The hell-hole stockyards
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
When I was asked to write a review of this film I had just returned from seeing it - greatly moved by this story of a young Southern black going to work in the hell-holes called stockyards in Chicago during the First World War.
It is a very harrowing tale, well told, of racism, unions and working class life in the 1910s. But before reviewing the film, I decided to read a well known book about almost the same thing, "The Jungle" by Upton Sinclair, written about the stockyards in the first decade of the century.
It was only when I read this amazinn hank which chowed ma in manh UNIN greater detail and clarity than the "Killing Floor" what a terrible place the Chicago stockyards were - and indeed all of Chicago, for working people - that I realised how much the "Killing Floor" had left out: the unbearable conditions in work; of housing in the slums; the corrupt city council; and the Beef monopoly. But above all, what it left out was the For a film set around 1917 and the greatest working class victory in history — the Russian Revolution -and involving itself with unions whose members at that time were Ruinonene aften with a history of involvement in revolutionary politics, it gave no indication of any politics above a very basic syndicalism with the inevitable retormism.
My final criticism — 1 tound it very hard to believe that all lessons of black and white workers together in struggle can be completely forgotten and destroyed by racism. If that is true, what hope have we got.
Lastly, I have probably been overcritical of this film. For all its faults it is very good and truly gripping, long overdue in its subject matter. Go and see it if you possibly can. Unfortunately, like most films of this genre, it is only playing in selected cinemas in big cities. And I wouldn't hold your breath until EMI bring out the video.
For example in the film an old Jewish man suddenly realises that a train that left the ghetto "for the Ukraine" was back in less than seven hours. The journey should have taken three days...The train had deposited its human cargo at Auschwitz.
Life, survival, at the price of death, of killing others in the hope that you yourself may be spared; of voluntarily going to the train just because they gave you a piece of bread and marmalade. In similar conditions how many of us would "give in" and how many of us would fight?
Although the resistance was late in coming, it proves that through armed resistance the op-pressed can defend themselves. nasty feeling that Mr Kinnock has finally allen down the same hole as the Labour Party in general; which is to suppose that he dodgy little fudges which work intertally will also work externally. He has atended too many meetings of compositing committees.
He is trying to flog Labour's stark inilateralism with a lot of convoluted versage about the International Monetary Fund talks and the dubious promise of nore expenditure on conventional veapons. The British public is not fooled. Neither, most certainly are the cold power soliticians of Washington. The Labour Party now fools nobody but itself. Hence his dingey fiasco."
With Reagan and Gorbachov both batling for Thatcher aybe Kinnock would se better advised to look elsewhere for upport. Like the working class, perhaps?
One final rather obvious thought that iasn't been taken up by any of the naional press: if it is true that Labour's lefence policy leaves us all at the mercy of "Foreign aggressors" , and if it is true that Russia is top of the league when it comes • "aggression" ... then why the hell is Sorbachov doing so much to boost Thatber's clection campaign?
Scan page 10
WOMAN'S