Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Kinnock and Hattersley at Labour's Red Rose Rally…]

Socialist Organiser no. 311, 30 April 1987 · scan p. 3 · about 782 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Kinnock and Hattersley at Labour's Red Rose Rally in Northampton THE CENTRAL argument of Eric Hobsbawm and others who favour 'tactical' voting is this: what is the alternative?

They say that there is no other alternative to a Thatcher victory in the coming general election but a pact to exchange votes between the Labour Party and the SDP-Liberal As Hobsbawm puts it in the May edition of the curiously-named magazine 'Marxism Today': "The defeat of the Tory government is the essential task in British politics, and should have absolute priority over aim other aim and political calculaHobsbawm admits that there is no chance that either the Alliance or the Labour leaders will call for tactical voting. He concludes that people should just go ahead and do it - the 'Popular Front' from below, so to speak.

If it can be taken for granted that the readers of 'Marxism Today' are natural Labour voters, and that quite a lot of them live in prosperous middle-class areas, then the main burden of Hobsbawm's message to them is: 'Vote SDP-Liberal And thus the grotesquely misnamed 'Communist Party' draws out the full logic of its politics to the muddy dregs.

Quite apart from any consideration of principle, the campaign for "tactical voting' now being waged by a gaggle of right-wing writers, ranging from the Communist Party and 'Marxism Today' to the editor of the 'New Statesman', can only bring an added dimension of chaos and confusion into the Labour camp. As if the Labour leaders weren't already making a big enough mess of things, these Marxists' are now doing what they can to sabotage Labour's election campaign.

Principle

The main argument against a Labour block with the SDP-Liberal Alliance is, however, a matter of principle. The question posed to the labour movement and the Labour Party by the advocates of a new Popular Front is nothing less than fundamental: to be or not to be.

Any political block of the Labour Party with the bourgeois Alliance will give the Alliance veto rights to determine what a Labour-led government can and cannot do. Defeating the Tories is of course 'essential' - but so is having an alternative to Toryism.

PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 01-639 7965 atesy date for sponsees postiMonday orphone, Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony.

(TU).

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. rinted by est EndORset TUNILONdOnER. jegistered as антемерирет the Post Office. igned asticleçmomen necessarily reflect the views of SocialistUrgamiser.Cagnoni, Report.

The new 'Popular Front'ists have only half the picture. If defeating the Tories is 'first" ', what is second? They propose to bring down Thatcher (assuming their tactics work) at the cost of the labour movement foreswearing the fight for a real alternative to Thatcherism.

Is David Owen — or a Labour or Labour-led government acceptable to David Owen - an alternative to Thatcherism? Or Thatcher's understudy?

Using the shoddiest sort of argument, Hobsbawm hangs everything on anti-Toryism in the way a preLabour radical might have done 100 years ago. "The Alliance is unquestionably an anti-Thatcherite phenomenon, and insofar as the Tory Party has been hijacked by the selfmade stormtroopers of the Right, a secession from Conservatism"

But the Alliance is much more fundamentally anti-working-class than it years in office. And, as we argued last week, they are fighting the election campaign like people not quite clear that they want to win, But what the new Popular Frontists want the labour movement to do is foreswear ever being able to offer the electorate an alternative - and immediately to give up in advance, on the say-so of the opinion polls, on an attempt to win the General Election.

If Labour loses the election, it will be because the Labour and trade union leaders have failed so miserably to organise the movement and unite it in a vigorous campaign against the Tory government. And because they seem more interested in inflicting on the movement such nonsense as the eve-of-election conflict with some of the most vociferous are notning new St W people in the Fight to win But Labour does not have to lose the election. A powerful campaign round Labour's conference policies can still be mounted, and it should be. The last thing Labour needs is to follow the advice of the 'SDPMarxists' and haul up the white flag of surrender.

For all their faults, and no matter how distant they are from socialist politics, Neil Kinnock and the leaders of the Labour Party who reject coalition and go into the election committed to fight for a Labour government are far to the left of those chickenhearted 'Marxists' who have abandoned class politics entirely. Good news

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 311

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →