Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The crisis facing Botha

Socialist Organiser no. 312, 7 May 1987 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,440 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no.312 7. May 1987 Page 10 PW Botha's ruling National Party (NP) will win this week's whites-only general election in South Africa. But the end of the election campaign will not mean the end of the profound economic, social and political crisis facing the country's racialcapitalist rulers.

The economy is in a mess. South Africa is currently going through the most severe recession since the 1930s.

Inflation at 16% is a major problem, unemployment is soaring, the balance of payments is in crisis and the Rand is doing very badly on the international money markets. The economic crisis is now affecting whites, for whom unemployment is at a record level. Soup kitchens have opened up in white areas and the worst off white workers are now digging trenches shoulder to shoulder with black workers in central Johannesburg for f30 a week.

This situation is aggravated by the monetarist solutions preferred by South African capital which threatens manv of the 'sheltered' positions of white state emplovees.

And this risks provoking a white backlash.

For blacks, things are much worse. In Port Elizabeth, which used to be the centre of South Africa's car industry, black unemployment stands at 50%. In the bantustans around 15% of the population are destitute.

Internationally the regime is under pressure. The trickle of 'disinvestment' has turned into a flood. Though much of this 'disinvestment" has been purely "economic' as opposed to 'political' and South African monopolies have gobbled up the spoils, the impression of isolation remains. More importantly, Botha has not got away with the latest state of emergency totally sanctions-free as he may have hoped. Botha's attempt to use the emergency to prove that he could "get tough" with the liberation movement and avoid any kind of sanctions has backfired.

Botha has failed to draw in a large enough number of middle class blacks to make his reform strategy work. Added together, all the collaborators, stooges and gangsters in local government, the tri-cameral system and the bantustans do not amount to a stable, national force in the black community on which to base a serious restructuring of white rule.

Even the most potentially powerful like those who run the mineral rich Bophutatswana bantustan don't represent a 'third force' in the black community that could at the moment undermine the black opposition and provide a safe partner with which to negotiate.

However, given time, money and arms, forces like Chief Buthelezi's Zulu Inkatha movement could well help beat down the liberation movement for Botha.

Reforms fan revolt Small scale reforms are that Botha can offer the black rity. Passes may go, but the whe mut botna's answer: repression of vanict lanielation which nantuala ut lacist leg sanel the movement of black people -influx control, group areas, and forced removals remain. These attempts to update the facade of apartheid have not succeeded in their purpose, rather they have fanned the flames of revolt.

Botha is unprepared and unwilling to give up white power. Even the "liberal' Progressive Federal Party (PFP) stops well short of the basic demand of the liberation movement for one person, one vote in an undivided South Africa.

But reforms put the system out of balance. Lenın writing over 70 years ago could well have been describing South Africa today when he outlined one of the elements of a revolutionary situation as "a crisis in the policy of the ruling class which causes fissures, through which the discontent and indignation of the oppressed classes burst forth"

The government's trade union reforms represent + just such a "fissure'. The registration of black trade unions has not, as Botha intended, led to a pliant and co-opted labour movement or to the consolidation of a black 'labour aristocracy' On the contrary it has created a space for the opposition to organise and to construct a powerful and militant labour movement.

It is clear that the National Party government has no clear policies and no clear answers. All Botha can offer, right now, is township upgrading' , i.e. small improvements in roads and amenities - plus large scale repression.

In the long term South Africa's racist rulers have to re-order white rule to cope with a skilled black working class and a rising black middle class. In a very general sense they can't go on ruling l'in the old way'. Yet right now it is precisely through ruling 'in the old way' , i.e. through direct and bloody repression, that the regime maintains itself.

Those who argue that the military have already taken over in South Africa are wrong. Yet through the structures of the President's Council, which makes national policy, and the Joint Management Committees, which actually run the black townships, the military has certainly got a larger say in affairs than ever before in South African history. As the South African socialist Duncan Innes has argued: "It is not a long way between the current levels of repression and filling a football stadium full of people."

The dismissal of 16,000 striking railworkers and the shooting dead of six strikers two weeks ago has meant that Botha can project himself as "tough" on the trade unions and therefore, for now, undercut a divided far right.

The struggle townships Since the declaration of the present state of emergency last June there has been a definite downturn in the struggle in the townships. Organisations have been forced underground, street committees are under pressure and murderous black vigilante squads are gaining the upper hand in some areas.

The urban uprising which has swept the country since September 1984 appears to be petering out, the only focus remaining is the rents boycott. The main reason for the decline in the township struggle is crude repression. However the strategy (or rather lack of strategy) of the main forces in the liberation movement has not helped to stop the struggle unwinding and turning in on itself.

Though the African National Congress has around 2,000 cadre inside the country it does not control or direct what goes on. The uprisings have been uncoordinated and isolated. Stratetic switches, like the decision to end the schools boycott, have been difficult to execute.

In part, this is because the ANC uses the struggle to boost itself as the credible black alternative government. As a result it makes different signals to different forces. To the black youth in the townships it is ultra-militant and confrontationist. But it adopts a more disciplined approach when attempting to address more "responsible bodies like the Soweto Parents Crisis Committee. In the same vein, when the ANC want to talk to George Schultz, Joe Slovo (head of the South African Communist Party and until recently leading figure of the ANC's armed wing) announced that he may well have been wrong, Stalin wasn't such a good guy after all, and that maybe there is a "middle road" between repression and revolution in South Africa.

But when they are trying to influence the best activists in the independent trade union movement the SACP stresses its socialist credentials and the 'uninterupted' character of the democratic and socialist revolutions.

The ANC is not about to opt for a Zimbabwe-style Lancaster House agreement with the white regime. But such a deal is by no means ruled out. Large sections of South African capital want such a settlement and forces exist that are organising for it.

Today the black unions are undefeated. Their democratic structures have allowed them to cope with and respond to repression far better than weaker, comunity-based organisations.

Since 1 November last year, when some 300,000 mineworkers took strike action in protest at the Kinross mine disaster, a powerful wave of strike action has been building up. Nearly every important sector of the economy has been affected: the mines, steel, engineering, motor, food, chemicals and retail to name but a few.

Today there are over 24,000 public sector workers on the railways and in the Post Office on strike in the Johannesburg area alone., The trade unions now face a greater threat of repression than ever before.

As the township struggle has declined the unions have become the central focus of opposition, but that also means that the security forces hands are not completely tied down by the township revolt anymore. They can devote more attention to repressing the trade unions.

The priority for the unions at the moment is physical defence. As COSATU has argued: "The attacks are getting so serious, so many people have died, that we must organise self-defence in every workplace and every township to consolidate and protect the gains we have made.?

Scan page 11

Industrial Westminster Councill Sacked miners picket

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 312

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →