Under Uhder the Lance
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-05-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Broadcast to buy dinner for anyone who could point to an Alliance-run council following 'loony' policies. I Cleese should take some time to examine the policies followed by Tower Hamlets council in East London in the year since the Libe THE LABOUR-run council previous to the 1986 council elections was increasingly failing to meet the needs of the borough.
Several attempts to cut services and reduce the council workforce were met with resistance from the council unions. Understaffing was 20% or more in some departments.
The housing service was in an appalling state, and this was made worse by the council's blind refusal to properly discuss arrangements for the transfer of 30,000 GLC flats and houses to the borough's control in 1985.
The Liberals, using their familiar "Focus' tactics, were able to pick up on disgruntled Labour voters. In fact many (though not all) of the 'Liberal successes' claimed in the 'Focus' newssheets were won not by the local Liberals but by tenants' associations and council housing officers.
The liheral camnaien. based on mie slogan of 50 years of Labour Liberals and one SDP councillor control or me counci over 44 Lavour councillors. The Liberals then reorganised completely the running of the council, abolishing most central committees and establishing seven local 'neighbourhood committees' , covering two or three wards each, with councillors for those wards (in theory) in charge of all decisions for the neighbourhood.
This lett Labour in control of three of the seven neighbourhoods, but the powerful central Policy and Resources and Decentralisation committees are still Liberal-run. Labour councillors have used the limited powers available to them, and the even more limited budget, to campaign against the Liberals' anti-working-class, anti-tenant policies on housing, the London Docklands Development Corporation, and the voluntary sector.
The comedian John Cleese offered on an SDP Political THE LIBERALS' manifesto promised no new council housing in the borough, despite a waiting list for transfer of over 9000 households, and 800 homeless families living in bed-andbreakfast hotels.
They agree with Tory Housing Minister John Patten when he claims that boroughs like Tower Hamlets have 'too much' council housing.
The Liberals want to dispose of blocks and estates to private developers or to housing associations. The council claims that it can't afford to refurbish some of the worst blocks in the borough, like the Hadrian Estate in Bethnal Green or the Bacton tower. The only alternative is disposal to developers.
Tenants on the Hadrian Estate ar convinced that the council deliberate / overestimates the cost of doing u he estate to justify getting rid of it Disposal of council estates leads f further pressure on the remainin council stock. Tenants from block haina cold are nut at the ton of th transfer list and the reduction of th PUE GE CAU SOP ME overall number of flats availabl means even longer waits for the res of the transfer list.
Leading Liberal councillors argu that some of the newly develope blocks will be sold at 'affordable prices to local council tenants. But o the Waterlow Estate in Bethna Green (which was sold to Barratt under the last right-wing Labou council), the special low prices star at £38,000 for a bedsitter — we beyond the pocket of local tenants.
Councillor Jeremy Shaw has refus ed to deny that the council would us the provisions of the Tories' 198 Housing and Planning Act - whic remove security of tenure fron tenants in blocks the council wishe to sell, allowing the council to evic them.
Scan page 7
Auti-mla pro-cuis Cuts and rent rises THE LIBERALS' rushed decentralisation — a total reorganisation of council services in a period that council unions believe is far too short - will cost something like £20 million.
Each neighbourhood is to have its Komnse no rusting in the tera-waning of-over-9000 d-800 hesdnving in ast hotels" own 'mini Town Hall', which means new buildings for some of them.
Paying for this has meant a 12½% rent increase for council tenants (with no real increase in spending on housing repairs), closures of council services (such as two council-run seaside hotels, and all public toilets in the borough), and cuts in grants to voluntary groups.
This last cut, which would have been over 50% if some Liberal councillors hadn't rebelled, has meant redundancies for workers in many of the organisations offering advice and help to people in the borough.
Many arts groups are still unsure if they will be getting any money over the coming year.
THE CURRENT Tory government put a third of Tower Hamlets under the control of the London Dockland Development Corporation.
This makes the unelected LDDC, not the council, responsible for planning in the south of the borough. A rate-free 'Enterprise Zone' was established on the Isle of Dogs.
This was supposed to attract new jobs and new investment to the area. In fact it has led to firms resiting their businesses there to take advantage of the rate-free period, and either bringing their own workforce or using the move to get rid of a unionised workforce and recruit non-union labour.
Several London Labour politicians had cooperated with the LDDC -including the ex-Bermondsey MP Bob Mellish and the former leader of Tower Hamlets council, Paul Beasley. But Labour fought the last Tower Hamlets elections with a clear policy of opposition to the LDDC and a call to return control over the docklands to elected representatives.
The Alliance in Tower Hamlets have no intention of opposing the Docklands redevelopment, including the giant Canary Wharf office development. This would have 10 million square feet of office space, bringing enormous congestion from commuter traffic to the Isle of Dogs and the rest of the southern part of the borough, while the LDDC's own consultants predict that only about 1800 of the 50,000 jobs to be sited in the Canary Wharf development would go to people living in Tower Hamlets and Newham. Those would mostly be low-paid jobs such as office cleaning.
The Labour-run Isle of Dogs Neighbourhood Committee is campaigning against the development and against the building of a six-lane road from Beckton to Wapping to service it.
The Alliance council, whose sole SDP member is now a member of the board of the DDC, refused to call for a public inquiry into the building of West Ferry Circus - a roun dabout about the size of Trafalgar Square — and talks of the benefit to the local community of having a sixlane highway running yards from already crumbling council blocks. *NOW THE banks can sleep safely at night" , said David Steel after the Labour government formed an alliance with the Liberals in 1978.
Unfortunately the bankers already had little cause to worry about threats to their privileges and power, but Steel defined accurately the basic interests that the Liberal/SDP Alliance defends.
Where they have had power locally in Islington, which became the first SDP-controlled council after a majority of the Labour councillors defected, in Liverpool, or in Tower Hamlets - the Liberals and SDP have been anti-union and pro-cuts.
Their manifesto for the 11 June election proclaims all sorts of genteel reforming ambitions. They want all guangos to have 50% women members within a decade, for example, and they want special help for women to set up small businesses.
But in local election contests the Liberals and SDP have often been dirtier and more scurrilous than the Tories. They won Bermondsey on a wave of vile gay-baiting against the Labour candidate, Peter Tatchell. In Tower Hamlets they have been racist. For all its equal-opportunities talk, the Alliance manifesto says nothing about abortion rights, and their foremost woman leader, Shirley. Williams, is vehemently against a woman's right to choose.
On the class issues, however, the Alliance defines itself most clearly. They support all the Tories' anti-union laws - only they think the Tories have not gone far enough.
They would make all strikes illegal unless the dispute had first gone to arbitration. They would encourage no-strike deals throughout the public services. Even after arbitration, they would make postal ballots compulsory before strikes in all but very exceptional circumstances. (The present laws demand a ballot, but it can be a workplace ballot - and even the Tories don't propose to change that, or not yet anyway).
During the great miners" strike of 1984-5, the Alliance repeatedly attacked the Tories for being too soft on the NUM and not using the anti-union laws sufficiently against it. Just last September, the SDP's supreme body, the Council for Social Democracy, gave 'unequivocal' DR WEN! De OWEN WHERE ARE YOU?
COME AND HELP US BEAT THIS TYRANT!
THE CRY OF THE TACTICAL VOTER backing to the UDM and attacked the Coal Board for not supporting the UDM enough!
The Alliance also want to reintroduce wage controls - enforced by a 'counter-inflation tax' on companies. Their purpose with such controls is shown clearly by their Budget proposals in past years, when they assumed that the controls would reduce wage rises by 1% below what they would be otherwise.
In their Manifesto the Alliance repeatedly claim to be above 'class struggle' or 'class conflict'. In fact -though most of big business continues to prefer the Tories - the Alliance gets its money mostly from the wealthy, with a fair sprinkling of business donations. And those are the interests the Alliance serves.
The Alliance is in favour of nuclear weapons - but, it claims, not as much so as the Tories. It puts more stress on international disarmament talks than the Tories.
Yet the differences are minor. Even the Alliance's commitment to cancelling Trident is not as firm as it seems in the Manifesto. They are committed to a replacement for Polaris - and statements by Owen since the Manifesto indicate that it could after all be Trident. If it is not, it will be something different only in detail.
On privatisation, too, l he Alliance share common ground with the Tories.
Sell They do not wish to reverse any of the selling-off done by the Thatcher government, and on top of that they want to sell off British Steel if it can be made profitable enough. Alliance leaders have indicated that they would also like to sell off the 49% share of British Telecom which the Tories have kept in public hands.
They support the Tories' deregulation of transport. They deplore the Tories' running-down of housing, health, and education, but are all in favour of more private provision and more free-market principles in all these sectors.
David Owen has made it clear that if the Alliance hold the balance in Parliament after the election, they will prefer to form a coalition with the Tories. And from the Alliance point of view, he is quite right. On the fundamental issues, the Alliance is at one with the Tories. It is another capitalist party. -PW
Scan page 8
te Labour, l kick out the Tories!
The Tories plan effectiven/ tom eintroduce grammer schoonstandither ill nius.
MargaretiThatcher has aried to reassune peoplerby saying tha twine secondary schoolsitorbe split o fil from do calmeduce thon authorities underthe Tories' mandfestonproposalsev ill not haves entrencerexam pnd will not charge fees. But the essence of the separater themselvestfrom the genered education system andıset theiripn academic tests forentrance. Almost certainly «herezwillbeways ind meansey which the can get mone mower when other Increasingly children will have their futuner de ci decatthes age of 1n. Orone sider there will beza pathi through elite schopisi to untersity or polytechnnct amd to well paid jobs...On the other side,. theirpad willlead throughi cashrstar verschopsavit harassed teachersitoim inimed joberaining. with littlergeneralieducation, theracompulsory cheap abour onischemes like TS.
The Torrestare onlyproposing to continue what ithey have stantedısince 4919 Arthur Bough lopks athenssues.
Vo matter:remarns.
Betteroff schopise alerte o schopie. and probably. yearsion the dole "THEY give you the absolute minimum to work with and ask you to do the absolute maximum. There is one of you and thirty children.
Classes are too big, books and paper in short supply. You are always juggling with a set of priorities in trying to equip those kids with even a basic set of tools for thinking about the world and assessing what's happening to them" , as one teacher told the researchers who produced the pamphlet In and Against the State.
With the introduction of TVEI (the Technical and Vocational Education Initiative) the Tories have tried to extend 'market discipline' in secondary and further education. TVEl is not only a privatisation of education, but an undermining of the principles of comprehensive education.
Dominated
On the one hand, the Tories have cut back money for local authorities' spending on education, and on the other they have given money to the Manpower Services Commission so that it can organıse VEl with local employers. The whole basis of TVEI is not to provide students with a rounded education, but to train them for employment - to act like a sausage machine churning out young people for industry.
It is the other wing - beside the new quasi-grammar-schools-to-be -of the Tories' return to the days of the 11-plus, with kids classified at an early age as being academics, technicians, or fit only to become unskilled workers.
The curs have hit ine inner cities votst. These, of course, are the very areas which need more resources. So schools in working-class areas get worse, and even while higher education in Britain was expanding (now, with the Tories, it is delining), the proportion of students from better-ddle-class backgrounds nen education remained hig)
emlor posmons in industr e, and, ofl course, education.
em filled py hose students The educational Establishment is nated by the better-off.
The effects of this in terms of the deological framework in which cachers have to operate can be seen om teachers" comments quoted in abour, kick In and Against the State:
"The model laid down for you is an authoritarian one, in which you are supposed to set out the tasks for the kids. If you don't believe in that, you totally screw up discipline for some time.
You have to take a lot of shit while the kids are being Te-educated to the new kind of situation. Standards fall to pieces. According to any headmaster or Inspector you are just not doing your job".
The next constraint on the teacher is exams. The exam-oriented system trains students in the values of dogeat-dog competition rather than cooperation, and it limits horizons through setting syllabuses and by suggesting that there is only one right answer to any question.
As unemployment grows, exam qualifications are increasingly important for getting a job. Conflicts grow between teachers who want to encourage a wider horizon, and the expectations of parents and students.
One teacher quoted in In and Against the State argued that socialist teachers must try to explain to working-class school students "why they are failing"
However, to the students this can seem to be adding insult to injury. One teacher showed a video to her O-level students aiming to prove that accents and idioms were not inferior to standard English. The students. hated to hear what they were striving for analysed in such a way.
Parents
Parents can be mobilised as pressure-group against progressive experiments because of their fears that these experiments will mean their children not passing exams. "The first thing black parents ask is What can you do to stop our children under-achieving like it says in the newspapers?' They don't question the way achievement is measured" one teacher commented.
The so-called 'Great Debate" about whether the education system was effective in producing young people suited for jobs, was sparked off in 1976 by the then prime minister James Callaghan. It developed into a contlict between the 'progressives" wanting to retain teachers' professional autonomy, and the reactionaries' who wanted to gear education to jobs. Now the Tories are UNION pushing for greater centralisation of power, more government control over the curriculum, and participation by parents and 'the community?.
Evaluation
The Tories' new demands for evaluation of teachers' performance represent an attempt to further restrict teachers' autonomy in the classroom, and to create conditions in which teachers are forced to gear their teaching to exam success. But in resisting central control, teachers must disentangle the cause of their own rights as workers, and of wider education for working-class children, from any narrow or elitist defence of professional privilege.
Just in case there are any holes in the ideological armoury, the state also has a back-up system. Unknown to the last Labour government, the Foreign Office made a grant of €500 to a NATO-backed political education project for 17 to 19 year olds. Details of the programme were given by its founder John Sewell in the NATO Review.
Sewell's framework was *The threat to Western democracies" from supporters of "authoritarian regimes" . He proposed an organised state response to the "indoctrination of young people" , by introducing *real politics (with necessary and adequate treatment given to defence)" into the school curriculum. In a written reply to Frank Allaun MP on 12 July 1979, Douglas Hurd confirmed that six educational establishments were taking part in the project.
Some local authorities already have a close relationship with the police for vetting applicants' political views. In May 1978 State Research reported that, Lothian Regional Council was vetting applicants without their knowledge for posts in education and social work. The vetting was done by Lothian and Borders police.
Vetting
In March 1977 it was reported that Sussex Special Branch had visited two schools in Eastbourne and Boxhill, making inquiries about the political views and activities of teachers.
The current Tory scare campaign against 'Labour's idea of a comprehensive education' continues on the same tack. In an election poster, the Tories denounce the limited (if sometimes ham-handed) attempts by some Labour authorities to introduce more balanced sex education, especially about homosexuality, and condemn teachers in Hackney, East London, who through their local NUT union branch have tried to keep the police out of their schools.
However, state intervention in one form or another is inevitable in education, and therefore it is meaningless Task whether it is right or wrong.
As Marx pur it in the Communist Manifesto, "The Communists have not invented the intervention of society in education; they do but seek to alter the character of that interventie and te of the redig clas from.
But the working class does not learn socialism in the classroom from enlightened teachers. It learns it in the class struggle. What must be challenged is the society whose ruling ideas are being transmitted.
In some ways, as the Italian socialist Antonio Gramsci argued, some 'progressive' education may be against the best interests of the working class by encouraging sloppiness and lack of discipline. Middle-class children, with books, encouragement, and quiet rooms to study at home, may do very well out of a freeand-easy system; but a desire not to be too 'academic' or 'rigid' in the schooling of working-class children can mean that they get none of the less 'practical' education which they should have.
Existing culture is, after all, bourgeois culture; but only after assimilating and absorbing that culture will the working class ever be able to go on to supersede it and create the classless culture of the future.
Does that mean that there is nothing that progressive teachers can do in the classroom other than just wait for the revolution? No. Social change is not achieved automatically or without pressure for change on a whole series of fronts.
Progressive teachers should encourage self-organisation among students, and the use of that organisation to strengthen the position of students through struggle. This is better than the individual teacher offering students a sham equality: students themselves have to demand a real equality, and a real say in their education.
Socialist teachers have to fight for their ideas among teachers, and throughout the labour movement, in order to challenge the 'ruling ideas in education. Only in this way can trade unionists as parents be turned into a support for progressive education rather than (as can happen now) a reactionary pressure group.
Campaign
y Finally, a campaign is necessary to democratise the teachers' trade unions. And socialist teachers have to address themselves to the vehicle of any likely legislative reform - the Unless progressive teachers are able to get their ideas taken up by the Labour Party, and to fight for the accountability required to ensure that a Labour government carries them out, even short-term reforms will be impossible.
As Terry Ellis — head of Walter Tyndale school in London, who was victimised for his progressive teaching methods in 1975- put it, "In the end progressive education has got to have a political perspective, or else it becomes airy-fairy playing around with pretty things in the classroom".
Photo: John Harris
----- pull-quotes -----
Party took control. Attackina the victims
The developers move in
LABOUR MOVEMENT
-FOR— NAS/UWA