South Africa: the NUM and working class politics
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-03-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Semil feen Raisd et rod on heinerlo teileisde Socialist Organiser no 307 19 March 1987 Page 5 The recent congress of the 360,000-strong National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), South Africa's largest and potentially most powerful union, represented a further step in the development of the politics of the independent trade unions.
The NUM committed itself to the struggle against capitalism in South Africa and stated quite explicitly the link between the struggle for democracy and the struggle for working class rule. This is how the preamble to the adopted conference resolution on political action described the struggle:/ The workers* struggle in the mines cannot be separated from the struggle in the community...apartheid and capitalism are two inseparable evils that must be smashed."
The conference saw a giant banner unfolded bearing the words *Socialism means freedom" . By all accounts, the mood of the worker delegates and shaft stewards at the conference was militantly anticapitalist.
There was much talk from the delegates of "a democratic socialist society controlled by the working class" . The model on which this talk of socialism is based is the experience of rank and file worker control in the independent unions, the only real democracy black workers have experienced.
Charter Probably the most important political development was the increased identification of the NUM with the dominant African National Congress (ANC) tradition of resistance politics, represented today inside the country by the United Democratic Front (UDF).
The conference adopted the Freedom Charter of the ANC which calls for a society in which:
*The people shall govern.
*All national groups shall enjoy equal rights.
*The people shall share country's wealth.
*The land shall be shared those who work it.
*All shall be equal before the law.
*All shall enjoy human rights.
*There shall be work and security.
*The doors of learning and culture shall be opened.
*There shall be houses, security and comfort.
*There shall be peace and friendship.
Cyril Ramaphosa, the NUM general secretary, described the Charter as "a guiding document in the struggle against national oppres sion and economic exploitation"
And he went on: "the Congress of the People which was held in Kliptown on June 26, 1955, was representative of all patriotic forces in our country when the Congress adopted a programme of minimum demands which came to be known as the Freedom Charter"
A giant poster of Nelson Mandela, who is the union's honorary president, was also displayed at the rally after the conference.
Winnie Mandela, addressing the conference, said that it was an illusion" that the miners or the workers' movement as a whole could distance themselves from the "mass struggle, or the popular people's movement for freedom"
In addition the union committed itself to fighting for a living wage (an across the board increase of 55%) and for an end to the migrant labour system, for workers" self-defence and Anne Mack takes a look at some of the implications of the political line recently adopted by South Africa's giant National Union of Mineworkers an end to the tibal induna" system in the mine hostels.
The NUM threatened a day of action against the State of EmergencyThe task of the union in the words of President James Motlatsi, was to encourage mineworkers to 'take control' of every aspect of their lives. All this points to a major confrontation between the NUM and the government and employers in the near future, The oppressed black workers have a powerful urge for unity. And the methods of working class organisation and struggle - accountability, democracy, mandates, report-backs, rank-and-file control and discipline - have shown themselves to be the most successful means of sustaining the liberation movement as a whole in the face of repression.
Unity in the struggle, even in some cases between working class and non working class organisations over specific issues is to be welcomed.
Nor should socialists bemoan the adoption by the NUM of the Freedom Charter.
Socialists should be critical of the Freedom Charter - but not because there is anything wrong with a democratic programme. The problem with the Charter is that it is not democratic enough, and it spells out no clear working class demands. Furthermore the strategy that often accompanies the Charter, the two-stage revolution - first democracy, then socialism at some time in the future - is flawed.
The problem and danger is that the unity that is being created at the moment appears to be a long term strategic unity without there actually being agreement on long-term strategic goals.
Part of the cause of this problem lies in the limitations of the initial political line taken by COSATU.
That policy was spelt out by Cyril Ramaphosa:
"Workers' political strength depends upon building strong and militant organisation in the workplace.
"We also have to realise that organised workers are not representative of the working class as a whole but are its most effective weapon...It is important that the politics of the working class eventually becomes the politics of all the oppressed in this country".
Ambiguities
This advanced position also tained ambiguities.
COSATU's founding political and economic statements, though more concrete and detailed than the Freedom Charter which at times they evoke, and containing specific working class rights such as the right to strike which is not contained in the Charter, still maintained a deep ambiguity as to the class nature of post-apartheid society.
This is how Jay Naidoo, general secretary of COSATU, explained the union's policy:
"So change does not just mean only a new government with a different colour skin. It must be a change to a real democracy that benefits the people who produce the wealth of the Diack miners Have massive pole country - the working class.
-Workers must lead the struggle for freedom. And after liberation they must be the leaders in the making of a new society."
Naidoo is clearly implying socialism here. But his argument can also be compatible with that of some South African Communist Party (SACP) theorists who stress the 'linked' nature of the democratic and socialist tasks in the South African revolution. These same writers do not specify if the new society' would be a workers' democracy.
The alternative to the workers' movement specitying the class nature of post-apartheid society is strategic incoherence.
Is it possible to say that the working class should lead the political struggle, and take power through their own organisations and at the same time allow another class to rule economically? The entire history of the international workers' movement suggests that such an option is impossible. Either the workers would be forced to go on and establish their own economic rule, or working class poltical power will be replaced by restabilised capitalist power.
COSATU and all the independent trade unions have to address this dilemma. A coherent working class strategy must include a struggle for a workers' government and a break with the power of capital as an immediate objective, i.e. as the governmental alternative for the workers' movement to the crisis of apartheid The problem is that the search for clarity on this question on the part of unions like the NUM or MAWU -preted as 'divisive' in terms of the strategic goals of the struggle as defined by forces in the popular movement such as the ANC and the UDF. For the ANC/UDF leaderships are clearly not in favour of a struggle for socialism. ELIGI DUVVGE For instance, Nelson Mandela before he was imprisoned interpreted the 'nationalisation' clauses in the Freedom Charter in the following way:
*It is true that in demanding the nationalisation of the banks, the gold mines and the land, the Charter strikes a fatal blow at the financial and gold mining monopolies and farming interests...But such a step is absolutely imperative and necessary because the realisation of the Charter is inconceivabie...until the monopolies are first smashed up and the national wealth of the country turned over to the people.
"The breaking up of these monopolies will open up fresh fields for the development of a nonEuropean bourgeois class. For the first time in the history of the country the non-European bourgeoisie will have the opportunity to own in its own home and right mills and factories and trade and private enterprise will boom and flourish as never before.
*The workers are the principal force upon which the democratic movement should rely but to repel the savage onslaught of the nationalist government and to develop the fight for democratic rights it is necessary that the other classes and groupings be joined. Non-European traders and business men are also potential allies."
Strategy This sums up Mandela's strategy: a broad, multi-class alliance against apartheid, with the working class as a stage army rather than the leading class, and a model of post-apartheid South Africa which is explicitly capitalist.
Oliver Tambo has reitereated on several occasions recently that this is still the basic strategy of the ANC.
According to Anthony Sampson after the famous meeting in Lusaka between liberal" capitalists and the ANC leadership, the capitalists came away with the strong impression that the ANC's model for a future South Africa was a 'mixed economy' on the lines of Sweden. Tambo has said nothing to contradict this. Joe Slovo of the SACP has underlined this approach by calling for the support of patriotic businessmen of 'good faith' This is clearly a conception of a new society in which the working class would not rule. Further, some of the "socialists' in the ANC/UDF camp have a model of socialism -Eastern Europe — which the most advanced forces in the unions rightly find repellent.
Advocates of a 'convergence between the unions and the UDF/ANC as part of a socialist strategy in South Africa are therefore faced with a problem.
The different components of this long-term alliance have very different goals. This points to a second problem with COSATU's basic position as expounded by Ramaphosa. The NUM leader talks at a time when working class politics "eventually become the politics of all the oppressed in this country' Given the differences that obviously do exist between different forces within the liberation movement, it is difficult to see how Ramaphosa's position does not necessarily entail a struggle of different "class politics" for leadership of the liberation movement.
The question is how best to pursue the struggle for working class leadership.
One of the alternatives to a convergence' of the popular movement and the trade unions, is to build a mass workers' party based on the trades unions.
A workers' party would not summon strategic differences into existence. They exist already. What such an organisation could potentially do is provide a specifically political vehicle for ensuring that "the politics of the working class eventually becomes the politics of all the oppressed."
Conscious
Because of its social nature, the working class needs conscious, open political organisation like no other class in history has needed it. The working class cannot grow organically to the position of dominant class as a result of economic development in the sense that the bourgeoisie did in the period preceding the great bourgeois-democratic anti-feudal revolutions.
Nor can the working class come to power semi-spontaneously as a result of the collapse or partial disintegration of the existing state.
The working class can only triumph consciously. This means that the workers can only become *the leading class of the nation" through a process of political, ideological and economic struggle. This struggle will first and foremost have to be directed against the old order; but working class leadership necessarily implies a struggle against other classes who project themselves as leaders of the nation"
Conversely, it is ditticult to see now a capitalist, post-apartheid South Africa could be created without a section of the popular movement in alliance with South African and international capital attempting seriously to defeat and disorganise the workers' movement.
So, the recent political turn by the NUM should not be seen as closing down the option of building a workers' party. Rather it has made that task more urgent.