Benefits and sexism
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-05-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
LAST week thousands of people on benefit didn't get their giros because of the strike by CPSA and SCPS members in benefit offices.
Although this is the fifth week of the strike it only appears to have hit the headline in a big way now. Is it because it is affecting London?
The usual story is that it is the north where employment is very high and lots of people there depend on benefit. One of the uniting effects of this strike is that people all over the country have been affected. The usual divide made by the government and its policies between the deserving' and 'undeserving' has been forgotten.
Pensioners, disabled and unemployed people have all been without money. The TV interviews have focused on how much money people have to live on usually, and emergency payments. No talk now of scroungers or 'on your bike stuff -they are all deserving and sufferingLord Young said so - I heard him.
But some people regularly don't get their benefit and the strike would have been just another week to add to the list for them. Who are they? Women of course., The benefit system is still very sexIt is very difficult for women livWOMAN'S ing with men to be the one to be the claimant and get the giro under DHSS rules.
Even for women who might be able to, the pressure of the male bread winner or the benefit winner is enormous. The friction and fuss caused by trying to be the female benefit winner would only add to the heavy pressure of trying to make ends meet. The women would be accused of taking away her man's dignity. So for women whose partners treat the benefit as their money and dole out small amounts for housekeeping -or worse, gamble the giro away - the day the giro is due is guaranteed to include a row followed by a week of worry. How to manage to the next giro day with little or no money? bal I think we should be pushing for a different benefit system that is indvidually based - not family based, so that women have benefit in their own right irrespectivelof whether they live with a man or not.
Of course extracting money from the man affects women whose partners are in paid work too. Then we have the problem of what they are to be entitled to claim from the state. If they don't have paid work should they get benefit in their own right -not wages for housework but unemployment benefit perhaps?
The CPSA and SCPS should be used to widen the discussion on the benefit system. The new Act coming in next April is awful. Benefits never come high on the list of issues when general elections are in the air. We could use the effects of the strike posiuvely to start changing that.
We also need to think about coordinating action better between Civil Service unions and local government ones like Nalgo. There is a new emergency payment rule that can now allow local councils to pay out benefit and claim it back from the DHSS.
The total confusion in London worried me. Different Nalgo branches were agreeing to different emergency arrangements. We must have better rankcand file links so that we knowowherenwelre going.
I can see a time when local DHSS offices could be closed by their management and councils will be told to use the emergency procedures. We need to be ready for that too. worst in Brazil's cities - they have jobs, shelter, and food - they are shown as utterly crushed by it. In some of the secondary characters, like Macabea's room-mates, you can imagine the spirit that has created militant trade unions and a sizeable Workers' Party in Sao Paulo. In Macabea and Olimpico there is not a spark of it. There is not even a portrayal of a spark being snuffed out. There is neither struggle nor tragedy, but only mute suffering land demoralisation.
Sympathy
Macabea and Olimpico are both stunted, intellectually and emotionally, so they can bring no comfort to each other.
Film-makers can show downtrodden and brutalised lives, and convey tragedy and pathos by the power of the sympathy they bring to their subject. What is lacking in The Hour of the Star' is precisely the kind of sympathy that could draw us into the lives of the characters.
As it is, it leaves the audience outside. It's a picture of working-class poverty which seems to be constructed entirely from a well-off middle-class viewpoint, from on high. No viewer is expected to identify with Macabea or Olimpico. tells It's like those worthy documentaries where you know what you've watched is terrible, but you don't feel it's terrible — you just don't feel a thing, except relief, or guilt for not feeling anything. drop these proposals. The Saratov Soviet adopts a resolution in support of the coalition Provisional Government. Thursday 11 May A meeting of 20,000 sailors, soldiers and workers in Kronstadt calls for the immediate publication of Tsarist secret treaties, an end to agitation by the government for a new offensive in the war, and for the conclusion of peace. The Riga Soviet refuses support for the Provisional Government and for the war, and calls for transference of all power to the Soviets. On the Southern front a congress of delegates of the 2nd Army resolves to organise distribution of socialist papers in the army, to set up political clubs and libraries, and to produce agitational leaflets in German.
Saturday 13 May. The Petrograd Soviet reatfirms its support for the coalition Provisional Government. A joint meeting of the Executive Committees of the Moscow Soviets of workers' deputies and of soldiers' deputies supports the Provisional Government. A number of soviets in the Minsk region declare support or reaffirm support for the coalition government.
The Executive Committee of the Kronstadt Soviet declares that the sole power in Kronstadt is the Soviet; the crew of the "Dawn of Freedom" calls for immediate transference of all power into the hands of the soviets. The Aleksandrov Soviet adopts a resolution to organise Red Guards. A mass meeting of railway workers in Sizran calls for transference of power into the hands of the soviets. In Gus-Hrustalny the Bolsheviks decide to recall their representatives from the local soviet, which is dominated by SocialRevolutionaries. 4200 9
Scan page 10
WHETTON'S Internation