Mud, rain, blood, death and terror
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
*Platoon', in addition to receiv; ing 4 Oscars, has received quite a lot of stick.
London's City Limits commented disapprovingly, "those who happen to think war glorious won't find much to contradict them here." And many critics have pointed out that its story is built around a good-soldier vs. bad-soldier whilst boy-becomesman cliche, and that the Vietnamese are, all just enemies in the jungle or passive victims.
Others have even decided PlaEdward Ellis reviews general release toon' is ordinary, run-of-the-mill uninteresting.
All of these criticisms are baffling. "Platoon' in fact is a brilliant indictment of the Vietnam war, which from start to finish is terrifying, distressing and deeply moving.
Director Oliver Stone, himself a Vietnam veteran, set out to recapture what it was really like in the war. He tells it through the eyes of a single platoon at the turn of 1967-8, just as the war was reaching its peak.
This appreach does impose certain limitations. It is true that the viewpoint is that of an American; the Vietnamese do not feature as individual characters. It is not, therefore, rounded-out history or political analysis.
But it was not meant to be, It is a film above all about disillusionment, about the discovery not only that war is horrible, bloody and dangerous, but that that this war is also both futile and wrong. The 'defend our way of life' idealism of volunteer GI (Charlie Sheen) gives way first to a mind-numbed survival instinct, and then to depression and despair.
There is no implicit racism in the exclusion of the Vietnamese from the centre of the plot. It is not illegitimate for a film maker to focus on a particular side to question - the perceptions of American troops in this case — and that is what 'Platoon' does.
It is extremely real and believable horribly so. The war consists of mud and rain, insects, pain, blood and death. It is above all terrifying. -Pain and death are portrayed with greater realism than in any film I have seen, and so it is more tense, frightening and upsetting than the most effective horror film.
It is all upsetting: from the US ambush on the Vietnamese in the jungle, to the violent destruction of a Vietnamese village, to the hopeless battle at the film's climax.
Of course, our immediate sympathies are with the American soldiers - mostly from the bottom of the social pile, dragooned into the army, poor kids who want to go home. But the film evokes no malice towards 'the enemy' . The Americans are dying because they shouldn't be in there in the first place: all this death is their fault.
News on Sunday seemed to think the message of the film is that Americans spent too much time fighting eachother and not enough fighting the enemy - an idiotic interpretation that bodes ill for the paper's future as an intelligent tribune. City Limits, to come back to them, argues that we are not meant to identify with the Vietnamese villagers that are brutalised by the Americans, but with the Gls who are horrified by what is happening. The City Limits reviewer should speak for himself. I certainly felt moved for the sake of the villagers.
Platoon is a very fine film. As a film about the Vietnam war it is unequalled. As an emotionally effective work of art, also, it is second to none. the women say that they never thought they would be prostitutes. The same was true of the women in the documentary:
Lorraine and Tracy, 19 and 15 respectively, led us through a grim scenario of their lives. Both women had come from homes where their father beat them. Both had been in care and run away. Tracy had been in 1l different homes in five years.
When you run away from home at 15, it's impossible to sign on or find a job, so how do you make ends meet? Prostitution, to them, was puręly economic.
Fears
They could get t10 for jerking a man off, and £20 for penetration in the back of a car.
Both talked about their fears of being beaten, mugged, kidnapped or raped by their clients. But they have no choice. Their other biggest fear, of course, was the police and the courts. It's a vicious circle, because the courts impose fines, and you resort to prostitution again to pay the fine.
Some call-girls or hostesses can make £100 or £300 a night if they get the right client, i.e. rich and kinky. But for the street girls it is a different matter.
The programme raised many issues about prostitution. How do we define prostitution? Someone who sells their body for sex? Someone who sells their body full stop? If the latter definition is true, would this mean that fashion models are prostitutes, or page 3 women are prostitutes, or even that Madonna Is a prostitute?
Do we treat prostitution as labout power? If so, do we unionise prostitution? Or do we rather try to look at men and women and sex?
Until women have economic freedom and ideological freedom from their families or their husbands, they will continue to earn money on the streets or in the hotel rooms. Men will continue to kerb-crawl and harass every woman in sight, be they six or 96, and women will continue to be burned out of their houses because their neighbours know 'what they are'.
*We may be your next-door neighbour, your daughter, your sister, your mother. Maybe you never knew that some of your best friends are pros".
ser na 311 30. APr ril 19% page