In this excerpt from 'the History of the Russian Revolution' Trotsky examines the reasons why Stalin and
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-04-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Kamenev, leaders of the Bolsheviks in the first months narty and how lenin managed the Provisional Government from the *The fundamental problem is to first as a hostile rampart unexpected- establish a democratic republic." In ly grown up in their path. The an instruction to the workers' Vyborg Committee (of Bolsheviks, in deputies, the Moscow Committee (of thousands of workers and soldiers, letariat aims to achieve freedom for which almost unanimously adopted the struggle for socialism, its ultimate resolutions on the necessity tor a goal." This traditional reference to seizure of power by the soviets. An the "ultimate goal" sufficiently emactive participant in this agitation, phasises the historic distance from Dingelstedt, testifies: "There was not socialism. Farther than this nobody one meeting, not one workers' ventured. The fear to go beyond the or with reservations, to the govern- and that in their place would appear ten teel, to te uncouvns or ten ment of the bourgeoisie did not have all kind of 'freedoms' proper to leaders. There were various conflicby any means the entire sympathy of bourgeois relations.
to turn the tide.
the party. The Bolshevik workers met St. Petersburg) held meetings meeting, which would have voted down such such a resolution from us if there had only been somebody to present it."
On the question of the social content of the revolution and the prospects of its development, the position of the Bolshevik leadership was no less cloudy. Shliapnikov recalls: *We agreed with the Mensheviks that we were passing through the period of the breakdown of feudal relations, Pravda said in its first number:
Bolsheviks) announced: "The proboundaries of a democratic revolution dictated a policy of waiting, of accommodaiton, and of actual retreat before the compromisers.
The lett Bolsheviks, especially the workers, tried with all their force to break through this quarantine. But they did not know how to refute the premise about the bourgeois character of the revolution and the danger of an isolation of the proletariat. They submitted, gritting tasha din stinno of thai ting currents in Bolshevism from the
Scan page 7
the tide
----- pull-quotes -----
of the revolution, failed to map out a coherent policy for the