Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Box Women starting to feel strong

Socialist Organiser no. 307, 19 March 1987 · scan p. 9 · about 1,113 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Belinda Weaver Who defines a woman's sexuality -- the woman herself or the person/s she is involved with? That question is bothering Nola, in the film 'She's Gotta Have If'. The film is set in Brooklyn, and has an all black cast, including the film's director Spike Lee, who shot the film in twelve days on a shoestring budget.

Nola is attractive, and is involved with three different men. She also has a lesbian admirer, Opal, whose advances she rejects. Nola is happy with her situation but the others aren't. Opal keeps trying to win her over, and all three men want Nola to choose between them. Each wants her for himself alone. Each man badmouths the others to Nola, while stressing his own qualties. And each, to some extent, implies that there's something wrong with Nola that she should want three men — it's just not normal!

The pressure begins to wear Nola down, and she begins to wonder if she's normal or not. She seeks advice, sees a therapist, tries to please each man in turn, then tries to choose between them.

In the end, she chooses the only sensible thing - to please herself, to define herself, and not let others do it for her.

This may sound like a feminist fable, but heavy it isn't. If anything, it's too light, too flippant. The film seems like a game, so you don't really care what happens. When Nola speaks at the start of the film about why she is allowing this investigation into her affairs, she's grinning as if it's all a joke.

The film also seems slightly voyeuristic in this look at a woman's sexuality. There are several sex scenes in the film, which serve to show Nola's different relationships with all three men. But the camera really lingers on Nola, and not on the men. Nola's body gets a much closer camera scrutiny than the men's do. Of course 'She's Gotta Have It' isn't the only film to do this. All too many films use female nudity as titillation. But in a film about a woman's sexuality, it is rather worrying to have the camera treat her as an object rather than a subject.

The lack of funds for the filmmaking is obvious, but not a drawback. Still photos are used in the beginning to set the scene, and it is *Last week 6 men attacked the church in Manchester where Viraj Mendis, threatened with deportation to Sri Lanka has been taking refuge.

The attackers' aim was to snatch Viraj. A supporter of the Viraj Mendis Campaign was stabbed in the Now Shoving edited out.

RACE AND Sexi comeoy The Sun NME ELLE cinema"

TIME OUT tle plot there is. The interaction Nola Old Bailey Broad Water Farm trial.

The boy, aged 16, has a mental age of 7. He was held in a cell for four hours before his interview and was not allowed access to a solicitor or his mother. A teacher who sat in on the interview was told that the juvenile's The film's basic problem is a weak plot that isn't really developed or taken seriously. Lee has proved you can make films on the cheap, and that a film with an all black cast made on the cheap can be a runaway box office hit. But it's not enough, if he's had to sell sex to prove it. one still faces a riot and affray charge. This leaves thre : men in the dock - Winston Silcoti (27), Engin Raghip (20) and Mark Braitl waite, who all deny the charges arisin ; from disturbances occuring in ctober 1985 in Tottenham. "She'll be wearing pink pyjan was the rather odd and putting title of last Thurs night's Channel 4 film. ( didn't wear them till right at end!) But the film itself wa gem, so hope you watched It was a fictional account of first women only Outward Bo course in Britain, and the e women who signed up for it. 1 ward Bound is a physical sur course, and the mere thought gives me the tremors. Even watc the women going through their tional paces made me yearn for a bath and a comfy bed.

The women underwent the kin physical misery usually reserved army recruits who don't get m choice in the matter once the signed up - shinning up ropes, ing into icy water, climbing st rocky slopes and hiking and cam in all weathers. No picnic! A hol for masochists, one might think.

A motley crew signed up for housewives of different ages, a h mistress, a bossy businesswoma doctor. I forget what Julie Wa who played Fran, did, but she the central character. Tough, fi and outspoken, she initially alien some of the women on the cour Discovery But the course forced them a face up to themselves, so it bec less a hike than a voyage of discovery. Each woman found den reserves to go beyond her no endurance. The support of the of helped each face up to her own blems and look again at the chi she'd made.

Men got discussed a lot. Fra first seemed the most intereste men. Only later did we learn tha had been celibate for three year prevent any more hurt from : (The film did cheat and hint future relationship with Tom, a l organiser of the course — he m over her earring).

But self-image rather than mi at the root of most of the won problems. None feels strong enc in the world to take her life and r of it what she wants. The course the sense of achievement it bri and the discussions with, and sup of, the other women help all act greater confidence.

It may all sound pat - wo climbs hill, and achieves the fidence to leave hubby — but the tue of the film is that it makes it: credible. The film carried you al it convinced.

The women did a fair bit of het complaining and a few tried to: off from the hard bits. The ce leader Anne had to do the ! Eastwood role of bullying and toring, but tinged with feminists tones. •Don't do it for me, do i yourselves'.

It was good to see a film good, strong roles for women of ferent ages. It was also good to women stepping out of normal r and looking unglamorous. The showed well the way women sup each other and give each other -fidence.

----- pull-quotes -----

reviews 'She's Gotta Have It'.

"You Gotta See Il!" "A bonafide Hip Hit" "Funny, pertinet... Deliberately proveking" DEREK MALCOLM - COSMOPOLITAN

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 307

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →