Big Bad
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Young Iranian fundamentalist The MA SIAS Labour and Ireland' carries a review by Geoff Bell of Moloney and Pollak's important book "Paisley'.
Half of the review ignores the book entirely and is instead given over to Geoff Bell's ruminations about Rhonda Paisley's TV chat show on Dublin's RTE, the nature of Loyalism, and the role of the individual in history.
Bell's ruminations are notable for the violence of the language employed, rather than for their accuracy.
Bell concludes by suggesting that *the book does tend to the view that a bullet in Big Ian's head could solve everything. Well, if it were that easy, someone would surely have lodged one there long ago. But the book does not tend to such a view.
Bell is equally inaccurate in claiming that there is "little new" in Moloney's and Pollak's interpretation of Paisley's career. He further compounds the error by reducing Moloney's and Pollak's work to be ing merely "a useful job (which) reemphasises just what a nasty political animal lan Paisley is.
Moloney and Pollak certainly do show what a 'nasty political animal' Ian Paisley is. But they also go well beyond that and successfully undermine many of the ignorant assumptions current on the British Left about Paisley and the Protestant community To list just some of the basic points made in this 456-page book:
*Paisley's rise to power is based on his ability to articulate the fears of the Protestant community.
*Paisley is a populist who has successfully tapped the antiEstablishment and anti-'fur coat brigade' tradition in the Protestant community.
*Like all populists, Paisley is adept at parish pump politics and is an efficient constituency MP.
*Paisley has played a central role in helping break up the Unionist monolith by founding the Free Presbyterian Church and the Democratic Unionist Party.
*Paisley uses violent imagery in his rhetoric, but is careful to keep his distance from the real thing, and is held in contempt by Loyalist paramilitaries.
*Paisley has vacillated wildly on the constitutional question, even briefly flirting with the idea of a united Ireland. *In the final analysis, Paisley is yet another careerist politician, pragmatically ditching his positions of yesterday and adopting new ones to further his own career, chasing, rather than leading the masses.
All this is clearly far from the interpretation placed upon the book bi Geoff Bell (et al). The authors have gone far beyond the simple (but accurate) notion that Paisley is a 'nasty political animal' and performed a valuable service in unravelling the complexities the reasons for Paisley's popularity and of the motivation of those who lend him their support.
----- pull-quotes -----
"Paisley', by Ed Moloney Pollak. Poolbeg, £5.95,J