Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Hobsbawm's scab policies are nothing new

Socialist Organiser no. 311, 30 April 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 550 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

is anti-Thatcherite. "Tactical voting' means foreswearing anti-capitalist policies — and not only for the coming election, perhaps torever.

The Popular Frontists want Labour to accept the Alliance at its present level of support as a permanent feature of British politics. Instead of fighting it, we must ally with it, block electorally with it, and let it set the limit to what the Labour Party can even aspire to do.

Wrapped up in the 'emergency' motivation for the Popular Front is something far deeper: a historic surrender to the forces of capitalist society by the labour movement.

Historic

Hobsbawm advocates a British version of the traitorous policy of the Italian Communist Party, which a decade ago offered, in the name of the Italian working class, a 'historic compromise' to the conservative Christian Democratic party.

Of course Neil Kinnock and the present leaders of the Labour Party are, in our view, far from having policies adequate to the task of sorting out Britain after Thatcher's Marxism MON FATH May 1982959 emabyl and Eric Hobsbawm:

There is only one placed to keep out the *xism special THE scab policies now being pushed by Eric Hobsbawm and the Communist Party aren't new. They had the same line in the '30s and '40s.

In the late '30s they argued that what was needed was not a Labour government but a 'Popular Front' government - Labour, CP and... Liberals! When the wartime coalition broke up in mid-1945, and Labour decided to ask the electorate for a majority in the general election, the then influential and sizeable CP was bitterly against it.

Labour should stick with the 'progressive Tories' like Churchill and Anthony Eden, said the CP! Labour won by a landslide.

There is a difference between the old Popular Front and Hobsbawm's idea of it today. In the past the CP was guided by Russia's foreign policy needs - in 1945, by Churchill's wartime alliance with the USSR.

Today it is not Russian foreign policy interests that guide them (otherwise they would follow Gorbachev into supporting Margaret That cher!). What determines their line now iş their own political prostration.

My only real complaint concerns the front page lead - the piece about a young Brazilian who had offered his kidney for sale because of desperate poverty. A most disturbing story, certainly. But the next day's Independent led on Peter Wright's revelations about the MIS plot to overthrow the Wilson government in 1974.

This story has been known to journalists for some time, and the NoS must have been aware of it. The Observer and the Guardian intended to splash it, but were silenced by injunctions from the government.

Guts

Papers like Socialist Organiser and Socialist Worker have reported it. Finally the Independent had the guts to publish and be damned.

Was it cowardice or stupidity that led the NoS to ignore what should have been the perfect lead story for their launch issue?

That said, I wish the News on Sunday well. They've got a tough job ahead, and need to sell 800,000 copies a week within two years to survive. I'll keep buying it, and I hope you do as well.

Scan page 4

Letters

----- pull-quotes -----

way of defeating the Thatcher government. I is by voting for the candidate who is best

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 311

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →