Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Russian Rev and women

Socialist Organiser no. 306, 12 March 1987 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,261 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Can socialism open the of 1917 was, however, themselves socialist is the suppression of the not encouraging. Lynn revolutionary working the workers' revolution Stalinist bureaucracy.

class struggle rather than utopia- the proletariat... ideas as "both reactionary and Uto- domination over woman in the pian" because they tried to run modern family, and the necessity, as society is a mass composed solely of matter. Society takes care of all individual families as its children equally, irrespective of molecules...In the family, (the man) whether they are born in wedlock or is the bourgeois; the wife represents not" - and, Engels adds, this will 1917. What would happen to all the women workers brought into the factories during the war? WOMEN have been oppressed for thousands of years but the programme of women's liberation dates from recent times — together with the ideas of human rights, democracy, and equality.

The early 19th century socialists -the most radical and thorough of the advocates of the idea of human emancipation or liberation which was launched by the American and French Revolutions — were also advocates of women's emancipation. Charles Fourier declared: "The degree of emancipation of women is the natural measure of general emancipation."

Fourier, writing in 1808, also went beyond legal tormalities in his programme tor equality. People would be housed in large bufldings which would be equipped with various services including creches. Young children would be cared for communally. There would be communal restaurants and public rooms.." Robert Owen had similar ideas.

There were exceptions in the socialist movement. Until relatively late in the 19th century there was a strong current of proletarian antifeminism', represented by such leaders as Proudhon and Lassalle. They reflected the element in the working class that looked backward - to the old patriarchal household economy - rather than forward. Claiming they wished to protect women, they opposed women's employment in industry.

Marx and Engels interpreted the programme of their more radical predecessors into a perspective of way to women's liberation? The experience of the USSR and other societies which call Ferguson argues that building; they opposed Proudhon's Dackwards away on that class struggle.

In 'Origin of the Family' (1884) Engels endeavoured to use the researches of the US anthropologist Lewis Morgan to map the evolution of women's position. The attempt has been criticised in the light of later research, but the approach was a lasting scientific advance. The position of women was discussed in terms of the changing material conditions that determined it, not just in terms of abstract moral rights and wrongs.

Engels also summarised the socialist programme: *The modern individual family is based on the open or disguised domestic enslavement of the woman; and modern a revolution for position of women went hand-in-hand with class by the new The peculiar character of man's mAll tha MARAN antahlinh wen as une manner, of establishiilg real social equality between the two will be brought out into full relief only when both are completely equal before the law. It will then become evident that the first premise for the emancipation of women is the reintroduction of the entire female sex into public industry; and that this again demands that the quality possessed by the individual family of being the economic unit of society be abolished...

*With the passage of the means of production into common property, the individual family ceases to be the economic unit of society. Private housekeeping is transformed into a social industry. The care and education of the children becomes a public underpin a great expansion In Germany, the basic ideas worked out by Marx and Engels (building on previous socialists) were bulked out a great deal by the experience of a proletarian women's movement, led by Clara Zetkin.

The Bolsheviks, under the leadership of Kollontai, Inessa Armand and Samoslova, were pupils of Zetkin and the Gernian movement in relation to organising women.

On taking power the Bolsheviks abolished all reactionary laws relating to women, and established full political and legal equality for women. Freedom of divorce, abortion, etc., were introduced. Special trains were organised to take birth control facilities into remote areas. All laws against homosexuality were scrapped until 1934. "The presentation of homosexuality in the great Soviet encyclopaedia was based on Magnus Hirschfeld and partly on Freud" '. (Hirschfeld was a pioneer for homosexual rights in Germany).

And a great beginning was made towards freeing women from domestic toil. Communal kitchens, laundries and creches were establishE But these facilities were always far from adequate both in terms of quality and quantity. Trotsky wrote:

*Moreover, the existing creches, even in Moscow, Leningrad, and the other centres, are not satisfactory as a general rule to the least fastidious demands. 'A creche in which the child feels worse than he does at home is not a creche but a bad orphan asylum', complains a leading Soviet newspaper. It is no wonder that the better-placed workers' families avoid creches."

The same applied to other facilities. The communal dining halls left much to be desired when compared to "home cooking". The laundries did virtually everything but return your laundry clean and fit for use. None of this is particularly surprising, if we think about the nature of the Soviet Union at this time - a materially backward country, with a predominantly peasant economy, where the First World War was followed by the revolution and then civil war in defence of the revolution.

Shortage

There were severe shortag es of the basic necessities of life. Gi ven that the precondition for the soci alisation of housework and childcare is a high level of economic developme int, most of the attempts made in t he early years of the Soviet state wet te bound to be utopian.

Trotsky warned that on ily "our children and grandchildr en will realise this aim" of wome en's full emancipation. Some Bol Isheviks, however, went in for doctrin laire fancies.

"Acute food shortages rat ther than the exigencies of socialist th leory led to a large extension of cc ammunal feeding. The vast prob lem of homeless children imposed on reluctant and overburdened at athorities the establishment of children I's homes

IC

Clara Zetkin, of the German socialist and settlements. In this aspect of war communism, as in others, doctrine was invoked to prove that what was done in the emergency of war was identical with what had long been included in the cherished precepts of socialist programmes...(Though from 1925 the state had to resort to foster-parents instead).

*The sequence of war, revolution and civil war had produced many of the same unpremeditated and disintegrating effects on family and sex relations as on other aspects of social lite. Here too, 'war communism' marked a specific period; and here, too, what in other conditions would have been treated as the unwelcome result of chaos, confusion and licence was now retrospectively, justified in terms of socialist doctrine. " (EH Carr, 'Socialism in One Country', Vol 1., p.27)

Lenin and Trotsky had to figh against fantasists and utopians on this front as on the fronts economic policy, military and diplomatic policy, art, etc.

The theses presented to the Third Congress of the Comintern in 1921 argued for active efforts to involve women in all aspects of Soviet society. It was also the responsibility of the party to fight an ideological battle against backward attitudes towards women amongst the working class, and particularly the peasantry. Lenin criticised the backwardness and com-placency, of, many male party members:

Scan page 7

oution

----- pull-quotes -----

women, too; and the worsening of the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 306

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →