Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The view of th Campaign for Democracy

Socialist Organiser no. 307, 19 March 1987 · scan p. 7 · about 1,247 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Andrew Wiard, Report hative view on the soft Left, represented by an article by Ken Livingstone in Tribune three weeks earlier.

Livingstone wants to reconstruct a soft Left independent of Kinnock. His formula is an alliance between eft MPs, the Labour Coordinating Committee, and Labour Left Liason a committee including the Women's Action Committee, Black Section, he Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, Socialist Action, Labour Brieting, and Socialist Organiser); it s not said in his article, but he wants Labour Left Liason purged of its nore left-wing elements.

According to Nigel Stanley, when LL was first set up "we were ssured that the troublesome Trotkyists of Briefing and Socialist Organiser would not be involved this ime, leaving only the cuddly side of he old man's thought" , and "some nfluential individuals associated with he realigned left were impressed".

Sketches

Livingstone sketches out a platorm for his left alliance. It does not nclude withdrawal from NATO -dentified by Nigel Stanley as one of he most objectionable policies of abour Left Liason. It does include "an end to all witch-hunts", the ther LLL plank most disliked by itanley: but how firm will LIvngstone be about that?

Nigel Stanley reckons that "part of alignment is putting gender and ace centre stage as well as class"; Livingstone agrees, but defines the reorientation as a redefinition of class politics rather than a turn away from it. In practice both have a very limited programme: constitutional reform within the Labour Party for women and blacks, and laws against discrimination.

What will they do about capitalism? Livingstone wants "to build on the job-creation policies of Labour councils" and "to toughen policy towards control of the financial sector"; Stanley finds such ideas "hard to disagree with" , but not detailed enough. All strands of the soft Left would do no more than tinker with capitalism: they would leave the ruling class and its ruthless profit-drive still dominating society, with all the class, sexual, and racial inequality that it brings.

The Left needs to regroup, and organise for a socialist voice within Labour's election campaign: but to do that, the Left needs to have socialist answers as clear-cut and decisive as the Tories' capitalist answers. As Arthur Scargill has put it: we need to organise and work for a government as loyal to our class as the Tories are to their class. The result of the Greenwich by-election demonstrates what should have been obvious for a long time. Wining the next General Election requires both Party unity and a programme that would make Labour a credible alternative to Thatcher. The present parliamentary leadership has failed to provide these requirements.

Its retreat from reforming, let alone socialist, policies has made Labour's programme almost indistinguishable from that of the Alliance. Instead of seeking to close Labour's ranks in the face of the very real threat of another five years of Thatcher, the leadership is dividing the Party by its continuous attacks on the Left!

Pathetic

Its pathetic attempts to distance itself from the Party's left wing has not produced electoral benefits but merely an image of a divided party.

Much has been said about the vicious press campaign against Deirdre Wood, Labour's candidate in Greenwich. On Polling Day, Vincent Hanna (Newsnight) let the cat out of the bag when he said " ...there was a period of three or four weeks when there was a lot of jockeying for position, and many interesting things were said about Deirdre Wood by prominent people in the Labour Party to political journalists, as part or the jockeying to get various candidates considered.

*And I think a lot of smears about Deirdre were well-placed in Fleet Street long before she was actually selected...So it is not completely the press's fault, though there is nobody I think, among the regular by-election comentaters...who would condone some of the disgusting things that were said in some of the newspapers.

Whoever furnished Fleet Street with damaging information about Deirdre Wood, this would not have happened had the leadership not condoned public attacks on Party members who hold left wing views. Marginalising the Left is hardly conducive to Party unity, but it does damage Labour's prospects.

The leadership's decision to reopen the issue of reselection must be seen in this context. It is a decision which will again divide the Party, and is also in defiance of the 1986 Conference decision on Resolution 39 (carried by 3,549,000 votes to 2,603,000) which reads:

*Conference recognises that the issue of reselection is both complex and divisive, and that to reopen the argument over new proposals would seriously damage Party unity and divert the Party's energies from the overriding priority of working for a Labour victory. Conference therefore calls on the National Executive Committee to refrain from bringing up such proposals before the next General Election", Yet only 7 weeks later we read in the minutes of the NEC (26.11.86) that:

"Consideration was given to the draft consultation paper relating to widening the franchise for the selection and reselection of MPs.

"During a lengthy discussion it was reported that the closing date for the receipt of views from parties and affiliated organisations had been amended to 31 July 1987.

Dennis Skinner then moved, seconded by Joan Maynard, "That he consultation not take place until after the General Election' "An amendment was then moved Evans, "That we proceed with the consultation and await the responses from affiliated organisations and Constituency Parties before further action, which will not in any event be before the next General Election."

"The amendment moved by Neil Kinnock, seconded by John Evans, was then carried by 16 votes to 12, voting being as follows:

"FOR: Ambler, Boothroyd, Tony Clarke, Colling, Dunwoody, Evans, Hattersley, Hough, Kinnock, McCluskie, O'Brien, Rogers, Sawyer, Short, Turnock.

"AGAINST: Benn, Blunkett, Eric Clarke, Dalyell, Douglas, Jeuda, Maynard, Meacher, Richardson, Skinner, Tierney, Wise, In the aftermath of Greenwich, Neil Kinnock has appealed to the Party not to indulge in recriminations — an appeal to which we hope all will any respond. des diso reported as mallurenand laie alon nannatad no sayıng:

"I have no time, and this Party has no time, for those who would rather win an argument with friends than win an election against enemies.

Pity It is a pity that he did not remember this when he induced the NEC, in this pre-election period to reopen the internal Party argument about reselection.

The consultative document has now gone to secretaries of CLPs and affiliated organisations. It reopens 'the argument over new proposals Ten proposals are made in the document. The NEC decision to initiate this consultation is in breach of the Conference decision, and a blow to Party unityBut why is the NEC so determined to ditch the present system that it is prepared to damage Labour's electoral chances and to ignore the Party's clearly expressed feelings on this issue? The answer is that under the present system, the body that makes the decision on whether or not to reselect is also the body that monitors the political performance of the MP on a monthly basis. This alone allows accountability to take place.

Without the pressure that the present form of reselection makes possible, a Labour government will be free - Just as it was before 1979 - to treat the views of the unions and constituency parties with contempt. From CLPD bulletin

----- pull-quotes -----

lor the Left there still no alternative n to realignment

Dur sing peor

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 307

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →