Not a spark, not even a spark being snuffed out
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-05-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Olimpico and Macabea: the tragedy is missing Socialist Organiser no 313 14 May 1987 Page 9 Belinda eaver The Hour of the Star"
*THE HOUR 'THE HOUR of the Star' made the Star made me as uneasy as a horror film me as uneasy a horror film usually does.
This Brazilian feature film has won many prizes, both internationally and at home. It's not trying to be enjoyable or entertaining; it's trying to show a drab, depressed, beaten-down ute as it really is. But it shows that life from a spectator's viewpoint -with pity and concern, maybe, but no sympathy or identification.
It's the story of Macabea, a young orphaned woman who comes to the big industrial city of Sao Paulo from the rural North to seek work. She gets a low-paid job in a warehouse, from which she's almost fired again and again.
Even at her miserable pay, Macabea is a liability. With her typing speed of about ten words an hour, and her dirty hands, she spoils each letter she types.
Her home life is also drab. She shares a room with three other women workers. They are resilient and active; they support each other, and try to give Macabea support, but Macabea never seems to make real contact with them. Invited by them to go to the zoo on Sunday, she instead prefers to ride the subway by herself.
She lives in a world of her own, and the problem is that we can never really get to understand that world. The film doesn't muster much interest in Macabea, or in the fellow she takes up with, Olimpico, except as specimens, so we feel closed off from them too. The director has tried to present them realistically and clearly, but hasn't shown them pathetically.
Macabea is plain, awkward, and silent. She has a fantasy life — in one scene we see her posing in front of the mirror as a happy bride, and she reveals to Olimpico that she wanted to be a film star. But her fantasy world is so far removed from reality that it seems to cut her off from reality. The world is nothing like her dreams, so why should she bother with the world?
Half alive
Seems to be only ha One of her room-mates remarks that Macabea isn't stupid, but because she makes no contact with people, she seems absent to them, or half-witted.
The girls she rooms with seem to make no impression on Macabea, but she is slowly stirred into some sort of action by Gloria, a co-worker whose life revolves around men. Gloria talkes about her life and men constantly, and Macabea wants to copy her. She meets Olimpico, a steelworker.
He has grandiose dreams, 100... he wants to be a Senator - but his fantasies and Macabea's never coincide, and can't bring them closer together. Macabea seems to doubt Olimpico, and he's oftended, since he doesn't think Macabea is gooc enough for him anyway. He only hangs around with her because he can't get anyone better.
If anything, Olimpico is more demoralised than Macabea, and mean too.
What is missing from the film is the tragedy of these people's lives. Macabea and Olimpico yearn for better things, but without any real hope. What they want is so unattainable that there is nothing they can do, day-to-day, to work towards their fantastic goals.
Although their poverty is not the YEAR OF REVOLUTION Monday 8 May Workers at Kiev workshops producing military uniforms pass a resolution declaring the coalition government *hostile to the interests of democracy, counter-revolutionary in its domestic policies, and annexationist in foreign policies. A meeting of the Dolzhan Regional Soviet calls on local soviets to establish armed militias to combat counter-revolutionary activities. The Kazan Soviet of workers' and soldiers' deputies declares its support for the coalition government. The local commissioner in Merv appeals to the commander of the garrison for reinforcements in view of increasing anti-government demonstrations.
Tuesday 9 May A series of factory mass meetings in Petrograd opposes the formation of a coalition government. A meeting of the Krasnoyarsk Soviet describes the entry of socialists into the coalition government as a "tactical mistake".
The Poltava Soviet approves the formation of a coalition government. The Executive Committee of the Odessa Soviet of soldiers' and officers' deputies appeals to all members of the garrison to support the coalition Provisional Government. The Novocherkassk Soviet declares its support for the coalition government and advocates war until victory. A regional congress of local soviets held in Simferopol supports the government and calls for immediate introduction of social control over production.
A meeting in Moscow of the 11th company of the 185th reserve infantry regiment calls for an end to the war. The Tambov Soviet calls for peace without annexations and confiscations. Soldiers on the Rumanian front send a letter to the Petrograd Soviet appealing for better provisions for the army, and for the despatch of police and gendarmes to the front. Wednesday 10 May Minister of Foreign Affairs Tereshchenko declares his opposition to the publication of secret treaties concluded under the Tsar.
In Odessa 1,000 delegates attend a con gress of Soviets of the Southern region; it declares its support for the coalition government, continuation of the war, the 8-hour working day, and better working conditions. The Elisavetgrad Soviet of officers' and soldiers' deputies calls for deserters to return to the trenches. A meeting of the military section of the Ekaterinodar Soviet of workers' and military deputies calls for the shuttingdown of the local Bolshevik paper and for the arrest of Lenin; a mass meeting of 3,000 workers, soldiers and peasants demands that the Soviet military section