Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

SWP support Kinnockites

Socialist Organiser no. 308, 2 April 1987 · scan p. 4 · about 1,202 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

• Socialist Organiser no.508 2nd Aprif 1987 bage 4 THE SWP's behaviour at NUS conference was bizarre. Initially they supported SSiN against NOLS. But, halfway through the conference they changed their line and voted for NOLS, giving a number of reasons for the change — each one of them false.

At conference they said that they wouldn't vote SSiN because the UJS voted for Simon Pottinger against Jo Gibbons the Deomeratic Left candidate. Some of them chanted at conference SSiN gets votes from Zionists.."

The SWP could not seriously mean that. If they did then one awaits their refusal to vote for Tony Benn as probably half the PLP who, more than getting Jewish votes, are actually Zionists.

If the SWP did mean it than they are sick. What they are saying is that anyone getting Jewish votes is tarnished. with? With what comrades of the SWP? But this could not be a reason for a change of line. The UJS declared their intention — well before Simon's election -and the SWP knew it. a So, there, had Jor: be another reason.y Socialist Worker (28 Match) says that during his hustings Simon Pottinger denounced the SWP as racist. In fact he did not. (Though later when the SWP began to chant "SSiN gets votes from Zionists na na na na, SSiN supporters did criticise them for implicit anti-semitism). Again this hardly marks a shift to the right of the conference. Our position on the issue has been clear for a year of more. Nothing new was said, and the SWP knew our position. So this could not be the reason for their change of line.

The final reason they give is that Liberals transferred their vote to us after their candidate was defeated. That is true. Liberal transfers went approximately 50% to SSIN, 50% to the Democratic Left. Of the 73 Liberal votes we got, between 50 and 60 were UJS votes. The other 13 or 23 were probably Liberals voting for us because they did not want the Democratic Left to seal-up' the sabbatical positions and thereby guarantee that anyone not in the Democratic Lett but on the NEC would be unmercifully, carved out.

Anyway, the SWP are in a ridiculous position. SSiN got perhaps 10 more 'Liberal' votes than the Democratic Left. The SWP are saying it is OK to vote DL because they got the real liberal votes but not SSiN because they get some real Liberal votes but mainly UJS votes going through the Liberals! There was no reason for the SWP to change their line. Nothing happened at conference to force them to change. Cynically, it is more reasonable to assume that the SWP knew that had to vote for Simon against the DL - that being the biggest Left-Right fight at conference - but they then wanted an excuse to vote for the DL after that - either because they do not want to promote their closet opposition OT because they were hoping that their long established relationship with the DI could be revitalised: they vote DL and in return they are guaranteed one NEC member.

Could it be that the explanation for the SWP's childish behaviour and grotesque oppotunism is — electoralism? official statistics. In the financial year 1984-5, Sheffield City Council spent in excess of £153 million on housing. In that same financial year the figure for Liverpool was £136,485,702. The 1985-6 figures for Sheffield were in excess of £163 million on their housing account, but the full figures for Liverpool are not available because of 'creative accounting'. The total capital budget we know to be £86,361,438. If Lawlor wants to find out how much was spent in a specific area of Liverpool he will be told by council staff that this is impossible because of the complications of accounting. Nobody really knows where, or on what, money is being spent - but Militant supporters continue to make wild and extravagant claims without possessing any proper figures.

We are certain to find that in areas such as education and social services, Liverpool City Council is woefully inadequate in comparison to other local authorities. They have been able to adopt a relatively larger housing expenditure a) by getting into debt to foreign bankers and b) by taking money away from other spending areas. These facts merely show the limitations of local government reformism. They are not virtues.

It is also important to note exactly where council house building is going on in Liverpool 8. This is an area of substantial white as well as black a population. In practice, very few of the new-build council house properties are going up in "black" areas. It is"

Harry Smith made this honest comment before the Tendency hacks could get to him with the 'correct line'. . But the following day, the accomplished liars in the Central Support Unit published this amazing satement:

*During the past two years, 15.6% of blacks who applied for jobs were appointed, compared to 11.88% of whites.

'This is obviously a step in the right direction. But under the present recruitment system most jobs are advertised only internally which meant that only 538 of the applicants were black, compared to 20,829 whites.

There are lies, and damned lies and then there are the statistics presented by the Militant Tendency. But it is nice to have some hard figures tor a change, even though they have been grudgingly flushed out as a response to a report from a select committee of a capitalist parliament! What we need to do, however, is to prsent them in a more honest light.

By their own admission, Militant say that only 84 blacks (ıncluding Sam Bond!) have been appointed to the City council workforce since they came to office in 1983. This compares to 2,475 whites. Therefore, of the total new appointments only just over 3% have been from ethnic in a city where blacks of the Liverpools revolution" in Liverpool?

Please remember also that Bond paid out over £1,200 to 'minders' for the purpose of breaking up a meeting critical of him which was due to take place in Liverpool 8. Note that the hysteria whipped-up against the caucus in the summer of 1985 bordered on a lynch-mob type of frenzy, when backward Militant hacks employed racist stereotypes -their opponents were "pimps and gangsters" — to justify their position.

In the months before it was disbanded, Liverpool District Labour Party had its aggregate meetings patrolled by uniformed security guards who verbally abused and intimidated anyone who had the gall to even question the 'Marxist' leadership.

Do you have Labour Party meetings like that in your neck of the woods, comrade Lawlor? Don't talk to us about violence and intimidation!

Finally, comrade Lawlor, try turning to the 20 February edition of Militant. Two articles are given over in that paper to the problems of Liverpool — without a single mention of the fact that over half the council workforce has been out on strike against the council, for one reason or another, over the past month. But then our three wise donkeys - Byrne, Mulhearn and Hatton -hear no evil, speak no evil and see no evil.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 308

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →