Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Housing crisis in Glasgow

Socialist Organiser no. 310, 23 April 1987 · scan pp. 5–6 · Clive Bradley · about 1,823 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Socialist Organiser no 310_23 April 1987 page expenditure by central government restrictions, the Council compromissed on housing standards and social facilities on the new estates. On a -range of criteria (lay-out, insulation, heating, density, etc) the new estates fell well below the recognised standards of the day.

Subsequent developments exacerbated further the situation - the emergence of a centralised and inefficient housing management structure; an inadequate repair and maintenance system; an allocation system which resulted in the segregation of social and economic grounds; and, more recently, savage cutbacks in local authority subsidies by the Tories, the blight of mass unemployment on the housing schemes and the collapse of tenants' spending power through cuts in social security.

Results Such ill-thought-out housing policies and continuous underfinancing have now led to:

*40,000 households on the waiting list for a council house, plus 19,000 new entrants every year;

*42,000 houses (15%) are below tolerable standards, including 22,000 council houses;

*Overcrowding on some of the peripheral council estates is seven times the national average, and infant mortality almost five times the national rate;

*14,000 council houses are acknowledged to suffer from dampness (though the real figure is a lot higher, as "condensation" is regarded as something different from dampness);

*8,700 properties lack a bath or shower;

*Mobility from less popular to more popular council housing is virtually nil - out of 8,230 applicants for a transfer in 1984, only 27 managed to obtain lets in the most popular areas of council housing;

*Poverty overlaps with bad housing to make living conditions even worse; unemployment on some estates is running at 40%, 83% of council tenants have gross incomes below £5,200 and 74% of council tenants are in receipt of Housing Benefit.

*The city also suffers from a shortage of sheltered housing units (6,000), wheelchair units (600), units for the mentally ill (400) and units for the mentally handicapped (200).

This is the reality of Glasgow, behind the Labour-controlled council's long-standing public relations exercise of trying to con people into believing that "Glasgow's Miles Better" and "Glasgow — A Great Place to Live (!) and Work (!!)"

Needless to say, Rifkind's strategy for "solving" the housing problem is geared to benefit private sector profiteers rather than council house tenants. Despite government cuts of £48 million in the Housing Support Grant and of £20 million in the Rate Fund Contribution to Glasgow over the last five years, Rifkind claimed that vast sums of government money for council housing were already available, that the government could not afford to spend any more, and that those who called for a doubling of government financial aid ing in "cloud cuckoo land".

Instead, Rifkind advocated the break-up of the large housing estates by transferring 50% of the housing stock out of council tenure, increasing council house rents to a "realistic" level, more involvement of the private sector in housing development in Glasgow, and a bigger say for tenants in the running of council housing. The inevitable outcome of such an approach would be that the private sector would snap up the most profitable sites for private development, while council tenants were left paying massively increased rents for the worst housing.

Sell-off Glasgow District Council responded to Rifkind's proposals by claiming — not unjustifiably — that they were already being carried out! Large chunks of council housing and council land have already been sold off in recent years. Rent increases of an average of £2.04 per week for council tenants have just been announced. And the Council actively promotes a "social mix" philosophy in housing, involving opening up council estates to the private sector (but certainly not making inroads into the privaté sector to the benefit of council housing).

Rifkind's response will, of course, be that this is not enough. Thus the framework for debate will be in terms of how much council land and housing should be sold off and how high rent increases should be, instead of why they council should collaborate with building cowboys and why tenants should pay more for continually deteriorating housing.

The high proportion of council housing in Glasgow (58%, as against a national average of 28%) and the relatively low council rents in Glasgow as compared with the rest of the country make Glasgow a natural target for a government ideologically committed to attacks on the public sector and to support for the "free play" of market forces. Rifkind's proposals fit naturally into such an approach, controlled Glasgow District Council The choice before Labouris therefore the same as that before any other Labour-controlled authority: either it can continue to implement the Tories' policies as it has done in the past, or it can line up with council tenants, Labour branches and trade union branches in order lo nount a campaign of active opposi tion to the Tories' attacks.

Edwina Ice amphet A Workers Liberty pamphlet Eric Hobsbawm and Communism By John Mcllroy. Price 50p Workers' Ireland series No.i: After the Anglo-Iris! accord by John O'Mahony and debate with Sinn Fein. Price £1 All pamphlets available from: PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Please include 20p D&p

Scan page 6

Fifty years ago on April 27 1937 the Italian revolutionary Marxist Antonio Gramsci died of a brain haemorrhage in the Clinica Quisisana in Rome. He had arrived there in August 1935, still a prisoner, suffering from ateriosclerosis, Pott's disease, pulmonary tuberculosis, angina, gout and severe gastric disorders.

Several weeks ago, on Saturday 11 April, the yuppy 'SDP-Communist' magazine Marxism Today sponsored a daylong event marking Gramsci's death. One of the workshops held -entitled Gramsci, the Left and the Popular' - promised gushingly to reveal the 'links between Gramsci's cultural writings and today's designer socialism.' Now perhaps I'm just an inattentive reader but I can't say I've ever noticed any mention in Gramsci's work of 'the pleasure of purchase' or the wonders of filofax.

The unfortunate victim of this ludicrous misappropriation was born of Albanian extraction in the village of Ales in Sardinia on January 22 1891. A childhood accident left Antonio hunchbacked - and thus an object of revilement on this superstitious island. In contrast with other major figures within Marxism, Gramsci endured great hardship and poverty both as a child and in adulthood.

Sheer determination won him a scholarship to the University in Turin and it was to that most proletarian of Italian cities that he travelled in 1911. However tremendous ill-health, culminating in a nervous breakdown in 1913 put paid to his degree in linguistics. Instead, together with fellow students Angelo Tasca, Umberto Terracini and Palmiro Togliatti he became involved in political activity in the Italian Socialist Party (PSI), writing for Il Grido del Popolo and Avanti.

Like many others on the left of European socialism Gramsci hailed the Russian Revolution as a heroic break with the clockwork Marxism of the old Second International - as a "Revolution against Capital. In April At the trial of Antonio Gramsci the Fascist prosecutor demanded that the court must "stop this brain .

functioning for 20 years." Brian McKenna examines the ideas produced by that brain and their relevance for socialists today.

1919 Gramsci collaborated in the founding of L'Ordine Nuovo, a journal which became the voice of the Turin 'Factory Council' movement; a movement which Gramsci saw as translating the Russian 'soviet" experience into an Italian context.

1920 saw (in April) a general strike in Piedmont and, in September, widespread factory occupations initiated by the metalworkers' union, the FIOM.

The PSI proved itself to be utterly inadequate during this crucial year, demonstrating the need for a new politically clearer and harder formation - namely the Communist Party of Italy (PCI) which was formed at Livorno in March 1921, and was initially led by Amadeo Bordiga.

L'Ordine Nuovo now became a daily paper of the Party. In its columns Gramsci analysed the rising Fascist movement, among other things. When Mussolini actually marched on Rome in 1922 Gramsci was in Moscow working for the Communist International. While there he was married to Julia Shucht with whom he was to have two sons.

The occupation of the factories Gramsci courageously returned to Italy — as an MP - in 1924 and became General Secretary of the PCI in 1926. In November of that year he was arrested and two years later was sentenced to twenty years in prison. He informed his sister-in-law Tatiana that he intended to produce something that would last. -Incarcerated first on the island of Turi and then in Rome he poured his heart and soul into notebook after notebook. The Party meanwhile had abandoned him since in 1931 he opposed the ultraleftism of the "Third Period' policy dictated by Stalin.

As the thirties tragically wore on, Gramsci's health deteriorated drastically; when his ten year calvary came to an end in 1937 he was only 46.

Within weeks of Gramsci's death the Prison Notebooks were in the hands of his former comrade Palmiro Togliatti, the PCI leader known to Spanish Anarchist workers as the Butcher of Bilbao.

When, in 1947, he finally allowed the notebooks to see the light of day, Togliatti ensured that they were ruthlessly censored. Within Italy until the mid-sixties Gramsci was falsely portrayed as a loyal Stalinist; from 1965 onwards as a "Eurocommunist' reformist.

The latter falsified version of Gramsci has been imbibed in Britain by the Marxism Today wing of the Communist Party and its fellow-travellers on the Labour Left. The definitive critique of this bowdlerised Gramsci is Perry Anderson's 1977 article in New Left Review no. 100; it remains well worth reading if you can get hold of it.

If the Stalinist and Eurocommunist versions of Gramsci are not worth a bean, what of the revolutionary version? Is there anything of specific value to be gleaned from Gramsci that cannot be got from Marx, Lenin or Trotsky? I think there is. Gramsci tried to think through a distinction between rule based on coercion and 'moral and intellectual leadership' based on consent. The word he uses to define the latter — 'hegemony' — tends to be overworked throughout the Notebooks moreover the distinction in reality is never very clear). However, the areas it opens up are important ones.

As early as the first years of LOrdine Nuovo, Gramsci was denoting by "hegemony" a whole cultural dimension of class struggle less well registered by Lenin and Trotsky. Revolutionaries were to compete for hegemony within the working class which would in turn seek to forge a hegemonic alliance with the Southern Italian peasantry.

Hegemony

More interestingly, however, Gramsci also used "hegemony' to understand the complexity of bourgeois ideological influence throughout society. His starting point was the inherently 'contradictory consciousness of the active wo/man-in-the-mass' He held that implicit in the daily practice of the popular classes was a subversive view of the world that contradicted the superficially explicit' one. Thus the ideological dominance achieved by those intellectuals wedded to bourgeois society can never be final; instead is

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 310

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →