ULSTER SATS