American Trotskyist James P Cannon on: Socialism and democracy
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no.308 2nd April 1987 page 10 What is the relationship between socialism and democracy? This passionate speech made in 1957 by the pioneer of US Marxism, Jam P. Cannon, argues that they are inseparable, and that socialism must and can only understood as a massive extension and expansion of democracy.
Tam glad to be here with you today and to accept your invitation to speak on socialism and democracy.
Strange as it may seem, an agreement on these two simple, elementary points, as experience has already demonstrated, will not be arrived at easily. The confusion and demoralisation created by Stalinism, and the successful exploitation of this confusion by the ruling capitalists of this country and all their agents and apologists, still hangs heavily over all sections of the workers movement.
At every step for 30 years, the Stalinist work of befuddlement and demoralisation, of debasing words into their opposite meanings, has been supported by reciprocal action of the same kind by the ruling capitalists and their apologists, They have never failed to take the Stalinists at their word, and to point to the Stalinist regime in the Soviet say: "That is socialism.* The Union, with all of its horrors, and to American way of life is better.
They describe the United States, where the workers have a right to vote every four years, if they don't move around to much, but have no say about the control of the shop and the factory; where all the means of mass information and communication are monopolised by a few they describe all that as the ideal democracy for which the workers should gladly fight and die.
The authentic socialist movement, as it was conceived by its founders and as it has developed over the past century, has been the most democratic movement in all history. No formulation of this question can improve on the classic statement of the Communist Manifesto, with which modern scientific socialism was proclaimed to the world in 1848.
The Communist Manifesto said:
'All previous historical movements were movements of minorities, in the interest of minorities. The proletarian movement is the self-conscious, independent movement of the immense majority, in the interest of the immense majority."
- The authors of the Communist Manifesto linked socialism and democracy together as ends and means. The "self-conscious, independent movement of the immense majority, in the interests of the immense majority" cannot be anything SAMIE James P. Cannon Workers against Stalinism: Hungary else but democratic, if we understand by "democracy" the rule of the people, the majority.
The Stalinist claim that the task of reconstructing society on a socialist basis can be farmed out to a privileged and uncontrolled bureaucracy, while the workers remain without voice or vote in the process, is just as foreign to the thoughts of Marx and Engels and of all their true disciples as the reformist idea that socialism can be handed down to the workers by degrees, by the capitalists who exploit them.
All such fantastic conceptions were answered in advance by the reiterated statement of Marx and Engels that "the emancipation of the working class is the task of the workers themselves."
That was another way of saying as they said explicitly many times that the socialist reorganisation of society requires a workers' revolution. Such a revolution is unthinkable without the active participation of the majority of the working class, which is itself the big majority of the population. Nothing could be more democratic than that.
Moreover, the great teachers did not limit the democratic action of the working class to the overthrow of the bourgeois supremacy. They defined democracy as the form of governmental rule in the transition period between capitalism and socialism.
It is explicitly stated in the Communist Manifesto - and I wonder how many people have forgotten this in recent years: *The first step," said the Manifesto, "in the revolution by the working class is to raise the proletariat to the position of ruling class, to establish democracy."* That is the way Marx and Engels formulated the first aim of the revolution - to make the workers.
the ruling class, to establish democracy, which, in their view, is the same thing. From this precise formulation it is clear that Marx and Engels did not consider the limited formal democracy under capitalism, which screens the exploitation and the rule of the geat majority by the few, as real democracy. In order to have real democracy, the workers must become the "ruling class"
Only the revolution which replaces the class rule of the capitalists by the class rule of the workers can really "establish democracy," not in fiction but in fact. So said Marx and Engels.
They never taught that the simple nationalisation of the forces of production signified the establishment of socialism. That's not stated by Marx and Engels anywhere. The nationalisation only lays the economic foundations for the transition to socialism.
Still less could they have sanctioned, even if they had been able to imagine, the monstrous idea that socialism could be realised without equality; that nationalised produc tion and planned economy, controlled by a ruthless police dictatorship, complete with prisons, torture chambers and forced labour camps, could be designated as a "socialist"
movement society. That unspeakable perversion and contradiction of terms belongs to the Stalinists and their apologists.
All the great Marxists defined socialism as a classless society - with abundance, freedom, and equality for all: a society in which there would be no state, not even a democratic workers' state, to say nothing of a state in the monstrous form of a bureaucratic dictatorship of a privileged minority.
The Soviet Union today is a transitional order of society in which the bureaucratic dictatorship of a privileged minority, tar from serving as the agency to bridge the transition to socialism stands as an obstacle to harmonious development in that direction.
In the view of Marx and Engels, and of Lenin and Trotsky who came after them, the transition from capitalism to the classless society of socialism could only be carried out by an ever-expanding democracy, involving the masses of the workers more and more in all phases of social life, by direct participation and control.
And, in the course of further progressive development in all fields, as Lenin expressed it, even this democracy, this workers' democracy, as a form of class rule, will outlive itself. Lenin said: "Democracy will gradually change and become a habit, and finally wither away," since democracy itself, properly understood, is a form of state, that is, an instrument of class rule, for which there will be no need and no place in the classless socialist society.
Forecasting the socialist future, the Communist Manifesto said: "In the place of the old bourgeois society, with its classes and class antagonisms, we shall have an association." Mark that, "an association" , not a state - "an association in which the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all".
Trotsky said the same thing in other words when he spoke of socialism as "a pure and limpid system which is accommodated to the self-government of the toilers...and uninterrupted growth of universal equalty - all-sided flowering of human personality...unselfish honest and human relations between human beings."
And I say we will not put the socialist movement of this country on the right track, and restore its rightful appeal to the best sentiments of the working class of this country, and above all to the young, until we begin to call socialism by its right name as the great teachers did.
Until we make it clear that we stand for an ever-expanding workers' democracy, as the only road to vestige of Stalinist perversion and socialism. Until we root out every corruption of the meaning of socialism and democracy, and restate the thoughts and formulations of the authentic Marxist teachers..
----- pull-quotes -----
NOU. LITA
«The authentic movement...ha been the most