Black youth and the Labour Party a reply to Black Sections
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Newham 7 demonstration photo Carlos Guarita (Reflex) John Bloxam and Mark Osborn reply to Narendra Makanji of Black Sections, who recently argued in the pages of SO that we should support the Black Sections candidate in the Labour Party Young Socialists. Dear Narendra, Youth Fightback will be standing a candidate for the LPYS place on the Labour Party National Executive, as our tendency has for the past eleven years.
We do not accept the view that one section of the trade union and labour movement, whatever the special oppression it faces, has the right to dictate what other sections of that movement do or say.
The labour movement needs democracy like a body needs oxygen. Rational debate and discussion, testing ideas in practice - only thus can we decide what is correct, not by who said it.
Are black people the only people with the right to a view on racism and how to fight it? Black people, despite the common experience of racism, disagree politically. There are black socialists and black nationalists. You say that Labour Party Black Section represents black youth; Darcus Howe has written a pamphlet saying the Black Section represents the black petit-bourgeoisie. In South Africa there are disagreements between the "black consciousness' movement (which you support), the ANC and the 'workerists' in the trade unions. How is colour of skin to determine who is right on such issues? Socialist Organiser has consistently supported and fought for the right of black people and women to organise separately in both the trade unions and the Party, both as a basic democratic right and because of the role separate organisation can play in fighting against the special oppression and discrimination that black people and women face within our own movement.
We argued this long before Labour Party Black Section was formed, including in the YS against Militant. Socialist Organiser has supported, from the very beginning, the fight for Labour Party Black Sections to have constitutional status within the Party. However, we do not believe that this active support means that we should automatically agree with everything you do or say. Support is not the same as sycophancy; solidarity is not an alternative to dialogue and debate.
Yet Kingsley Abrams said this in the Black Sections Newsletter of Spring 1986: "…although Kingsley's demonstrated he's the true militant candidate in the election with his support for workers in struggle, elements on the Left like Socialist Organiser have snubbed him. They refuse to recognise that solidarity with the oppressed means supporting those people whom groups like Black Sections say best represent them. For predominantly White groups not to do so is racist. " (p.11). A number of our leading members have also ac used i us of being possibly win the NEC position in 1987.
Last year Kingsley picked up 37 votes, including all the Labour Coordinating Committee's; the Youth Fightback candidate got 10. Militant had enough votes not only to overwhelmingly elect Linda Douglas, but also to clearly win the runner-up position as well. In this situation the reasons for standing are to campaign and to make propaganda.
Youth Fightback will not cost Steve Jamoa a place on the NEC, nor stop Black Sections making propaganda for their candidate. And how can our candidate be against Black Sections when she will clearly state her support for Black Sections' right to Labour Party recognition?
Congratulated
Comrades from Youth Fightback and Socialist Organiser have proved themselves year after year at YS conferences, submitting motions and arguing for pro-Black Sections and anti-racist politics against Militant. Marc Wadsworth even congratulated an SO supporter last year for making the best speech in support of Black Sections.
At the LPYS Summer Camp 1985, for example, we debated Militant on the Black Sections question, and defended the rights of the Liverpool Black Caucus against Militant in a very violent atmosphere. Neither Black Sections nor any of the present supporters of Steve's campaign were We are c working class people. A proportion of working class youth are genuinely attracted to their ideas. If we are to build a movement that can replace the Militant in the LPYS it will have to be built on policies that stand up to debate with the LPYS leadership.
Unfortunately, on central issues of the economy, etc., Steve stands to the right of Militant. Indeed many of his supporters at national conference will be witch-hunters from the LCC - as were Kingsley's last year.
On issues such as women Steve's platform says only one thing: "We support the constitutional demands of Labour Women's Conference." This is one of the issues where the Black Sections programme is wholly inadequate to present as an alternative to Militant.
Your letter mentions the issue of South Africa. We strongly agree that support must be won in Britain for the liberation movement. In particular we have focussed, as socialists, on work with South African trade unionists and socialists.
As you may know, Tom Rigby from Peckham LPYS (a Youth Fightback supporter) was involved in one of the most successful examples of direct links involving a tour of British Plessey factories with a brother from the South African Electrical Workers Union (EAWTU). We are obviously concerned, therefore, that Steve's platform ducks the issue of direct links.
In LPYS terms Steve's demands on the issue of apartheid are unexceptional. However, to be credible gainst the Militant we must answer vestions on people's versus orkers" sanctions the ANC; the arkerit in the unions, etc. etc.
liana have answers to these quess. We must have too. Youth ghoback is quite clear on these ssues, Steve is not.
Moreover, it is not simply a quesdon of politics. To lappear credible to young workers you need to have a record of work on the ground.
Youth Fightback comrades have a record, for instance, on South Africa. We have raised hundreds of pounds for union detainees, EAWTU and Students of Young Azania. Comrades have organised gigs, discos, street meetings, bucket collections as well as a national speaking tour. Youth Fightback have produced posters, leaflets and speakers' notes which help LPYS branches campaign.
It is interesting to compare this level of activity with Black Sections Youth. For most of the last part of 1986 Black Sections Youth have not met; the promises made by Kingsley during last year's Black Sections Youth bid for the NEC place have not been met (e.g. work around racism on the YTS); and Black Sections Youth had only three voting members when your letter was sent. Steve is not representative of black youth.
Suspended
What of the participation of Youth Fightback supporters in Black Sections Youth? The letter does not mention that the voting rules on the Black Sections Youth Committee were recently changed so that all of our comrades were deprived of a vote. Last year, for the 'crime' of not supporting Kingsley Abrams in the YS NEC election, SO supporter Keyvan Lajevardi was suspended from participating in the Black Sections Youth Committee for the duraion of the campaign.
The letter says that our comrades should have stood to "give members the opportunity to choose between the politics of two candidates" Which members? The three who had just voted to take away the votes of our three comrades? At the previous meeting the Youth Committee had voted not to stand a candidate in this year's YS NEC elections. Our comrades had put forward two main arguments against the Black Sections Youth Committee putting forward a candidate — insufficient discussion on the political programme, and the fact that the Black Sections Youth had no base or record on the ground in the YS.
Finally, we would like to comment on the situation in Labour Left Liaison, particularly after your representatives walked out of the 9 March meeting because of the issue raised in your letter.
Unity
Our view is that the unity that has been achieved in LLL on campaigning around jointly agreed issues has been valuable. That is why in this dispute on the LPYS SO has adopted exactly the same position that the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy did when they were faced with an equivalent situation last year.
On the five women's places on the NEC, CLPD were a minority of one on LLL. They did not support the five candidates put forward by the Women's Action Commitee from the Labour Women's Conference "shadow elections'. For one of the places they supported a different candidate.
What happened? CLPD refrained from vetoing support for the five candidates supported by everybody else, but continued on their own to campaign for their different candidate. Socialist Organiser has adopted exactly the same approach on the issue of the candidate for the YS NEC elections.
If there are any threats to the unity of LLL over the issue then it will be because you decide that is what you want, or because Socialist Action try to use the disagreement to implement the threat they made last year to "drive us out".
Scan page 11
Caterpillar Lambeth