Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists and teachers E-DEPLOYMENT

Socialist Organiser no. 311, 30 April 1987 · scan pp. 10–11 · Penny Barnett · about 3,096 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

YEAR OF REVOLUITIOF April The Petrograd Soviet issues two appeals: to the socialists of all countries, appealing for support for Russian democracy; and to the army, appealing for preparations for an offensive. The founding meeting in Petrograd of a trade union for coopers passes a resolution of no confidence in the Provisional Government. The first meeting of the Centrobalt is held in Helsingfors. On the Northern front the first issue of "Okornaya (Trenches) Pravda appears. The Vladimir Soviet resolves that no troops will be dispatched from the garrison to the front without the permission of the Moscow and Petrograd Soviets. At a meeting of the army chiefsof-staff in Mogilev, Miliukov calls for the speediest possible mounting of an offensive as a means of "curing the country and, in particular, the capital." Attempts at fraternisation on the South-western front are prevented by Russian artillery fire. A pro-monarchist demonstration in Kiev, under the slogan 'Long live a Constitutional Monarchy is broken up by soldiers.

Monday 1 An extraordinary meeting of the Petrograd Soviet Executive Committee discusses the question of a coalition government and resolves by 44 votes to 19 with two abstentions to send representatives into the Provisional Government. A plenary session of the Moscow regional bureau of soviets opens in Moscow, attended by 34 delegates; it votes in support of a coalition Provisional Government.

The factory committee of the Kazan chemical factory resolves to introduce a six-hour working day for workers in hazardous working conditions, and to introduce eight weeks' maternity leave for women. In Urzhum, peasants led by soldiers arrest local bureacrats and factory-owners. In some smaller towns and villages the day is celebrated as a holiday. Tuesday 2 May Negotiations open between the Provisional Government and representatives of the Petrograd Soviet about the formation of a coalition government. An extraordinary meeting of the Petrograd Soviet held in the evening votes to approve entry into the Provisional Government. At a meeting of the Moscow Soviet of workers' deputies, speakers from the Black Sea fleet and the Sevastopol garrison call for continuation of the war until victory. A meeting of workers from twelve small Moscow factories replace their delegate to the Moscow Soviet after he votes for the "freedom loan" . On the South-western front soldiers vote to send troops 10 Petrograd to defend the gains of the revolution. On the Rumanian front the first issue of "Soldier-Citizen" appears, produced by the army committee of the soviet of officers' and soldiers' deputies; of its three editors, one is a general and another is a colonel.

Wednesday 3 May Negotiations continue between representatives of the Provisional Government and the Petrograd Soviet of workers' and soldiers' deputies about the formation of a coalition government. The bureau of the all-Russian Soviet of peasant deputies supports the formation of a coalition government and sends delegates to the negotiations.

A 2,500 strong mass meeting of workers of the Petrograd United Cables Works condemns the formation of a coalition government and calls for all power to be transferred to the soviets. The Soviet of military deputies of the Kiev military zone welcomes the formation of a coalition government A general meeting of the Archangelsk garrison demands the shutting down of the defencist "Soldier-Citizen" newspaper. A joint meeting of the Orechnvozuyev Soviet and the Vladimir and Pokrov Soviets of soldiers' deputies warns local textile factory owners that unless they meet their workers' economic demands, their factories will be placed under workers' control. Liam Conway starts a discussion on the education system and socialism After reading Tracy Williams' article the other week about her experience of teachers in secondary schools I began to think about the way socialists perceive certain groups of workers.

My own experience of Secondary Modern School was very similar to Tracy's. It was a Catholic school where half the teachers were nuns, and many of the others petty tyrants. My decision to become a teacher was based on the naive assumption that I could do it better, that I could change the world through teaching.

However, becoming a teacher has altered my perspective somewhat about teachers and education. It is not that all teachers are enlighened socialists practising socialist values in education (although there are more than you might think), but simply that teachers are workers doing a difficult and stressful job.

Yes some teachers victimise children, have racist values, see themselves as middle class, etc., but so do many other groups of workers. What matters is the objective reality of any group of workers in relation to capitalism.

Teachers are just as prone to attacks and cuts by capitalists as any workers and the coming period may tragically make this clear. They may be better paid than average but so were some of those on strike at Wapping.

The bottom line should be that we see teachers as workers and tackle their shortcomings like revolutionaries seeking to patiently explain.

In any case, if teachers victimise they are also often victims themselves. One of our own comrades was recently one such victim.

He was asked by students to state whether or not he was gay. Rightly or wrongly he chose to say that this was a private matter, but that he defended the rights of gays and lesbians, and had attended demonstrations to show his support. Unhappy with this response the students mounted a vicious campaign of abuse against him. This campaign lasted for several We discussed the incident in the Socialist Teachers Group and agreed that the best solution was open discussion with the students - no heavy discipline or tokenistic assemblies, but free speech for sides. The victimisation ended after the discussion but the students were not convinced about gay rights.

However, it might not have ended there. What if the harassment had continued? Should teachers have to put up with this type of abuse indefinitely? Is any action against such students simply teachers acting as state police officers?

Clearly the answers are not easy within a capitalist system. But socialists should analyse these and other events independently, from a principled position. Otherwise the result is inconsistency - like defending McGoldrick against Brent Council but not the Poundswick teachers against racist personal abuse from students.

Socialists should build bridges from themselves to all workers. It strikes me that few socialists have attempted to cross this bridge to see how teachers work, especially in primary and secondary schools where they are in direct contact with work. Schools of struggle? Photo Moniqur ing class youth. This results in letting the Tories have it their own way in any debate about education.

Whilst the Labour leadership ignores educational content, and the hierarchical structure of the service and promises only to spend a little extra money, the left withdraws from the arena on the grounds that little can be done under capitalism. The Tories are less naive. They hate the thought of working class kids having contact with education, especially if this goes beyond the 3 Rs, strict uniform and military discipline, Education was fine if it stayed within the limits of cannon fodder for capitalism. 'Liberal' education of a type was OK at university or polytechnic where the effect was limited. The numbers being educated in higher education were small enough so it was safe and fairly cheap to allow small discussion groups, one-to-one tuition and even a little debate about controversial issues.

Tories At school this was not the case. The Tories have consistently sought to undermine the comprehensive system, not because going comprehensive meant anything in itself but because it heralded another more dangerous potential. Linked with comprehensives was the idea of mixed-group teaching - race, class, literacy, disability etc., would not be excuses to split students up. Throw in small class sizes of under 15 and 'controversial' subjects discussed in an open way, like class, racism, sexism, even Marxism - in tact anything connected with this reality kids had to face — and you had a combination the Tories felt threatened by:

It might be said that these progressive developments are meaningless as part of the fight against capitalism, but some points are worth considering. e Blanchet (Report)

Little radical came out of school udents belore comprenensives, even the '30s. The relatively open atosphere in comprehensives has lade some contribution to the forlation of school student unions. low many of us could seriously gue that smaller classes, radical ducation and mixed groups would ot accelerate the growth of school udent unions?

And what about the teachers? ven right wing teachers recognise le difference between groups of 30 nd groups of 12. When you have a lixed group of 30 it is significantly ifferent from 30 'O' level students. It a potentially antagonistic group, here differences can explode. Teachers can be forced against leir will to use neanderthal teaching ethods just to survive with their erves intact. Anyone who has been 1 this situation understands this.

But a group of 12 mixed students is different world - it can be made scially cohesive, students can and till learn to live with each other and › learn from each other. The feeling f us and them is taken out of the tuation and the teacher merges into le class and the educational process:

Socialists should fight for such hanges as we should seek to raise the onsciousness of workers as early as ossible, thereby preparing them for neir role in the class struggle. Take the case of our comrade gain. Surely he would have been beter able to fight racism, sexism and nti-gay hysteria if the atmosphere in lass and school was less oppressive. ind if he was able to do this ouldn't this make at least a partial ontribution towards working class nity, if only by counteracting the efect of capitalist media on children.

The Tories' attack on schools is ot just about funding. The implicaons of smaller classes go far beyond s cost. That is why Baker has linked is attack on teachers to a return to ne 3Rs, selective education and paylent by results.

The Tories want teachers and students to be passive, to fulfill their role for capitalism. Baker's attempts to tie teachers down to a rigid contract that will increase contact time with students, give more power to heads and introduce 'thought control' appraisal are all linked to this objective If teachers have no time away from students, then how can they prepare new ideas to pervert the children with? Better still, if teachers have a rigid contract how will they take effective action for a better, more radical and well funded education service?

And if the students are in large, badly resourced classes they will learn to hate teachers, minorities, each other and anything except the system that oppresses them along with the rest of us. Teachers in this situation will see the kids as the enemy and revert to reactionary teaching methods. The whole atmosphere will be repressive, education will suffer and the Tories will be able to gloat about the failure of the comprehensive system.

Finally with everyone knowing their place in the educational rat race and incapable of mounting united opposition, the Tories will be able to privatise the whole system without so much as a whimper from those involved.

This strikes me as the reality of the current situation. Socialists should learn to handle this reality and develop a strategy for dealing with it.

We should not look at schools as containing oppressed and oppressors, goodies and baddies, students and teachers. We do not do this when we look at the world at large.

Instead we should pose a transitional programme for education, one that will improve the conditions for our purposes. Otherwise we spout knee-jerk, emotional responses which leave schools outside our struggle and often alienate those within schools whose support we need to enlist.

Scan page 11

Civil service pay fight continues There is no clear cut answer to this with a company that manufactures question and a wide range of views is cars or packs toilet rolls, but with an held on the left in the unions. The organisation that daily pays out the eft loses out • Industriall The two largest civil service unions are now into their fourth week of rolling strike action. An all-out strike now looks more likely than at any time in the union's history. This means that the thorny problem of emergency payments to benefits claimants in The I THE LEFT was unsuccessful on every major vote at the National Union of Teachers (NUT) conterence.

We were unable to get a fair hearing for the eight Inner London Teachers' Association (ILTA) officers who were expelled and suspended from the union for their vigorous campaign against the conditions imposed on teachers by Tory Education minister Kenneth Baker.

A motion calling for total non-compliance with Baker and escalating strike action was defeated. The famous ILTA motion calling for immediate 'no cover' for absences was narrowly voted out after pretty suspicious delaying tactics by the executive.

However, the conference was by no means all a failure for the left. The Socialist Teachers' Alliance (STA) conducted a daily campaign on the ground, and many delegates were convinced by the arguments.

London the event of such a strike is agenda again.

NUT conference eft i Liam Conway reports on NUT conference The defeats at conference are not ones from which the left cannot recover, despite the work and conditions most teachers will face after the Easter holiday.

The STA must continue campaigning among the members. Our task will be to stop demoralisation, lift up the heads of the members, and point their eyes in the direction of those who sold out all their conditions of service.

This means a campaign against both the NUT executive and those local leaders whose votes condemned teachers to the Baker Act.

In Liverpool, Manchester, Sheffield, Birmingham, Derby, Nottingham, and many other towns and cities, teachers on the left who wanted to fight Baker must be mobilised against the time-servers Buses starting point for many is the fairly narrow trade union view that in a civil servants' strike, as in action by more traditional industrial unions, to allow any of your duties to be carried out is scabbing on your own strike.

Unfortunately we are not dealing and bureaucrats, This task will primarily fall on the STA. The STA must concentrate its mind on the major questions confronting teachers in the aftermath of the Baker Act. This means providing the political leadership for all those prepared to continue the fight against Baker and the Tories.

We must forge a united front against the national executive's defeatist strategy. Such a united front can only be successful if we are not diverted by sectarian politics and unprincipled use of the capitalist courts. It means building and rebuilding strong local groups of the STA.

It means continuing to work through the Local Association Pay and Conditions Campaign, LAPACC, an organisation capable of providing the STA with a much wider audience for its ideas.

And it means using the ILTA 8 Defence Campaign as a means to get into every association [NUT branch] in the country, defending the ILTA officers and arguing on a wider political front. It is vital that the lett is politically strong, well-organised only income received by millions of people living in poverty in this country. That fact won't go away and socialists should think through the implications of all-out strike now.

It is important right from the start to separate out the arguments. The basis for the discussion is a whole hearted recognition of the right of those in social security offices, along with health workers, residential social workers, etc., to strike - full support for their action to improve pay and conditions and build their strength and militancy. But from that basis socialists in the movement need to examine ways of directing the full force of that action at the employers, minimising the damage done to, in this case, the poorest and least organised section of our class.

In recent discussions among the left in the Civil Service unions, three main positions emerged.

1. That no emergency payments should be made at all, and that NALGO members in social services should be asked to boycott any such work they are asked to do.

This is obviously unacceptable from a trade union and socialist viewpoint. The idea that food riots on the streets of Britain would quickly cause the government to crumble relies on the Tories being more sensitive to the plight of the poorest than workers are, and anyway it is hardly the way to build solidarity across the labour movement.

From a purely trade union point of view the millions saved in unpaid benefits could go a long way to undermining the effectiveness of action in the revenue collecting departments, e.g. Customs and Excise.

That emergency payments should be made by local councils via NALGO members in social services, very limited powers to pay our money. They are already hard pressed and would be simply swamped from day one. In fact the likeliest scenario is that they too would be pushed into taking industrial action against the intolerable pressure, and while any escalation of the action by civil servants would be desirable, it does rather defeat the object as far as emergency payments is concerned.

Local centres for the unemployed could find themselves in an even worse position - even assuming a sympathetic local council stumped up the cash. Could we seriously expect three or four workers in a centre to make hardship payments to thousands of claimants?

Except in some very well organised areas, this is unlikely to be a practical proposal.

3. That emergency payments should be made by DHSS offices. under union control. Just as health workers established rotas for emergency cover during their dispute, it should be possible for strikers to establish rotas for teams to go into local DHSS offices soley for the purpose of providing an emergency service.

The teams would obviously refuse to work alongside scabs and would greatly marginalise them.

Action like this, far from prolonging the dispute, would make it easier to get the support and involvement of claimants and unemployed workers and to build the sort of solidarity action from other unions that would help bring it to a speedy conclusion.

It would have the additional effect of boosting the confidence of the strikers in their ability to challenge "management's right to manage" and to resist the introduction of anticlaimant legislation like the recent

----- pull-quotes -----

SCPS (personal capacity).

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 311

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →