Labour Can Turn Thetide!
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-05-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Flux A GALAXY of labour movement luminaries, ranging from the New Statesman and Frank Field MP to the misnamed Marxism Today - have proposed that Labour voters should be asked to back the Liberals or SDP in some constituencies.
Their starting point was the defeatist idea that Labour could not otherwise stop a Tory landslide and had no chance at all of winning.
They based themselves on the massive lead the opinion polls gave to the Tories, and on the good showing made by the SDP and Liberals after the Greenwich by-election.
The opinion polls still say that the Tories are in the lead. They also say that Labour is catching up rapidly, and that the Liberals and SDP have fallen back. A Weekend World poll last weekend showed Labour about to overtake the Tories in 50 marginal seats.
Even without many marginal seats, the Tories could still form a majority government. But what the recent polls show is a situation in flux, and opinion swinging rapidly in Labour's favour.
There is a long campaign still ahead. It is perhaps too early to say with Neil Kinnock that Labour is heading for a landslide victory on the scale of 1945. But it can be said with certainty that a Labour victory is within our grasp, if we go all out for it between now and the election — and if the Labour leaders refrain from inflicting any more selfwounding stupidities on the labour movement like the NEC-imposed uproar over the Sharon Atkin affair. years the left has suffered a series of setbacks, desertions and defeats. Labour's manifesto in this election is not even a half-way attempt to present Labour Party conference policies to the electorate. The working class would have to defend itself against a Kinnock/Hattersley government.
Nevertheless, the Labour Party is the only alternative the labour movement now has to the Tories. In many ways, the limitations of the official Labour Party are the limitations of the British labour movement as a whole.
After all, it was the trade union block vote that defeated the left in the Labour Party in the struggle of the early 1980s. For better and for worse, the Labour Party reflects the unions, the mass workers' organisations.
Licence
A tactical vote is a licence for the Tories - in coalition with the Alliance if necessary — to make war on the labour movement. A Labour victory means defeat for open reacton, and a government in power which has certain basic loyalties to the labour movement. It means a government which is open to the pressure of the labour movement and the working class.
A multi-million-strong labour movement fighting for socialism would be a better alternative to the Tories than the present Kinnock/Hattersley-led Labour Party. We have yet to create such a movement. A Labour victory would perhaps be a step towards creating it.
It would encourage and stimulate a revival of industrial militancy, and put an end to the climate of militant anti-socialism which has dominated British society since 1979.
Advance
For all these reasons, socialists and trade union militants must work for a Labour victory in this election. It is the biggest blow we can deliver to reaction right now, the best immediate advance we can secure for the labour movement.
Opinion polls are treacherous. But for once they offer labour movement militants encouragement rather than discouragement. The current polls seem to be saying what we were inclined to deduce anyway from the basic facts of life after eight years of Tory hell: the working class and large sections of the middle class do not agree with Thatcherism and do not want a third Thatcher term. A majority of working-class people want revenge on Thatcher for her eight vicious years.
Of course, opinion polls can be wrong — as the polls which seemed to point to a Labour victory in the 1970 election certainly were. But what the opinion polls are saying right now is this: that if we push hard enough, we can topple Thatcher and her government into the black hole of history. Push! side. We're going out and we're campaigning and we're fighting like hell to make sure that we get as many Labour MPs as we can.
But those differences won't be forgotten. Issues that we want to sort out will be raised whether we win, lose or draw - issues like Sharon Atkin, like the failure to include the Justice for Mineworkers Bill in the manifesto. We have shelved our differences in the interests of unity for the time being, but that doesn't mean to say that we have forgotten them.
My view is that the main issue in the election is the attack on the trade union movement.
All the other issues are vitally important - education, health, defence... But if the Tories really succeed in neutering the trade union movement, that will make it all that much easier to carry out the attacks in those other sectors.
They will go for the trade union movement, and if they can in any way succeed, that will clear the way for all the other attacks. I see that as the greatest threat to working-class Paul Whetton is secretary of Bevercotes NUM, Notts.