Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Soviets ink up

Socialist Organiser no. 308, 2 April 1987 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,868 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

1917 in Pravda: "The all-Russian congress of of the Tsar These protests from below comelled the editors to become more tutious in their expressions, but did ot change their policy. Even the first ticle of Lenin which got there from proad passed by the minds of the litors. They were steering al ghtward course all along the line. The policy of the party throughout le whole country followed that of ravda. In many soviets, resolutions sout fundamental problems were now adopted unanimously: the olsheviks simply bowed down to the oviet majority. At a conference of e soviets of the Moscow region, the olsheviks joined in the resolution of e social patriots on the war. It remains to ask - and this is no important question although easier ask than answer: How would the volution have developed if Lenin id not reached Russia in April ›17? If our exposition demonstrates id proves anything at all, we hope it roves that Lenin was not a demiurge the revolutionary process, that he erely entered into a chain of objecve historic forces. But he was a eat link in that chain. The dictatorlip of the proletariat was to be inred from the whole situation, but it ill had to be established. It could at be established without a partyhe party could fulfill its mission aly after understanding it. For that enin was needed. Until his arrival, ot one of the Bolshevik leaders ared to make a diagnosis of the evolution. The leadership of amenev and Stalin was tossed by le course of events to the right, to e Social Patriots: between Lenin d Menshevism the revolution left • place for intermediate positions. iner struggle in the Bolshevik Party as absolutely unavoidable. Lenin's rival merely hastened the process. lis personal influence shortened the isis. Is it possible, however, to say confidently that the party without m would have found its road? We ould by no means make bold to say lat. The factor of time is decisive ere, and it is difficult in retrospect to tell time historically. Dialectic materialism at any rate has nothing in common with fatalism. Without Lenin the crisis, which the opportunist leadership was inevitably bound to produce, would have assumed an extraordinarily sharp and protracted character. The conditions of war and revolution, however, would not allow the party a long period for fulfilling its mission. Thus it is by no means excluded that a disoriented and split party might have let slip the revolutionary opportunity for many years. The role of personality arises before us here on a truly gigantic scale. It is necessary only to understand that role correctly, taking personality as a link in the historic chain.

Arrival The "sudden" arrival of Lenin from abroad after a long absence, the furious cry raised by the press around his name, his clash with all the leaders of his own party and his quick victory over them - in a word, the external envelope of circumstance - make easy in this case a mechanical contrasting of the person, the hero, the genius, against the objective conditions, the mass, the party. In reality, such a contrast is completely one-sided. Lenin was not an accidental element in the historical development, but a product of the whole past of Russian history. He was embedded in it with deepest roots. Along with the vanguard of the workers, he had lived through their struggle in the course of the preceding quarter century. The "accident" was not his interference in the events, but rather that little straw with which Lloyd George tried to block his path. Lenin did not oppose the party from outside, but was himself its most complete expression. In educating it he had educated himself in it. His divergence from the ruling circles of the Bolsheviks meant the struggle of the future of the party against its past. If' Lenin had not been artificially separated from the party by the conditions of emigration and war, the external mechanics of the crisis would not have been so dramatic and would not have overshadowed to such a degree the inner continuity of the party development. From the extraordinary significance which Lenin's arrival received, it should only be inferred that leaders are not accidentally created, that they are gradually chosen out and trained up in the course of decades, that they cannot be capriciously replaced, that their mechanical exclusion from the class struggle gives the party a living wound, and in many cases may paralyse it for a long period. July 1917. Demonstration calling for power to the soviets. Wednesday 29 March The first all-Russian meeting of Soviets of workers' and soldiers' deputies, convened by the Executive Committee of the Petrograd Soviet with the agreement of the Provisional Government, opens in Petrograd. 470 delegates attend, representing 185 different organisations, including 139 soviets. Mensheviks and SocialRevolutionaries predominate at it, In Petrograd, soldiers in a reserve company of the Litvian regiment unanimously agree to each donate half-a-pound of bread out of their rations to the poor until resolution of the food crisis. On the Northern front, General Dragomirov reports of continuing unrest amongst the troops: officers are arrested, orders are refused, the disposition of troops is questioned, and agitation for an end to the war continues. On the Western front soldiers in the Ekaterinoslav regiment fraternise with German troops.] The Omsk Soviet of workers' and military deputies resolves to immediately introduce the eight-hour working day. In Tiflis the electricity station workers inform the Executive Committee of the local Soviet that they have introduced the 8-hour working day of their own accord Thursday 30 March The all-Russian meeting of Soviets adopts a resolution in support of the war. A member of the Petrograd Soviet's Executive Committee moves a resolution calling for support for the Provisional Government.

Moscow railway workers appeal to the Moscow Soviet of Workers' Deputies and to the Petrograd Soviet to demand of the Provisional Government that it prevent factory-owners from causing a cut in production, if necessary by requisitioning their factories and calling the owners "to account, for betrayal of the mothercountry"

In Nizhny-Novgorod a committee of representatives of local industrialists passes a resolution condemning introduction of the 8-hour working day as "a crime against the state" and reserves the right to protest against and revise the decision.

There is fraternisation on the Northern front between sections of German and Russian troops.

Friday 31 March A mass meeting of 10,000 workers at the Putilov works in Petrograd condemns the lies of the bourgeois press in blaming the shortage of munitions for soldiers at the front on strikes and calls for a boycott of various bourgeois papers. The meeting calls on workers throughout Petrograd to support their resolution.

A mass meeting of 1,500 reserve soldiers and officers in Petrograd adopts a resolution condemning the slandering of workers by the bourgeois press. It appeals. to soldiers not to believe the lie that workers did not pay a price in blood to achieve freedom: "The working class was, is and will be the leader of any truly emancipatory movement."

General Alekseyev informs the Provisional Government that he has sent orders to all fronts to maintain censorship of any material designed to spread unrest in the army, and calls on the government to take the most decisive measures to guarantee that the army is free of discord."

Saturday 1 April The Kazan Soviet of workers land soldiers' deputies resolves to introduce the 8-hour working day. The Ufa Soviet resolves to demand of the Provisional Government immediate publication of a decree on the introduction of the 8-hour YEAR OF REVOL JTION working day for the entire country. Pravda publishes a resolution adopted by sailors on the cruiser Aurora on the question of the 8-hour werking day, and pledging the revolutionary solidarity of sailors of the fleet with workers fighting for further development of the revolution..

In an article entitled "Eight Hours": Pravda allacks ne agitation of bourgeois press in opposition to the 8-hour working day. It warns that this is an attempt to undermine the standing of the Soviets, and to incite soldiers against workers. Pravda announces the March total for its fighting fund: 15,750 roubles and 30 kopecks. The Provisional Government appeals for further financial assistance from Great Britain. Sunday 2 April The all-Russian meeting of Soviets agrees to convene an all-Russian congress of Soviets no later than 25 April.

On the Western front Russian troops repeatedly fraternise with the Germans, but on every occasion the fraternisation is broken up by artillery fire. In Balashov soldiers in the 141st reserve infantry reginent free arrested soldiers, burn down the zuardhouse, demolish the regimental offices, burn all documents and try to beat to death the regimental commander.

In Herson a meeting of tobacco and confectionery workers resolves to establish a trade union, and demands introduction of the 8-hour working day. In Odessa, the Executive Committee of the Soviet of officers' and soldiers' deputies appeals to all members of the garrison tosupport the Provisional Government and to obey orders.

Monday 3 April Lenin returns to Russia from exile in Switzerland. On arriving in Petrograd he addresses the masses of workers, soldiers and sailors gathered in the railway station square and calls for the victory of the socialist revolution.

The all-Russian meeting of Soviets concludes its business, adopting a series of resolutions without discussion and disperses.

A meeting of 3,000 sailors and soldiers. in Helsingfors adopts a resolution supporslander against the working class. It blames economic disruption on economic sabotage by the factory owners and pledges full support for the working class. A meeting of 6000 soldiers in Voronezh condemns the attempts of the bourgeois press to sow divisions between soldiers and workers. In Verny local military commanders and town officials are arrested on the instructions of a meeting of soldiers in the garrison. Tuesday 4 April Demonstrations are held throughout the country in memory of the Lena events, when gendarmes massacred unarmed demonstrators during a strike of 1912 in the Lena goldfields of Eastern Siberia. Mass meetings at the close of such demonstrations pass resolutions calling for the guilty gendarmes to be brought to justice, for a boycott of the bourgeois press, for the publication of all secret agreements concluded by the former regime, and for an end to the wan, The Omsk Soviet of workers" and military deputies resolves to introduce the 8-hour working day of its own accord after the failure of the industrialists to do so. The Provisional Government promises an amnesty for all deserters who return to the ranks by 15 May. Those who fail to de so will be pursued with the full rigour off the law.

A congress of teachers" representatives from all parts of Russia opens in Moscow. It resolves to support the Provisional Government, actively support defence of Russia in the war, and call for convocalion of a Constituent Assembly. Krupskaya (Lenin's companion-for-life) writes teachers reveals with utter clarity that the reaching masses are wholly under the influence of the bourgeoisie."

Stan Crooke

Scan page 8

Is the By Cliv SWP an alternative? : Bradley, Martin Thomas

----- pull-quotes -----

ting the introduction of the 8-hour work. ing day and condemning the campaign of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 308

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →