Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Make CPSA serve the majority

Socialist Organiser no. 312, 7 May 1987 · scan p. 6 · about 1,310 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

THE FIGHT STIL STIL FOR CAML SERVANTS POIN S. всна : demo, Chel Harris The majority of the CPSA's members are women yet the majority of union officials are men. The CPSA has its token "Thatcher" figures - Marion Chambers (President) and Kate Losinska (Vice-president) but these two, on the right of the CPSA, have done nothing to further the interests of women members.

The Stalinist/Kinnockite alliance grouping Broad Left '84 have always maintained that they are at the forefront of the fight for women members interests and rights. But what have they done?

*They have paid lip-service to demands such as work-place creches, then have done nothing about it.

*They have feigned great concern for pregnant women, then have sold them down the river with a new technology agreement which does not provide automatic protection for pregnant women on visual display units. *They stand women candidates in elections, shouting loudly about the lack of women officials - but make no effort to ensure that the union is al habitable place for women members.

*They make a big noise about the need for women-only schools - then FIGHT GOES ON GOES ON argue against them against the law"

When they split from the Broad Left, BL '84 were able to win support from women who had had enough of Militant's often sexist and bullying attitude towards women in general — and particularly towards those who wished to organise autonomously within the Broad Left and the CPSA. However, it did not take long for many women to realise that it was mere opportunism which motivated BL'84 and that they are a sham as far as furthering the interests of women members is concerned.

The majority grouping in the CPSA Broad Left - Militant - has an appalling record as far as issues affecting women are concerned. Militant supporters are totally opposed to the self-organisation of working class women within the class. They argue that the autonomous organisation of women is "divisive" and splits the class along the lines of sex.

Militant's politics in this area oversimplified, undemocratic, opportunist and wrong.

Women Against Pit Closures STILL glowing example of autonomous organisation actually strengthens the class. The pit women, ofte backbone of the strike, w give practical and political the striking miners. They themselves politically and to challenge the sexism of men. Women Against P was not divisive.

In fact Militant suppor tive in Labour Party wc tions, yet they oppose the of Broad Left women's g The effect of these politics has been that the pays little real attention blems of women member to stand up at a meeting loudly about abortion i and low pay. It is much ficult to actually convince union members that they only take these and o seriously, but also change ing and behaviour in ord the union is habitable members.

Militant believe that or how the of women • working n called the ere able to support to developed were able the mining it Closures ters are ac›men's sece setting up roups.

mistaken Broad Left to the pro's. It is easy , and shout ights, rape 1 more dil: male trade should not ther issues their thinker to ensure for women ice a man is STIL supporter he will automatically become non-sexist, non-racist, nonhomophobic, etc. Militant refuse to recognise that a working class man can actually benefit from women's oppression under capitalism. He will come home from a hard day and home is a refuge from work. She will come home after a hard day in the typing pool - and carry on working as an unpaid domestic and childminder!

Militant also refuse fo examine and consider the profound and often subtle way by which capitalist society oppresses women, through religion, education, ideology and socialisation. How many times have you heard an up-front woman trade unionist described as "pushy"? How often have you heard "she only got that position because she slept with the right person.

CPSA women's groups need to be set up as a matter of urgency. They will provide a forum for women to voice their opinions, they will give women collective strength to fight against male chauvinism in the union, and they will help to ensure that issues specifically aftecting women members are raised.

Militant's opposition to the self-organisation of oppressed groups is based on a typically oversimplified view. The bosses are our biggest FIGHTINE LON enemy, so the thinking goes, therefore we must forget all our differences and unite behind the banner of the working class. Yes, we must unite as a class. But that will only be a sham of unity unless the different sections of the working class are able to understand the problems of the others.

At Broad Left conference in 1986, supporters who proposed the setting up of Broad Left women's groups were heckled. Those who dared to suggest that men in the Broad Left might be sexist received a torrent off abuse.

The motion was passed due to a change in line from the Socialist Workers Party. However it has only been put into practice in non-Militant Broad Left branches.

The last period. has seen numerous attacks by Thatcher on women workers. The latest of these is the new maternity legislation implemented from 6 April this year. This legislation attacks the maternity rights fought for and won by women oyer the years.

There has hardly been a murmur in the CPSA about this issue. It would have been a golden opportunity for the Broad Left to organise workers in conjunction with groups such as Maternity Action. But the opportunity was missed.

Within the • Broad Left, Militant supporters say that they don't support "women's groups" but they do address the "here and now" problems experienced by women workers. But the plain truth of the matter is that they don't. Militant supporters shout loudly but do not organise members at a rank and file level. For them the Broad Left is an electoral machine.

Opposed

Militant supporters are totally opposed to reserved places for women on the National Executive Committee of the CPSA. They argue that "voting for a woman because she is a woman" is "insulting"

The demand for reserved places is based on the fact that the proportion of women on committees, nationally and at other levels, is much smaller than the proportion of women in the CPSA as a whole. This is for a number of reasons: women's position in society as a whole; the sexist and bureaucratic nature of trade unions (including the CPSA), so that many women do not have the confidence to come forward; and women's childcare responsibilities which prevent their attendance at meetings outside working hours. Fear of travelling alone after dark prevents other women from coming to meetings.

The demand for reserved seats is not an answer to these problems. But it does go some way to recognising them. It would ensure that the various factions in the CPSA would stand a certain number of women who might otherwise be passed over in favour of men. It would mean members would vote for a woman they agreed with politically, but who might have less experience or be less "up-front" than a man in her particular faction.

The introduction of new technology (visual display units, word processors, etc), among CPSA grades in the civil service affects all members in terms of worsening conditions and job losses. It particularly affects women members who tend to be those most likely to work with new technology and are most affected in terms of health and safety.

Last year a new technology agreement was presented to the members by the right wing dominated NEC. It was supported by "The Moderates"

and "Broad Left '84", and opposed by the Broad Left.

It did not give

----- pull-quotes -----

CIVIL RIGHTS GCHIQ. TRADE UNIONS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 312

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →