Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

1924: the red scare election

Socialist Organiser no. 313, 14 May 1987 · scan pp. 7–8 · Tim Anderson · about 1,403 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Orgreave June '84 and the police, and the international ruling class was in such a state of disarrav that it was unable to invade or interfere.

That is all possible if you want to stretch your imagination million miles from today's Britain - or if you want to conveniently avoid the problems that workers face right now. For it is a fact that in current conditions workers face violence, or the threat of it, on picket lines, in the black communities, and on the streets. Our job is to develop vorking-class organisation to the vel at which workers will be repared to defend themselves om attack.

This principle, extended to the ..af society, must be built on • it he economic gains of a - workers' control ible economic planning. of workers' self- defence links the class struggle of today with the socialist future. rather than imposing the schema of a parliamentary road onto the battles of today Possibility The point is made clear if you look at the way the leftreformists in the Militant operated during the miners" strike of 1984-5. During the strike the Militant called for a 24 hour general strike, the aim of which was to force the Tories into a general election. What this would have meant was derailing a strike movement which would have offered the possibility of changing society for ever - by imposing their blueprint of socialist transformation.

For the capitalist Photo: John Harris. ment is only one means of ruling. It is not their main means even now: most real decisions are taken by permanent, unelected state officials in the Bank of England, Whitehall,and the police and army top ranks, while parliament acts as a facade. If the capitalists reckon that their wealth and power is seriously threatened, they will ruthlessly ignore the formalities of that parliamentary facade, and use all the resources of the bureaucracy and the armed forces to try to defeat the working class.

If the labour movement is mesmerised and bewitched by the parliamentary facade, and does not face up to the task of tackling the behind the scenes unelected power of the millionaire class, then we are fighting the class war with one hand tied behind our backs THE ELECTION of 1923 had given Labour 191 seats in Parliament, as against 159 for the Liberals and 259 for the Tories. So Labour had no absolute majority and indeed only half the seats of the Liberals and Tories combined. But they didn't combine. The ruling class was divided and this division was reflected in the unwillingness of the Liberals and Tories to form a coalition.

It was into this gap that Labour stepped and Ramsey MacDonald formed the first Labour government in the following month. The fact that the two capitalist parties acquiesced to a Labour government was not a sign of Labour's strength, but rather of the confidence of the bourgeois politicians that Labour would provide a safe stopgap. As Asquith put it, "if a Labour government is ever to be tried in this country, as it will be sooner or later, it could hardly be tried under safer conditions.

Labour's electoral programme was one of nationalisations and of dealing with unemployment; it laid particular stress on nationalising the mines, If anything worthwhile was to come out of the Labour government, then the strategy would be to press ahead with party policy and force an election on these issues as soon as the Liberals and Tories combined to vote against them. With such a strategy Labour would certainly have increased the nember of its MPs, and could possibly have been returnedlas the largest single party.

Election

But MacDonald did not tall short of Asquith's estimation. Rather than forcing an election on its own terms and around its own policies, the Labour government was concerned to use its few months of power to demonstrate that "fit to govern" — or in other words, that it was entirely subservient to the whims of capitalism.

Unemployment increased and prices went up; the mines weren't nationalised; and so eager were the Labour leaders to prove their respectability that they even evoked the Emergency Powers Act against a transport workers' strike.

The excuse given for every betrayal was, of course, that Labour had to depend on Liberal support in order to survive as a government.

But in fact they were forced to fight an election - by a Tory 'Red Scare' campaign. This was sparked off by the infamous 'Zinoviev Letter the existence of which was announc ed to the world by the Daily Mail. just 5 days before polling was to take place.

The letter was supposedly sent to the British Communist Party by Zinoviev, *President of the Presidium of the IKKI', and Arthur MeManus, who was a member of the Executive Committee of the Communist International. Headed 'very secret the letler called for a campaign 1o put pressure on Labour 10 ratify The Anglo-Soviet Treaty which the Government had negotiated; for the building of communist cells within the Army and Navy and the munitions factories, and for the formation of a group of military experts with the CPGB.

It was a fake. But this clumsy forgery was quite sufficient to dictate the terms of the election. Exactly how the letter came into the hands of the Foreign Office was never revealed. The truth of the matter was probably as stated by the Communist Party at then time; that, the forgery was berpetrated bira White Russian emigres intent on wrecking the Anglo-Soviet Treaty.

In any event, the Foreign Office sent it to MacDonald, who returned MacDonald it with instructions that they should find out whether or not it was genuine and publish it if it wasn't a forgery. MacDonald also approved a draft protest note to the Russian Charge d' Affairs, Rakovsky, and left the matter with the Foreign Office, who were to consult him before making any move.

Someone at the Foreign Office, however, decided to force MacDonald's hand and the letter was leaked to the Daily Mail. The same day the Foreign Office published it too, and also sent off the protest note, without MacDonald knowing a thing of what was happening.

The next day the storm broke. The press started a rabid anti-communist witch hunt, with the government supposedly in the hands of communists. "Union Jack or Red Flag' screamed the Daily Mail, Vote Conservative and rid the country of the government that is controlled by the Communists who take their orders from Moscow, the home of wholesale murder and starvation.

At first the Government Ministers claimed that the letter was a forgery, as it was. But that line fell through when it became apparent that MacDonald had approved the protest note.

The Labour Ministers protested that they were the most vehement anti-communists, as indeed they were, and they produced an impressive list to prove their claim. Had they not at the Labour Party Conference which had just ended excluded Communists from standing as Labour Party candidates and declared Labour Partv and Communist Party membership to be incompatible? Hadn't they jailed JR Campbell, the editor of the CP's weekly paper, for inciting mutiny amongst the armed forces?

But it was no use. Grovel as they may, the reactionaries would not let them off the hook. Labour was branded as the 'tool of foreign agents'. danger to 'national security'. The election became a one issue affair, and Labour's one independent piece of policy, the recognition of the Soviet Union and the Anglo-Soviet agreement, now hung round their necks like a dead weight.

For their betrayal of party policy and for their, anti-communism, Labour leaders reaped a bitter harvest. In the election Labour lost 40 seats and the Tories were returned with 415 MPs, their biggest majority since 1832] But the "Red Letter" scare did not in fact shake the hard core of working class Labour support. Labour's vote increased from 4,348,379 in 1923 to 5,482,629 and in North Battersea, Saklatvala regained his seat on a Communist ticket (in 1922 he had stood as a Labour candidate) defeating a 'constitutionalist' who had Liberal and Tory support.

What had happened was that the Red Scare? had shaken the middle classe voter away fromethe Liberals and towards the Tories - exactly the same vote which McDonald had hoped to attract towards Labour by his weak-kneed policies.

Scan page 8

is the work ing class

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 313

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →