Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Lenin turns

Socialist Organiser no. 308, 2 April 1987 · scan p. 6 · about 1,025 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

In 3 April, Lenin arrived in St. Petersburg from abroad. Only from that moment does the Bolshevik Party begin to speak out loud, and, what is more important, with its own voice.

For Bolshevism the first months of the revolution had been a period of bewilderment and vacillation. In the "manifesto" of the Bolshevik Central Committee, drawn up just after the victory of the insurrection, we read that "the workers of the shops and factories, and likewise the mutinied troops, must immediately elect their representatives to the Provisional Revolutionary Government."

The manifesto was printed in the official organ of the Soviet without comment or objection, as though the question were a purely academic one. But the leading Bolsheviks themselves also regarded their slogans as purely demonstrative. They behaved not like representatives of a proletarian party preparing an independent struggle for power, but like the left wing of a democracy, which, having announced its principles, intended for an indetinite time to play the part of loyal opposition.

In the Soviet on the next day, out of 400 deputies present, only 19 voted against the transfer of power to the bourgeoisie - and this although there were already forty in the Bolshevik faction. The voting itself passed off in a purely formal parliamentary manner, without any clear counterposition from the Bolsheviks, without conflict, and without any agitation whatever from the Bolshevik press.

This readiness to submit silently, 1919 Square. in very first day, but nu one of them carried its thoughts through to the end.

Although a Bolshevik almost from the very birth of Bolshevism, Kamenev had always stood on the right flank of the party. Not without theoretical foundations or political instinct, and with a large experience of factional struggle in Russia and a store of political observations made in Western Europe, Kamenev grasped better than most Bolsheviks the general ideas of Lenin, but he grasped them only in order to give them the mildest possible interpretation in practice. You could not expect from him either independence of judgement or initiative in action. A distinguished propagandist, orator, journalist, not brilliant but thoughtful Kamenev was especially valuable for negotiations with other parties and reconnoitres in other social circles - although from such excursions he always brought back with him a bit of some mood alien to the party. These characteristics of Kamenev were so obvious that almost nobody misjudged him as a political figure.

Stalin Stalin was a totally different type of Bolshevik, both in his psychological makeup and in the character of his party work: a strong but theoretically and politically primitive organiser. Whereas Kamenev as a publicist stayed for many years abroad with Lenin, where stood the theoretical forge of the party, Stalin as a so-called "practical" without theoretical viewpoint, without broad political interests, and without a knowledge of foreign languages, was inseparable from the Russian soil. Such party workers appeared abroad only on short visits to receive instructions, discuss their further problems, and return again to Russia. Stalin was distinguished among the practicals tor energy, persistence, and inventiveness in the matter of moves behind the scenes. Where Kamenev, as a natural result of his character, felt "embarrassed" by the practical conclusions of Bolshevism, Stalin on the contrary was inclined to defend the practical conclusions which he adopted without any mitigation whatever, uniting insistence with rudeness!

Opposite

Notwithstanding their opposite characters, it was no accident that Kamenev and Stalin occupied a common position at the beginning of the revolution: they supplemented each other. A revolutionary conception without a revolutionary will is like a watch with a broken spring. Kamenev was always behind the time - or rather beneath the tasks - of the revolution. But the absence of a broad political conception condemns the most willful revolutionist to indecisiveness in the presence of vast and complicated events. Stalin, the empiric, open to allen influences, not on the side of will but on the side of intellect. Thus it was that this publicist without decision, and this organiser without intellectual horizon, carried Bolshevism in March, 1917, to the very boundaries of Menshevism.

(Pravda) declared that the Bolsheviks would decisively support the Provisional Government in so far as it struggles against reaction or counterrevolution." (Kamenev and Stalin) expressed themselves no less categorically on the question of war:

While the German army obeys its Emperor, the Russian soldier must "stand firmly at his post answering bullet with bullet and shell with Soldiers celebrating the overthre shell". *Our slogan is not the meaningless "Down with War'. Our slogan is pressure upon the Provisional Government with the aim of compelling it...to make an attempt to induce all the warring countries to open immediate negotiations...and until then every man remains at his fighting post!

Defensists

Both the idea and its formulation are those of the defensists. The programme of pressure upon an imperialist government with the aim of "inducing" it to adopt a peace-loving form of activity was the programme of (the vacilating centrists of European socialism. It was anything but the programme of Lenin, who was calling for the overthrow of imperialist rule. Defending itself against the patriotic press, Pravda went even further: "All 'defeatism,' " it said, or rather what an undiscriminating press protected by the Tsar's censorship has branded with that name, died at the moment when the first revolutionary regiment appeared on the streets of St. Petersburg" • This was a direct abandonment of Lenin. *Defeatism" was not invented by a hostile press under the protection of a censorship, it was proclaimed by Lenin in the formula: * The defeat of Russia is the lesser evil'.

Pravda

When that number of Pravda was received in the factories, it produced a complete bewilderment among the members of the party and its sympathisers, and a sarcastic satisfaction among its enemies... The indignation in the party branches was enormous. Pravda was soon compelled to print a sharp protest from the Vyborg district: "If the paper does not want to lose the confidence of the workers, it must and will bring the light of revolutionary consciousness, no matter how painful it may be, to the bourgeois owls",

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 308

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →