Justice for tr A story of victimisation
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
There are 29 sacked miners in the Notts coalfield now. Two were reinstated shortly after the strike - they were on small offences like stealing coal. Apart from them nobody else has been reinstated.
The Coal Board will not talk to us, so we are at the mercy of industrial tribunals, in which we have not got much faith. We have won seven, with reinstatement ordered in four. But the Board has not complied.
We thought that Haslam might consider a number of the cases in his review' . However, I always thought he was going to be hardline.
He said he was not going to deal with anybody who had been to a tribunal and lost, nor anybody who, in his words, had been "involved in acts of violence" . That can mean all things to all men. We have had men done for minor scuffles in clubs or on the street, with no criminal charges. But presumably for Haslam those are incidents with "violence"
In Notts the sackings are part of the Coal Board's strategy to keep the NUM down and the UDM up.
-Those who have been dismissed since the dispute — people like Whetton, McGinty and Poulter are men who have been very successful in recruiting to the NUM. It is no coincidence that the three best recruiters, who were branch officials at the pits with the highest recruitment, have been dismissed. It is a calculated manoeuvre by the Board, and this has since been confirmed by the results of Paul Whetton's tribunal.
Then, for those who had been sacked at the end of the strike, we had the excuse that they could not be set on because of the bitter antagonism that existed between them and the majority who had been working. We were told they would not be accepted. But the strike has now been over for two years. We have NUM and UDM men working together and a lot of the bitterness has died away.
We maintain that all the 29 are victimised. But there are examples that really stand out.
We have some pits in the Notringhamshire coalfield that are geographically in Derbyshire -Bolsover and Cresswell. They are surrounded by Derbyshire pits and durDear Colleagues, We are hoping, once again, to organise a holiday for our sacked miners children during 1987. You are aware of the financial difficulties all our sacked miners are suffering, and this organised holiday is the only hope our children have of obtaining a holiday this year.
We have received tremendous support from you in the past and although I hesitate to impose on your good offices again, I very much hope that your organisation will be able to assist us.
My two years in jobs - by miner Available from S Richardson Notts area mingling between the Notts and Derbyshire NUM members. Derbyshire was all out on strike.
There was an incident at Whitwell, a Derbyshire pit. Two scabs had been enticed back by the Board, and they were being brought in by car at night with police escorts from Worksop. They played cards all night in a cabin on the pit top, surrounded by the police — it was part of the Board's strategy to break the strike.
32 men lined the pit lane the scabs had to go through at the end of the shift and put a barricade up. The police car ran into the barricade; the Coal Board van carrying the scabs ran into the back of the police car; and another police car ran into the back of the van! Not a lot of damage was done - in fact, £49 worth to the Coal Board van. The men scattered but two were identified. The Board said they would drop charges against them if they returned to work, which they did. Évidence Of the other 30, 27 were from Whitwell and three from Cresswell, a Notts pit. All were charged with unlawful assembly. When it came to court, seven months later, still during the dispute, the two who had been enticed back gave evidence against the others.
However, in this case for once, the judge, Justice Skinner, tried to put a bit of sanity back into it. He stopped the trial and said he thought it wrong that these working miners had to give evidence against their mates, and that he hoped that when the strike was over they would all work together. He appealed to all sides to come to some form of agreement.
There was then a meeting with the lads and barristers where it was agreed that, if they pleaded guilty, they would be given a lenient sentence - in fact, they got community service and a f7 fine. And the Board undertook in court, and put it in writing, that the men would all get Idren's holiday Now that I have the experience of organising one holiday, I am able to estimate that we will need between £4,500 and £5,000, which would pay for the cost of the holiday and provide a small amount of pocket money for the children.
My very grateful thanks for your support in the past and my hope for your continued support for this holiYours sincerly, Kate Lees.
All donations to be sent to:
36 Chestnut Drive, New Ollerton, Newark, Notts. their jobs back when the dispute was over. On that understanding all the 30 men pleaded guilty.
When the dispute finished all the 27 Whitwell men were reinstated immediately, but the three Cresswell miners were refused. They are still dismissed.
The excuse of the Board in Notts was that the written undertaking was given by the Training Officer and not by the manager. But in almost all cases of hiring and firing at the pit the Training Officer is the man delegated to do the job. So it is a pretext to break a clear written agree. ment, given in court, which is the only reason the men pleaded guilty in the first place.
It was the same employer, the same offence, but three men were segregated out _ Of 30 and not reinstated.
The only correspondence I have had from the Board, when I have written protesting cases like this, is that they are not prepared to consider any sacked miner in Notts for reinstatement. Since then we had Sir -Robert Haslam's review'. He had our papers for three months and we got nothing.
We support the sacked miners financially, with weekly payments. It is a difficult job — a very expensive item supporting 29 out of a member ship of 5,000. But we undertook that we would not betray them, and we are maintaining them.
We have also set up a day release course in conjunction with the Derbyshire union to give them something to do.
Basically there is nothing much more we can do at this stage; it is a question of biding our time. I am amazed at the fortitude they have got. They all want their jobs back at the pit.
My view is that if there is going to be any patching up it will never happen, or even begin to happen with the Board or anyone else, until these lads are all reinstated.
Nationally there used to be a Hard ship Fund for the sacked and victimised men, which was tremendous. Initially it was financing 1000 men, which then went down to 500. Payments were running at £20,000 a week - £1 million a year. We were able to maintain that until other unions also ran up against the Trade Union Acts, and like SOGAT got their own members sacked. In fact, the National Hardship Fund has not completely dried up, but there is not enough money coming in to pay out regularly, so it has fallen back on the Areas — it is now their responsibility The support we have had from the rank and file of the labour movement as a whole, whatever their political persuasion, has been tremendous. But we still have to recognise the difficulties. People think 'everybody is back at work now, "the sacked miners have been reinstated' and so on. Our job is to explain what is really happening, so we send sacked miners out to speak at meetings all over the country.
I am not going to blame the rank and file people. The fault is elsewhere. We certainly have not had AMN
----- pull-quotes -----
ing the strike there was a lot of inter- An appeal
jail for fighting Terry French iO, PO Box