[Get your copy! In April 1962, a government…]
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-05-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Get your copy!
In April 1962, a government commission headed by Lord Radcliffe published its findings on the question of state security in the Public Service. The Radcliffe Report expressed concern 'at the number of Communists and communist sympathisers who are holding positions' in the Civil Service unions.
Though massively exaggerated by Radcliffe, the 'left' (in the form of members and contacts of the Communist Party) did hold some positions among the full-time officials of the Civil Service Clerical Association (forerunner of the CPSA). Just how little influence this 'left' had with the ordinary membership of the CSCA was shown at the union's 1963 conference — where a motion authorising the Executive Committee to terminate the contracts of three leftwing officers was carried by a large majority. The motion stated bluntly that the reason was because these officers had been labelled 'security risks'.
Throughout the remainder of the 1960s, the CSCA/CPSA had no left wing that would have been visible to members in the offices, though there were full-time officials and close colleagues who organised against the ruling right wing clique. By 1971, the left — with Tribune-style politics -could get 11 of the 26 seats on the NEC, but still there was no organisalion at the grass roots.
Change
This situation began to change in 1972, when the first open, campaigning left organisation was set up. It called I itself 'Redder Tape' after the union's official journal 'Red Tape'), and the core of this group was the IS (International Socialists, now the Socialist Workers' Party). However, it pulled in wider support - including members of the Communist Party and the Labour left.
At that time, CPSA's constitution had a rule stating that the organisaton or participation in the activities of unofficial committees or similar bodies which seek to influence the policies or electoral processes of the Association, shall be deemed detrimental to the interests of the Association. 'Redder Tape' simply ignored this. It earned itself some influence... and some emnity from union headquarters.
At the 1976 Conference, the rule quoted above was abolished, and both left and right were free to ORGANISER cops did Ulster shoot to kill The Tories new homeless organise openly. The founding conheld in March 1977. ference of an open Broad Left was By this time, Redder Tape was past its heydey, due to the increasingly sectarian attitude of the SWP, a sectarianism that was confirmed by the SWP's refusal to enter the new Broad Left. Instead the SWP continued to run Redder Tape as its own 'front' Some others on the hard left mainrained joint membership of the Broad Left and Redder Tape, arguing in the latter for entry into the Broad Left.
But the SWP were not to be moved.
The Broad Left grew rapidly after its inception, especially in the DHSS.
and Department of Employment.
Politically it embraced all shades from the Communist Party and middle-of-the-road Labour supporters through "Militant' to the smaller revolutionary organisations. No single tendency had control, though some tensions existed between the various factions - held in check both by the urgent need for a united front against the CPSA's vicious right wing, and by an optimism sparked by the Broad Left's swift growth.
Hard In early 1978, a small group of London-based activists set up a hard-left 'Socialist Caucus' within the Broad Left. It included supporters of Socialist Organiser and of some other groups, though many people attracted to the Caucus were not in any organised tendency. The Socialist Caucus began to push issues such as women's rights, which other sections of the Broad Left tended to ignore or pay lip service to.
The left picked up support from its fight for union democracy. With the notable exception of Militant, the whole Broad Left supported a successful campaign to do away with the old system of block votes and replace it by individual ballots at workplace meetings.
Then in 1980, conference passed the principle of membership election of the senior full-time officers (who had previously been appointed without consultation); and in 1981 the necessary constitutional changes to implement this principle were carried. These senior officials were now subject to election every five years. However, after these successes, the cracks in the left began to show, and some of the impetus of earlier years Rates(UK) £8.50 for six months, £16 for a year, Name Address.
Please send me 6/12 months sub. I enclose E. To: Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. John Maureadie. Photo, John Harris was lost.
Some on the left felt tha democracy had now gone far enough:
it was time to start thinking about their own careers and electoral prospects. Militant had grown faster than the other tendencies, and conflict between themselves and the soft left became more apparent: at the same time, both these blocs were content to see the Broad Left become more of an electoral machine.
There were Broad Left majorities on the National Executives of 1979-80, and again in 1982-3, and winning elections was becoming the priority for many leftists. But when the Broad Left was in power, it often failed the membership.
In late 1982, Oxford and Birmingham DHSS offices struck for increased staffing. Instead of giving a strong lead to these struggles, the Broad Left NEC twice recommended a settlement on a pathetic offer from management. The basic argument of Militant (by then very influential in the Broad Left was that it was the wrong time and wrong issue for a fight...'save the union's strength for the 1983 pay campaign' : In other words, the same approach and same arguments that have always been used by bureaucrats to stave off rank and file action.
But the November 1982 Broad Left conference refused to condemn the NEC's actions over the Oxford/Birmingham dispute.
Tensions
By 1984, internal tensions in the Broad Left reached a critical level, and rumours began to circulate about an impending split. Two events then took place which were rendered almost comic by their ironic coincidence. Redder Tape had folded enclose £.. To: ndon SE15 4NA.
some time before, and the SWP had been declining as a visible force in the CPSA. The SWP suddenly joined the Broad Left...just in time to see the Kinnockites and the Communist Party depart! In a carefully pre-arranged walk-out at the very start of the 1984 Broad Left conference, these elements left to set up the group called "Broad Left '84"
The excuse used by this group for leaving was the heavy-handed domination of conference that had then been achieved by Militant, an argument that carried some weight with activists. However, it did not take long for BL'84's real face to appear. Attacks on Militant's style and tactics soon developed into a blanket condemnation of the hard left. In short, it became a Trot-bashing organisation guaranteed to warm Kinnock's heart. Radical policies were ditched in favour of a 'realism' that had a lot to do with furthering a cosy relationship with the bureaucracy.
Split
The split in the left was followed quite shortly by a split in CPSA's right. A group calling themselves the Democratic Moderates pulled out of the National Moderate Group, repeating the accounts of the latter's corruption and undemocratic workings that the left had been making for years. To date, however, this new group has achieved little electoral support.
So what is the position within the CPSA and its Broad Left now? Since the left split, the right wing have won the 1985 and 1986 elections to the NEC. But despite attacks from the media, the 'Moderates' and BL'84, the Broad Left has remained more influential than its soft-left rival. For example, in the recent election for CPSA's General Secretary, John Macreadie (a well known supporter of Militant) gained 20,424 votes compared to 14,740 votes for Geoff Lewtas of BL'84. Militant remain the single biggest tendency in the Broad Left, but there has been growth of an opposition.
The SWP have increased their influence since entering the Broad Left, but many long-time activists view them with suspicion (or derision!) because of their frequent 'turns'most recently, their approaches to Militant for unity: curtly rebuffed, and now abandoned.
Socialist Organiser, working with other activists and groups in the Socialist Caucus, tries to build a campaigning organisation that combines a rank and file approach with consislent, principled policies.
Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty, East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight to replace capitalism with working class socialism.
We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.
Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers.
We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwide, including the struggle of workers and oppressed nationalities in the Stalinist states against their own anti-socialist bureaucracies.
For full equality for women, and social provision to free women from the burden of housework. For a mass working class based women's movement.
Against racism, and against deportations and all immigration controls.
For equality for lesbians and gays.
For a united and free Ireland, with some federal system to protect the rights of the Protestant minority.
For left unity in action; clarity in debate and discussion.
For a labour movement accessible to the most oppressed, accountable to its rank and file, and militant against capitalism, We want Labour Party and trade union members who support our basic ideas to become supporters of the paper — to take a bundle of papers to sell each week and pay a small contribution to help meet the paper's deficit. Our policy is democratically controlled by our supporters through Annual General Meetings and an elected National Editorial Board.
What they are and what they must become Socialist Organiser A detailed account of the struggle by the NCU (then POEU) against privatisation of British Telecom and against Project Mercury when the Broad Left got a majority on the union's National Executive in June 1983 concludes: "For any trade union caucus, electoralism, the practice of struggling to gain leadership positions, is necessary. But when it becomes, however subconsciously, the exclusive or main priority, it can lead to fatal errors...
And a survey of the history of the CPSA Broad Left concludes by stressing "the need for much more political clarification within the Broad Lefts" and the need to combat "a routinism where positions in the union loom larger than the Available for 35p plus postage from SO, PO Box London SE15 4NA.
Scan page 9
ISMaIaM
It's not easy to describe Crimes of the Heart. I laughed till I cried in parts of it, so I'm sure it's funny, but it doesn't really have any plot to speak of. You'd have to tell the whole film, funny bits and all, to give a sense of what it is like. And that would spoil it!
So, I'll tell a little, and leave it to you to find out the rest when you go to see it. It's a big star movie. Jessica Lange, Diane Keaton and Sissy Spacek play three sisters from Hazlehurst, Mississippi, a small Southern town.
The girls grew up under a cloud — cheir father was a stinker, their mother achieved notoriety in the national press when she hanged herself and her cat. The girls grew up under the domination of Ol' Grandaddy, a bullying type who wanted to dictate the girls" lives to them.
Maidish
Oldest sister Lenny, played by Keaton, has become shy and old maidish and, at thirty, has donned the gardening hat and gloves of their grandma. Meg (Lange) started drinking and going wild after finding their hanged mother. She left town to follow a singing career, pushed into it by Ol' Grandaddy. Babe (Spacek) stayed and married a bullying senator.
It is Babe's trouble that starts the film. She has shot her husband. He isn't dead, but he's mighty mad, and determined to make Babe pay. He doesn't want to send her to jail (think of his career!) but he is thinking of having her 'put away' in an asylum.
Babe returns to the family home in her time of trouble, and she is joined there by Meg, summoned back by Lenny. The three girls or rather women, though they act so much like little girls that it is hard to think of them as grown up) are alone in the house — Ol' Grandaddy is ill in hospital.
Once reunited, the sisters' old childhood rivalries and antagonisms come out, as does their affection for each other as well. Each sister has been frustrated in life, through following her grandfather's wishes rather than her own. Without the bullying presence of the grandfather, the girls act more freely, and through the bonds they re-forge, each finds the strength to override the past and change her course in life.
That might sound soppy, but it isn't. The film is so full of odd behaviour played absolutely straight Why is the Jessica Lange that you find yourself laughing all the way through, even at such wildly inappropriate things like skin diseases and Grandaddy's coma.
Each sister has her quirks and oddities. Lenny has become shy and frightened of life because she has a shrunken ovary. Ol' Grandaddy has convinced her she'll never get a husband. Meg took to staring at pictures of skin diseases and cripples to prove how tough and unfeeling she was. Babe, the most wacky of them all, Is terrified of going crazy, like their mother.
Babe keeps an album full of piccures of all the sad things in her life, rather than the happy things - it's more like life that way.
The film is only about the sisters it wobbles a bit when other characters take the centre. Keaton, Lange and Spacek play their roles with such gusto, and such feeling for the oddities of each sister, that you are carred along, believing in them. It's only later that you realise their achievement - because there is no real plot, no story, just the actresses living their roles with conviction.
In our industrial society, attention has been increasingly ed on the effects of metal pollution on people.
Substances like lead, cadmium and mercury are known to cause nasty ilInesses in large amounts but what about the effects of small amounts on such sensitive individuals as babies?
Do many apparently normal newborn babies actually bear the evidence of mild poisoning by say, lead?
Small effects can more easily be detected statistically. Large numbers of babies need to be examined to see how much of the pollutant they have in their bodies. The results are compared with such factors as birthweight which may be evidence of illeffects.
Surprisingly, such work has only just been done though the debate on lead has been going on for years. A survey of 100 live births in Barnsley showed a clear link between high levels of lead and cadmium in the body and low birth weight. This would seem to indicate that the development of such babies had been slowed down. Such babies tend to be at more risk of illness and death.
A possible explanation of this effect is provided by another finding. Levels of zinc in such babies were also lower. Now, zine is an essential element for normal growth and health, but, in the presence of the lead and cadmium, the body cannot absorb as much as it needs. One way of counteracting this problem might be to monitor lead and cadmium in pregnant women and given them extra zinc. A better way, however, would be to cut out lead and cadmium pollution. But that might interfere with profits.
NEW GROUND The Spring issue of the green socialist magazine New Ground carries several articles of interest to SO readers.
On public health there is an indictment of the appalling state of British beaches. These are frequently polluted with "faecal solids" released from sewage pipes either too short or damaged. This is against European Community law but to get round this and thus save money the Thatcher government simply refuses to designate such places as Blackpool as an area where bathing is traditionally practised"
The result is a serious risk to bathers of diseases such as diarrhoea, hepatitis and polio. The article includes a form of complaint to be sent to the European Commission if your favourite beach is also "undesignated"
Also on public health is a report on Northern Ireland, detailing some of the environmental insults the people have to endure. In one West Belfast estate, dampness and faulty sewers caused many cases of gastro-enteritis, hepatitis, chest diseases and polio. These were initially blamed on the
----- pull-quotes -----
Britains death squad exposed!
The Broad Lefts
reviews 'Crimes of the Heart'
Hobsbawm and Pollution