Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why ferry travel is risk

Socialist Organiser no. 307, 19 March 1987 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 755 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

On 25 August 1984 the ferry Olav Britannia collided with the Mont Louis, loaded with uranium hexofluoride. The Mont Louis sank, the ferry was barely dented and a few passengers were treated Socialist Organiser stands for workers' liberty, East and West. We aim to help organise the left wing in the Labour Party and trade unions to fight We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control. We want democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system — a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrat's and management's privileges. bet Socialist Organiser post. Rates: E8.50 for Name sua six months, E 16 for a year.

Enclose E London SE The disaster of the Herald of Free Enterprise was neither unexpected nor unavoidable. Several factors - some design, some practice but all to do with "free enterprise" and competition - conspired to consign some 140 people to a watery grave.

The scene was set when the Herald was designed for maximum speed, minimum turnaround time in port, maximum vehicle capacity and maximum attractiveness to passengers. Optional safety features, including warning systems were left out.

Stability was the key to the tragedy. For a ship this depends on the relation between two points - the centre of gravity (COG) and the centre of buoyancy (COB).

The COG is where the ship's weight seems to be concentrated. It "tries" to be as low as possible. The COB is where the upthrust of the water seems to act. If the COG is not below the COB, the ship will capsize.

Now you might think the safest thing would be to make the COG as low as possible by putting lots of heavy things low down. Such a ship would be impossible to capsize but would also be prone to pitch about a lot. The top of the ship, being relatively light, would be more easily affected by the waves. This would have many passengers reaching (retching?) for the paper bags.

Townsend Thoresen opted for greater comfort and a COG nearer to the COB. Loading the vehicle decks would raise the COG nearer still to the COB.

The next problem - ballast tanks at the bows were loaded to lower the entrance to the vehicle deck for ease of access. Ordinary ships spend hours adjusting ballast so they are evenIv laden before sailing. Ferries cannot afford I this valuable time and usually adjust ballast after sailing. Thus the Herald left with its bows lowered.

the other way? -.and with the bow doors open, there being no automatic warnings of this.

As the ferry turned sharply to port out of the harbour, it listed to starboard. This seems to have submerged part of the entrance, allowing water in. As it straightened up again it would have listed to port. This water would have surged across the deck without hindrance, making the list greater and allowing more water in. Finally, the unsecured vehicles would have slid across and the list became a capsize.

No-one in the ferry business can say the Herald disaster was unexpected. Marine consultant Dag Pike wrote some 18 months ago in New Scientist of various problems to do with ferries. These included danger of collisions (the Channel is the busiest waterway in the world), the difficulty of evacuating hundreds of frightened passengers from high-sided ships in the prescribed 30 minutes, slipshod attitudes to safety and the question of stability of high-sided ferries, such as the Herald. Pike wrote of their proneness to capsize, particuarly if they shipped water. Already European Gateway had capsized following a collision. In 1985 the International Marine Organisation was suposed to be looking at the safety of ro-ro ferries (roll-on, roll-off) but have still not reported. As Pike said, *the authorities seem to have their heads in the sand. It may take a disaster to effect any major change in that attitude.

Solutions to the dangers are not hard to find. For the Herald, warning lights for ballast distribution and open doors could have saved 140 lives. A vehicle deck in compartments or movable bulkheads might have stopped water sloshing around. Vehicle decks below the water-line, lower passenger decks for easier evacuation, automatic ballast adjustments and other changes that are possible.

AL bilannid

Scan page 9

"FRANK, FUNNY •.CANDIDLYS EROTIC" THE FACE Revi on the

----- pull-quotes -----

for shock, But suppose the accident had happened Socialist Organiser no 307 19 March 1987 Page 8 STAND

Britains death re squad 5 exposed!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 307

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →