Labour after
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-03-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Martin Thomas takes a Greenwich by-election defeat, and at the lates Labour's right-wing is trying to use our bad showing in the opinion polls and at by-elections for their own purposes.
They say Labour needs unity their terms, and Labour needs drop or play down any radical controversial policies.
But the facts do not bear out their arguments.
Labour's poor showing is not due to left-wing candidates or left-wing campaigning. Labour does a lot less left-wing campaigning now than it used to, yet that has not helped matters. Labour did badly in Greenwich with a left-wing candidate; and just afterwards we did equally badly in the West Midlands Euro by-election with a right-wing candidate.
On the whole left-wing candidates do no better and no worse than rightwing candidates. What really makes a difference is how bold and confident and relevant the whole party is.
Left-wing policies shunned and badmouthed by Labour's leaders lose votes. Left-wing policies which offer real answers to the problems facing the working class, campaigned for properly, win votes.
Labour's poor showing is not due to the working class disappearing. Class divisions have got sharper, not softer. Traditional industries have declined - but the unemployed, and the workers in the new industries, are no less working-class than those in the traditional industries.
Labour's poor showing is not due to masses of people being convinced by Tory arguments and moving to the right. A recent large-scale survey showed that on redistribution of income, on nuclear weapons, on military spending, on the welfare state and nationalisations, and on abortion rights, opinion has shifted to the left since 1983.
Labour's poor showing is not due to the left dividing the party. The left has been very much in retreat over the last few years.
Hostile | But as the left has retreated, the right wing has come after us. So Labour still looks divided - and, what's worse, Labour's leaders show themselves to be ashamed of, embarrassed by, and hostile to the Party's offered to the working class by official Labour leaders.
Two factors have turned the longstanding cynicism and disillusion into a big declne for Labour in recent First, the depth of Britain's economic and social crisis has led working class voters to look for new answers. Vague talk from Labour leaders about tried and tested' methods of Keynesian reflation is not enough.
Labour's leaders, too, have lost faith in "1945 socialism' (if they ever had any) and increasingly offer no clear message at all.
Second, the existence of the Alliance as an apparently viable, apparently new, anti-Tory option means that Labour does not automatically get the anti-Tory vote.
Showbiz
Gimmicks, pastel shades, direct mailing, expensive advertising, and other showbiz politics cannot substitute for real political answers to real questions. Labour has to offer answers — and, centrally, answers on the big bread-and-butter questions of jobs, housing, education, health, racism and women's rights.
That requires democratic planning of the economy — to guarantee everyone a useful and properly-paid job - and therefore public ownership and workers' control of the decisive sectors of industry and Finance. The working class has to take over the wealth now monopolised by a small minority, and use it for human need, not for profit. Social provision has to be not only rescued from Tory cuts, but greatly expandCU.
Restore
Yet Neil Kinnock will not even undertake to restore Tory cuts. Renationalisation of enterprises sold off by the Tories has been put off to the misty future.
Most of Labour's left has never really fought the right wing on the central economic issues. It has seen greater possibilities of achieving something if it concentrates on issues like nuclear disarmament or lesbian and gay rights, and leaves open the field on economic questions.
But that does not work. As those policies become radical excess baggage, they are generally treated as an embarrassment and finally ditched.
The Greater London Council managed to keep a fair level of support for two reasons. It had a lot of money, because it could draw income in rates from the huge properties of the City and Westminster. And alongside its policies for a variety of special oppressed groups, it was able to make improvements in, the basic service it ran for everyone, transport.
Other left-wing councils are running into trouble now because they have no money and they can't do anything to improve their basic services, like housing. When council Kinnock and Deirdre Wood. Photo
----- pull-quotes -----
vich moves left. non-class, "national interest' politics
the prospects Labour after the on the Labour