Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Arguing for class politics

Socialist Organiser no. 309, 9 April 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,946 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Many on the left have tried to give a radical gloss to their retreat from class politics, but all have veered away from or downplayed 'traditional class struggle.

Workers' Liberty defends one of the basic ideas of.

Marxism: that the working class must liberate itself.

Socialist Organiser no 309 9 April 1987 page:

the magazine Workers Liberty, reports on the new issue just out, and available from PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA for 90p plus 20p post (cheques payable to SO).

The new issue of Workers' Liberty magazine carries on the front an epigram from Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, writing to August Bebel and other leaders of the German socialist movement in 1879.

*For almost forty years we have stressed the class struggles as the most immediate driving power in history, and, in particular, the class struggle between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat as the great lever of the modern social upheaval; therefore it is impossible for us to ally ourselves with people who want to eliminate this class struggle from the movement...The emancipation of the working class must be the work of the working class itself".

The Social-Democratic Party had just been made illegal under Bismark's "Anti-Socialist Laws' , and some of its leaders became nervous about the way the party had conducted "a one-sided struggle for the interests of the industrial workers" and thus 'increased the hatred of the bourgeoisie unnecessarily" Marx and Engels, as the quotation shows, replied without equivocation.

In Britain today, and in many other countries, the labour move. ment has recently suffered setbacks, though less sharp and clear-cut than the Anti-Socialist Law. These set backs have generated the same dislike for and scepticism about class sturg gle as infected those • German socialists. On trum, the 'reteat from class is sometimes given a radical gloss by the claim that it is a matter of seeing that race and gender conflicts must have the same status as class struggles.

The left-wing version of the retreat from class' is not, however, much better than the standard right. wing version. Conflicts between women and men, or black and white, can be adjusted, equalised, redressed; not even the boldest solution can do more. If the class struggle is put in the same level, then it is reduced to trying to put workers on equal terms with the capitalist class. And indeed PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 0111670-7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone, Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony. Typesetting: Upstream Ltd ПW1.

Published by Socialist Organiser London SE15 4NA.

inted by bert Endle (TU), London E2.

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Sorry! We omitted the author's name on the talk of the seizure of the means of production by the workers, and of public ownership, is considered old hat on much of the left today.

A number of articles in the magazine address its main theme. An editorial surveys the state of the British working class, recognises that defeats have taken a toll, but sees much scope for positive organising and hope for the future. A review of an important recent book by Ellen Melksins Wood (from the title of which the magazine borrows its cover theme, *The Retreat from Class'), summarises her arguments against the right-wing neo-Marxists who are now advocating a socialist politics dissociated from class, and argues that many of them strike home against more left-wing tendencies. tOO.

An article gives detailed facts and figures on the rise of industrial capitalism (and thus of an industrial working class) in the Third World over the last 25 or so years. Bob Fine explains why trade unionists in South Africa want a Workers' Charter as well as, or instead of, the ANC's much-mythologised Freedom Charter; and Tom Rigby surveys the "mushrooming growth" of the non-racial trade union movement in A contributor from Australia, Janet Burstall, carefully examines the claim that Nicaragua shows a new populist road to socialism, and argues that independent working class politics are still necessary despite everything positive that can and should be said about the Sandinista revolution. Salman Rushdie's new book on Nicaragua is also reviewed.

Some on the left believe that the best way to get world peace now is to support Mikhail Gorbachev. An editorial argues that "nothing agreed between the superpowers merits the trust and confidence of socialists" and that the real road to peace lies in the struggle of the working class, East and West.

Controversially, the editorial points out that as long ago as 1939 Leon Trotsky recognised an "element of imperialism" in the Kremlin's international policy. If we apply the same method and concepts as Trotsky to the realities of the past 45 years - and in particular to the USSR's brutal domination of Eastern Europe — we have to conclude that the USSR today is imperialist. It is a different sort of imperialism from that of the US, France or Britain: but then history has had many sorts of imperialism other than modern monopoly capitalism.

Defend

Workers' Liberty is concerned to defend the basic ideas of classical Marxism — against toning down or dilution. But it is equally opposed to wooden dogmatism, or the recital of the words 'socialism' and 'working class' as magic answers to all problems.

A feature on the politics of Northern Ireland argues that viable socialist politics there must include an adequate democratic programme on the relations between Ireland's two communities, Catholic and Protestant. The magazine's openness to debate is signalled by a contribution from Donal Rayner O'Connor Lysaght which criticises Workers' Liberty No. 5 on Ireland.

Debate is also represented by an interview with Vladimir Derer of the beyond today's tactical questions of day-to-day Labour Party politics to explain his idea of how the capitalist state will be overthrown. And the magazine contains a lively element of polemic.

Jim Allen's [Perdition', EWORKERS"

LIBERTY Sama clas the Nazi mass murder of the Jews of Hungary in 1944, has become a cause celebre. Allen believes that the play "is the most lethal attack on Zionism ever written...because it says quite plainly that privileged Jewish leaders collaborated in the extermination of their own kind in order to help bring about a Zionist state". Jews of many different political stripes have protested that this is an obscene twisting of the facts, using the desperate strategems of people facing ruthless massacre as evidence to try to smear present-day Israel with part of the guilt for the horrors of Nazism.

Most of the left has rallied to Allen. John O'Mahony in Workers' Liberty finds that "Those who have campaigned against the play being produced are wrong in principle and shortsighted in practice" and of course there is much that modern Israel can be criticised for - in its treatment of the Palestinian Arabs. But "it is a pretty vile play". *It is highly improbable that Jim Allen is himself hostile to Jews, but that is not the issue here. He embraces politics which by demonologising Israel are in their logic inescapably hostile to Jews...

Another polemic uses a review of a book about the Bolsheviks in the Tsarist parliament to examine the British SWP's attitudes to parliament AIDS is looked at criticates. And the left's response to The magazine also carries a survey of the recent international wave of student struggles, a discussion of the issue of commemorating 1688, and other reviews.

Workers' Liberty is a magazine which is firmly of the activist, rather than the academic left, but which debates issues rather than blandly reciting a 'line'; one which examines changes in the world and is not frightened of offending left 'public opinion, but. bases itself firmly on classical Marxism. Read it?

"QUEEN'S cousin locked in madhouse" said Monday's Sun front page.

No doubt you know the basic outline by now - two first cousins of the Queen spent 40 years of their lives locked away in a Surrey mental hospital that was once condemned for its lack of sanitation, Both the sisters have been listed in Burke's Peerage as dead for many years. In fact, one died last year and is buried in a pauper's grave, while the other is still alive in the strict sense of the word.

According to the Financial Times on Tuesday, three other cousins of the Queen were also locked up in this hospital in 1941. One has since died and two are still alive.

Not the usual sort of Windsor story, this one. No glamorous gowns or daring flashes of royal knees. No chubby, cheeky royal infants. None of your "they're just like us, really"

jocularity — these royals (or nearroyals) are definitely not "just like us"

The picture of Katherine BowesLyon on the front page of the Sun showed a gaunt face with dreadful, staring eyes. The Windsor characteristics were unmistakeable.

Buck House, of course, denied a "cover-up'. Of course they would, wouldn't they? That silly, kindhearted old soul, the Queen Mum, knew all about it. She never visited her nieces, but sent them the occa sional box of licquorice allsorts.

How the phoney entries got into Burke's Peerage remains a mystery.

The niece of the Bowes-Lyon sisters, Lady Elizabeth Shakerley, claimed that it was all a mistake.

When Burke's Peerage sent family the proofs of the sisters tries, noone noticed that it said th were dead. The whole family is, a parently, 'marvellously vague' I was going to write a jokey pie about the Windsors' long history mental illness, which Tuesday's Si reports in surprising detail: the ma Duke of Clarence (who may or ma not have been Jack the Ripper Prince John, the Queen's uncle, wh was kept in isolation at Sandringha shook it warmly by the branch.

But actually I think the whole ma ter is a little more serious than tha Fleet Street's coverage of the story -not to mention the royals' treatmer of their embarrassing relatives - say a lot about the way the mentally har dicapped are regarded and treated i this society. They are locked away i frightening establishments and, if nc entirely forgotten about, then regard ed with a mixture of morbid fascina tion and horror.

The Queen Mum, of course, i patron of Mencap - the Roya Society for Mentally Handicapper Children and Adults. Mencap cam paigns against families dumping peo ple on the state.

Meanwhile, Tuesday's Su reported that another mental healti charity has put an interesting pro posal to the Queen. "We must bring mental health out into the open" said Chris Heginbothom of the organisation MIND. "The Royal Family are like any other family and mental illness can strike them too"

*The Queen should visit Miss Bowes-Lyon and be seen with her. That would show that they appreciate her worth as a human being -regardless of her mental health. The public could have learned from their example"

Somehow I don't think Her Majesty is likely to take up that suggestion.

Scan page 4

Like Against YTS Manchester school student strike against JTS last week "Private property" wrote Marx "has made us so an object is only ours stupid and one-sided that when we have it... Capitalism today is making people so 'stupid and one-sided' that this applies not only to objects but to children, In the US, William and Elizabeth Stern have just

----- pull-quotes -----

Jane Ashworth, business manager of

letter on page 4 last week. It was Bas Hardy:

Campaign for Labour Party Democracy in which Derer goes

Morbid fascination

until his death aged 14; and, ‹ once mistook an oak tree in Hys Park for the Emperor of Prussia, an

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 309

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →