Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

An Irish might- have-been

Socialist Organiser no. 309, 9 April 1987 · scan p. 9 · Clive Bradley · about 722 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

HISTORY is written by the victors, and so it was after the 26 Counties of Ireland won separation from Britain in 1922 and the remaining six assumed Home Rule under the Westminster Parliament.

Thereafter history in the South was written from the standpoint of the Southern bourgeoisie, and according to the historical outlook of physicalforce republicanism. In the North history was written from the triumphant Unionist point of view And not only is history written by the victors. What has happened in history seems in retrospect to have happened inevitably. The result is that all the might-have-beens vanish, discredited and often scorned, into the void.

For the 50 years during which Lloyd George's Partition settlement seemed to have led to a stable Ireland, divided into two hostile 50p By Paddy Dollard states, there was not much interest in the many might-have-beens of Irish history. To tell the truth, there was not much real history.

There were 'stories agreed upon", encrusted with myth, special pleading and nationalist and Unionist pieties.

It began to change in the '60s, and it changed with a vengeance once the IRA's war provided proof that the 1922 partition had not 'settled' the Irish question. Irish historical research and publishing became a growth industry.

Cooperative

It reminds me of Orson Welles' much-quoted comment that while war-ridden Renaissance Italy produc ed Michelangelo and Leonardo da Eric Hobsbawm Communism By John Mollroy. Pricé 50p Is the SWP an alternative! By Clive Bradley, Martin Thomas and Paddy Dollard.

The sectarians tested against South Africa, the socialist struggle in the Labour Party, Ireland and the Arabs, Jews and Socialism The debate on Palestine, Zionism ar Anti-Semitism (including Trotsky or Zionism) Price 90p Vinci, 500 years of sleepy peace in Switzerland produced - "the cuckoo clock' The hero of Horace Plunkett, Cooperation and Politics' by Trevor West* was a Southern Unionist and a landlord. He founded the cooperative movement which contributed to transforming the lot of Irish farmers by way of self-help.

He was one of those who brought about what must have been one of the strangest conferences in history, that in which representatives of the Irish landlord class and of the peasants met over Christmas 1902 and worked out the terms on which the landlords would agree after decades of bitter conflict, and centuries of landlord oppression of the farmers - to be bought out by them.

Afterward the British Tory government obligingly organised the finances of the deal. It was enshrined in the Wyndham Land Act of 1903 which broke the back of the old Marxism, Stalinism Afghanistan Second edition. Price 80p Vorkers' Ireland series No.1: After the Anglo-Irisi accord by John O'Mahony and debate with Sinn Fein. Price £1 All pamphlets available from: PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Please include 20p landlordism in Ireland - by consent.

After the 1916 uprising, which galvanised nationalist Ireland and put the previously marginal physicalforce Republicans at the centre of the political stage, Plunkett and others tried (in 1917) to achieve Dominion Home Rule for a united Ireland (the same status as Canada, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa).

Conscription

The British government's attempt to introduce conscription to Ireland tipped the balance in favour of Sinn Fein and of complete separation from Britain. In turn that ruled out whatever chance there may have been of reconciliation between Protestant and Catholic Ireland.

Ireland was torn apart. The scene was set for the eruption, after 50 years' oppression of Northern Ireland's Catholics, of the present conflict with its threat of full-scale civil war, • The labour movement in Britain and in Ireland needs to study Irish history — history, not the myths and emotional catchcries of either side — because that is the only way to understand the bitter division in the Irish working class.

The study of the might-havebeens' is of great value because what *has-in-fact-been' for the last 65 years is manifestly unviable, threatening to lead to something worse, and even to a Lebanese level of communal conflict.

It is necessary to take a critical look at how we got into this mess -and at the might-have-beens. West's book is of great value here. * 'Horace Plunkett, Cooperation and Polities' by Trevor West. Colin Smythe/Catholic University of America Press, £12.95.

----- pull-quotes -----

SDP Communism Mary all Workers Liberty pamphlet

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 309

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →