Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialism has got a future!

Socialist Organiser no. 306, 12 March 1987 · scan p. 3 · about 862 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The idea of socialism has come in for quite a hammering in recent years. The Tories have an evangelical mission to wipe 'socialism' from the political map. The Alliance are little different. And even the Labour Party leaders have progressively ditched all mention of social.

ism in an effort to win votes.

With this in mind, the New Statesman magazine last week ran a feature entitled 'Socialism - A Future?' • Kicked off by Labour Party deputy leader Roy Hattersley, the discussion includes contributions from Eurocommunist writer Eric Hobsbawm, from Inner London Education chief Frances Morrell, and from Paul Hirst, an ex-Maoist turned right-wing Labour university professor.

Advocating 'market socialism, one contributor notes that "leaves little for the unions to do.

But "if the purposes of unions are being served by other, better means, then no one except those with a personal interest in their survival should mourn their demise."

"Since market socialism does not involve the actual expropriation of capital, it is less vulnerable to it than most other forms."

Paul Hirst declares: "Socialism is in no sense committed by its basic values to such institutions as central planning and state ownership.

Indeed, it should be opposed to them." A socialist society "presocialist Organice PO Box 823, London SE15 NA Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone, Monday evening.

Editor: John O'Mahony.

Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU).

Published by Socialist Orgniser POIBox 82B, London SE15 4NA.

Printed by East End Offset (TU), London E2.

Registered esza «емраренет the Post Office.

Signed artifies demot lacessari yurerlect the erasmo Socialist Unganiser. supposes bargaining rather than planning."

And Hirst openly admits his ideological lineage. Referring to the German socialist Edward Bernstein who argued nearly a century ago that socialism was impossible and Marxism out of date, Hirst comments: "He became a political leper...But he was right."

Flawed

The lines of thinking expressed in the New Statesman (and there are differences - not all the contributors are Roy Hattersleys) are widespread and popular in the Labour Party. They are the political wing of trade union 'New Realism' But they are fundamentally flawed The 'new revisionists' , as they are often called, and probably like to think of themselves, accept as a point of departure the Tories claims that socialism has been tried, failed and proved unpopular. But socialism has never been tried. What has failed is not socialism, but the traditional Labourite, bureaucratic "welfare capitalism' Socialism requires, as a minimum, grass-roots democratic control over political power, and over day-to-day work. It means working class political and social power, making collective decisions based on what people need - not on what will make the fattest profits. For it to be possible to fulfill people's needs, socialism will have to be an international evetem And it does need planning: not the planning of faceless bureaucrats, but the active participation of people in deciding how to direct resources. Democratic planning will have to take priority over the market, and eventually market mechanisms will die out. In the long run, market mechanisms and real social control are incompatible.

The problem for the labour movement is that it has never fught for such a socialist future. Our answer to the Tory evangelists should not be to renounce this future, but to reassert it, and fight to commit the labour movement to it It is a future that can be won only by the mass action of rank and file workers, taking control over their own lives, by mass action and self-management like that fought for by Poland's Solidarnosc.

Working out nice ideas about "market socialism' in which unions play no role is irrelevant to the real world a real world of class struggle. Paul Hirst, at least, partially acknowledges that this world exists:

"The 'veto group' against socialism is a large one [but] is not confined to a minority of wealthy bourgeois. It will ruthlessly resist and destroy a legal socialist government and if it fails to do so it will solicit the help of foreign allies."

Indeed in the miners' strike we saw a foretaste of the ruthlessness of this veto group', But what is Hirst's conclusion? He argues that we should "not abandon socialism" because it "is not only a narrow political enterprise, it is also based on certain fundamental principles about how society should be organised..

But his is a feeble conclusion. In fact capitalism is based upon the wealth and power of big business They will do whatever they can to defend their wealth and power Time and time again we have seen.

vokes their "ruthless veto"

The distinctly non-insurrectionary President Allende of Chile was: overthrown in a bloody coup in 1973. To fight for socialism, the working class will have to be prepared to defend itself. "Insurrection" - or revolution - is not an option: it will be a necessity.

The New Statesman special does not answer the question of how to fight for socialism. It abandons socialism as an objective - except that none of the contributors ever knew what socialism was in the first place.

----- pull-quotes -----

that not only the 'insurrectionary socialism' so despised by Hirst pro-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 306

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →