Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Our programme for Ireland

Socialist Organiser no. 308, 2 April 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · Jeremy Green · about 2,621 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Protestant demonstrators confront the RUC in Portadown. Photo: John Arthur, Reflex.

Socialist Organiser no.308 2nd April 1987 bage Our programme for Ireland is: socialism -- a socialist Ireland integrated into a Socialist Federation of Europe; thus, in passing, resolving the age-old conflict with Britain on the basis of British-Irish equality within the Socialist United States of Europe.

Only the working class can make Ireland socialist by conquering power. But the necessary unity of the Irish working class is held back and has for over a century been rendered impossible because of the chronic communal antagonism, centred in the north-east of the island. This antagonism runs through all classes in society.

In politics it is expressed on one side by unionism - the desire for close links or integration with Britain; and on the other by limited Home Rule - nationalism and by full scale - Republican separatism.

Contradiction

Irish history for over a hundred years has been dominated by the irresoluble contradiction between the Trish majority's commitment to Home Rule or separation from Britain and its commitment to Irish unity. A powerful Irish minority opposed even limited Irish local government (Home Rule) because, considering itself British and being vigorously Protestant, it refused to let itself become a mere minority in a Catholic The combination of the minority with a section of the British ruling class led to the rupture of Irish political unity and to the partition of In a process that began with a powerful, mainly Catholic movement for Home Rule, and then a powerful, mainly Protestant, Unionist countermovement, the people of Ireland achieved I not one but two Home Rules; and for the 26 Counties Home Rule quickly evolved into real (1936-7) and then even formal republican independence (1949).

But Partition was the opposite of a democratic solution. The Protestant minority were - with the exception of most of Ahtrim and Down -heavily interwóven with the other Irish community. A clear separating out of the minority was not possible.

Instead of'a democratic solution by way of the natural Irish minority PO Box 823, London SE15 INIA.

Он638 7065 Bias i chang orangem fe post Monday or by phone, Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony. Typesetting: Upstream Ltd MIRPublished by Socialist OrganiserLondon SE15 4NA.

Printed by ERst EnrOlfeat (TU), London E2.

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office.

Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the views of SocialistOnganiser. negotiating minority rights with the natural Irish majority, Partition brutally and arbitrarily cut Ireland in two - creating . a new, artificial Catholic minority in the North which was bigger as a proportion of the Six County population than all the Irish Protestants were in the whole of Ireland. This is no solution.

The late '60s Catholic revolt against their condition of being second class citizens in the Six Coun ties, and the IRA's 16 year long war against the British army and the state personnel of the Six Counties, is the proof that the Partition settlement imposed on the Irish majority in 1920 is as untenable as it is unjust and arbitrary.

Against the oppression of Ireland by Britain, socialists like Marx and Engels argued for an immediate democratic programme — for the Irish people's right to self-determination. "Socialism now' was not a sufficient answer to the national conflict in the pre-trish secession UK. The class unity or the British and Irish workers could best be secured if British socialists advocated the right of the Irish people to secede from the UK if they wanted to - and the majority did.

Against Britain in Ireland now; maintaining the artificial and undemocratic partition of Ireland with military force, self- determination for the people of Ireland as a whole remains the central democratic programme for British and Irish socialists.

In the light of the existence of one million people in Ireland who consider themselves British, the only possible democratic version of Irish self-determination - the only version that is working class and not bourgeois, or petty-bourgeois Irish chauvinist - is that which advocates a federal Ireland, in which, instead of Partition which creates two Irish minorities (one of them, the Six County Catholics, artiticial north of the Partition border, the natural Irish (Protestant) minority will be freely able to protect its interests and identiJust as it was no part of serious working class politics to counterpose socialism within the old UK to the Irish majority's desire for Home Rule, so now it is no part of Marxist politics to counterpose a socialist Ireland to a democratic solution of the conflict that divides the people of Ireland. The problem is to create the conditions - working class unity -that will make it possible for Irish workers to win socialism.

Mutual respect and guarantees against any attempt by either side to indulge in chauvinist trampling on the rights or susceptibilities of the other — that is now the precondition for Irish workers' unity on a mass scale. Immediately, the advocacy of such a programme is a precondition for advanced workers from both Northern Irish communities to be able to talk to each other and to the less advanced in their own com munities about class politics.

Given the attitudes of the one million Protestants, right now troops our aone stanas in at comradicuon to self-determination for the Irish people as a whole. Troops out alone is a programme that only expresses the politics of those who think that getting Britain out of Ireland is the highest goal, at whatever cost. However nationalist and 'for a single unitary Irish state' such people may think they are, in fact their version of troops out — without a political settlement - inevitably and inescapably means "dual self-determination'. manna idual calf datarmination Troops out without a prior political settlement would not liberate and allow self-determination to the Irish 32-country majority but would set the Protestant community completely adrift from Britain to seek its own self-determination by way of bloody civil war and repartition. Britain already has the most repressive labour law in Western Europe. Many of the laws which constrict the activities of British trade unions would themselves be illegal in other countries.

For example, in Spain, compulsory strike ballots before strike action would be unlawful - because they might hinder the right to strike, which is protected by the constitution. In Italy, workers may not be dismissed during a lawful dispute; in Greece and Portugal, employers cannot legally hire strike breakers.

However, the Tory government is not content with the existing level of repression. They believe that union bashing is a vote winner - so they plan to introduce a further round of ant-union laws. These new laws, set out in a Green Paper entitled Trade unions and their members, are designed to destroy both the individual workers' rights which trade unions have achieved for their members and the collective organisation which enabled them to do so. Attacks on individual rights include measures which will:

*Reduce workers" rights to pursue unfair dismissal claims;

*Remove wages council protection from young workers, so forcing them to undercut adult wages in low paid jobs;

*Deny women workers maternity rights, especially the right to return to their jobs after they have a child.

The real meat of the proposals, though, is an assault on the collective rights of workers which make effective trade union organisation posss ble. The Green Paper includes provi sions which will:

*Give strike breakers the legally protected right to cross picket lines, even if a majority of workers have voted to strike;

*Prevent trade unions from disciplining members who break union rules;

*Give government financial support to individuals who want to take legal action against union decisions even if those decisions are the result of a majority vote;

*End closed shops, even in workplaces where 85% of employees vote for them;

*Give individuals the right to examine unaudited trade union accounts;

*Sweep away existing trade union democracy and replace it with a single, postal, voting system.

It is no wonder that these proposals are being referred to in the labour movement as a "scabs' charter"; that is exactly what they are intended to be. Behind all the guff about "giving the unions back to their members" is a straightforward attempt to make almost any kind of collective action by workers impossible. Many forms of industrial action will simply be illegal. Most others will, in practice, be impossible -because the law will give massive protection to any minority of workers, however unrepresentative, who want to line up with the employers against their fellow workers.

For strike breakers, no expense will be spared to make sure that "their union" is given "back to them" A new body, along the lines of the Equal Opportunities Commission and the Commission for Racial Equality, wil be created to ensure that their legal rights will be upheld. Unlike the EOC and the CRE, though, this Scabs' Rights Commission will have the funds - and the statutory duty - to ensure that all • applications to it receive support,

Scan page 4

EASTER NUS Conference marked a shift to the right. Preparing the way for a Labour government the Democratic Left leadership of NUS abandoned past policies to bring NUS in line with Labour Party policy.

Despite previous positions of opposition to all cuts NUS now supports "alternative strategies' of cuts - which can only mean that Students' Unions should put forward plans for where they want cuts to be made. -Similarly, NUS is now in favour of colleges collaborating with the Universities Grants Committee (UGC) and the Polytechnic equivalent - NAB. In the past NUS has called for colleges to retuse to participate in 'rationalisation' plans.

NUS policy of opposition to all immigration controls was also junked at the behest of the Democratic Left.

The shift to the right started in colleges earlier this year and has been seen most clearly in both the lack of AD Jez Coulson IFL right national campaigns and the defeat of Labour candidates (of every hue) in Union elections this term. The blame for this drift lies firmly with the Democratic Leit. They themselves have moved rightwards and by their refusal to organise campaigns against the Tories there is no climate of opposition in colleges. NUS has not provided a credible strategy to defeat Tory attacks. Student Unions have retreated into being service centres and students have drawn the conlusion that there is nothing they can do.

Despite the shift to the right, SSIN candidates, Simon Pottinger, Michele Carlisle and Liz Millward were elected to the NEC (and SSiN candidate Stuart Beeston would have been elected but for a mathematical error by SSiN's organising team).

SSiN's fringe meetings were by far the largest at conference with over 150 attending one meeting. The SWP were knocked off NEC for the first time in years. Simon Lawlor (SO 302) says that *the Marxist programme' comes before the need to place blacks in positions of responsibility in the Labour Party. A statement like this naturally begs the question what exactly constitutes 'the Marxist programme?

I for one don't counterpose the advancement of blacks in the Labour Party society. in general to a "Marxist' programme. On the contrary, you can't have one without the other. Marx himself said that *Labour cannot emancipate itself in the white skin where in the black it is branded."

Are the social workers who struck against cuts in community care acting against the "Marxist programme"? Are the housing benefits staff in Liverpool betrayıng socialism because they demand greater physical protection at work?

Are the teachers, who struck because the Education Authority docked their pay for refusing to cover for absent colleagues similarly politically backward? Are we to condemn more than 1000 GMBAT members — led incidently by Militant supporter lan Lowes - for striking against council attempts to privatise landscape gardening work? Or the TGWU members at Speke airport who refused to sell their labour power at a low enough price for the 'socialist' city council to employ them?!

Nowadays it doesn't appear that it is just 'uppity blacks' who are against Militant-style 'Marxism'. They are joined by the majority of trade unionists employed by the council! In this respect, Militant have much in common with Eastern European 'socialist' regimes. The workers there, too, do not seem to identify their interests with the "Marxist programme" imposed by the elite.

Council leader Tony Byrne, together with Militant hack Andy Pink, made various attempts In January to call in full-time union regional officials to discipline the local workforce. In the opinion of Messrs Byrne and Pink the unions are now "running wild', 'out of control' and 'go on strike at the drop of a hat'!!

As to Liverpool Council's record as a house-builder, let us consult the FOR 14 years John Hamilton was the Labour leader on Liverpool council, for part of that time the boss of one of Britain's bi est cities. broken man. He has been kicked out of office by the and faces a E106,000 surcharge. At Today ne in politics, he faces the age bankrup caused by fighting for the city he s home if th loves, he would not care. But it wasn't. of the blame From the time he became Hamilton's deputy in 1983.

Hatton was the real boss. He was by tums brutal and charming He boasted he was a tough political oper ator, but really he most enjoyed the good life and the glare of his own publicity.

John Hamilton saw It all.

Now. for the first time, he telis the full, true and shocke ing story.

The bitter fruits of boss politics difficult to know the extent to which various ethnic groups benefit from new housing, of course, because the empty-headed Tendency does not agree with ethnic monitoring. It found it more comfortable to rule in the dark.

Discussing employment, Lawlor claims that 20% of the total new intake are black. But the parliamentary inquiry into black employment with local authorities has produced figures which serve to prove him wrong. This report said of Liverpool City Council that "In no other case did we hear such a sustained and bitter attack made on a local administration by members of the minority ethnic groups.""

When the Personnel Committee chair, Councillor Harry Smith was asked to comment on this he said: *There is no excuse, I cannot defend the fact that there are not as many black faces in council offices as there could be. We are trying to make changes and we want to employ more black people. But, sadly, a lot do not have the faith in us to apply for an interview any more." population.

Since most of these appointments have been advertised internally first, we cannot even conclude that there has been a total increase of more than 3% blacks in the council workforce. For all we know, all the black appointments might be people who already have a job with the city council! (And judging by what Harry Smith had to say this appears to be the case.

I think I have given enough hard information here to disprove the ridiculous talk of 20% of the new intake being black.

The charges that the Black Caucus used violence and intimidation against the Labour Party are laughable, when compared to the Tendency's antics. Don't forget that Hatton set the cops on Black Caucus supporters who were protesting against the Bond appointment in the council chambers. Or isn't police violence violence? Or are the police hugs working for Liverpool City Council — which Militant said was some sort of "workers' state" - no

----- pull-quotes -----

ty for as long as it chooses to, Counterpose

paper blues

GRA ONLIFE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 308

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →