Is Paul Simon a sell-out? CLASS
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-03-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Many people in Britain who have no previous experience of popular African music have widened their musical horizons.
However, Artists Against Apartheid claim that the act of recording the album in South Africa breaks their line of no performance/recording in South Africa, and thus Simon is now on the Artists Against Apartheid offenders' list.
Simon himself claims that he had prior approval from the ANC, but some ANC leaders are now for the "boycotting' of Simon's music.
Two well-known South African anti-apartheid musicians, Hugh Maskela and Miriam Makeba, have decided to tour with Simon. Within the popular left' press this has been portrayed as a great sell-out. It's likely that Artists Against Apartheid will picket any live performance by Simon.
'Isolate apartheid' has been a catch-phrase and a basic starting point for the Anti-Apartheid movement for many years.
Socialist Organiser, over the years, has criticised the way this position is The same problem arises with the "cultural boycott of South Africa.
On one level, of course, every genuine anti-apartheid campaigner 1s for the picketing, boycotting, etc., of any group of people who are over hére for the purpose of defending the racist apartheid regime. However the boycott has been used in an arbitrary manner, The cultural level and the political level should mirror one another. In contrast to the general drift of the Anti-Apartheid Movement, we should be for the development of "cultural links' of all sorts with anti-apartheid South Africans. palates or apisation calls this The villagers in the jungle didn't ask visionary Allie to bring them his "progress' , yet he foists himself on them as if he were on a God-given mission. They have little choice but to knuckle under. Then their home is destroyed, the river polluted, and they are forced to flee where they can. Sounds familiar?
Industries which have exhausted an area, or have had severe accidents which make the region uninhabitable, can simply move on to greener pastures, and set about the same thing again, as Allie does in the film, having destroyed the lives of those he supposedly came to help.
Many people seek to turn their backs on society. Seeing the world threatened by nuclear war makes people frightened. Many people, like Allie Fox, loathe the deadening consumerism of capitalist society.
Yet even in the jungle there is no escape. The only answer is to stay and fight to overthrow the capitalist system.
Outcast
Although exceptionally bright and "well read" she was a social outcast. (I hate that term "well read" - I'd never come across it till I went to university. This seemingly harmless little phrase is much used by the Camillas and Philippas during freshers' week it's riddled with so much middle class snobbery).
Kay soon found that her Home Counties chums couldn't quite take to someone from Widnes.
I mean, Widnes of all places. Oh. the stigma of it!
She got into huge debt trying to keep up with the social circle - she nearly had a nervous breakdown and had to leave after less than a year's study!
I don't think Kay is untypical.Many of us go through the education system either feeling out of place or that all this stuff about coffee from Brazil, Rasputin or Laurie Lee has little to do with our lives or "prospects"!
Scan page 10
through the local Labour Party, even ween £1.30 and f3.25 per week. CATALE **1*..1*8 The arguments they are using to general election put at risk. for years that something like this was justify the abandoning of City Party bound to happen. The party, it policy have a familiar ring to them. swallow these increases, what about seems, has been lulled into a false There is no time to mount a cam- next year? The situation is likely to be sense of security that the crisis could paign before the budget has to be set. much worse then, with or without a Deficit budgets are illegal and Labour government. 100% rate rises Labour Group leadership, who must councillors wouldn't vote for it. The and £10 a week rent increases? have known differently, did nothing deficit budget may put jobs and services at risk when the money runs out easy option. It is made that much The City Party, at a recent and the unions wouldn't support it. harder if the need for a fight isn't exThe student movement and the labour movement have made not an inch of progress as a result of last weekend's conference of the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS).
The same problems still beset NOLS and the National Union of Students and in fact one particular problem — the position of NOLS on the Middle East - has become even more confused.
NOLS still has a pro-Palestinian position which, as far as it goes, is fine. And the campaign mandates are equally good - they were common to most motions up for discussion. But NOLS now has no position or whether or not the Israeli Jews have the right to a state. Both the "democratic secular state' position and the 'two states' line were voted down.
The past practices of the Democratic Left' are to blame for Manchester City Council's budget crisis — so often promised and postponed - has finally arrived.
Even with a whole range of creative accounting measures, including selling the ground that schools and other council buildings stand on and leasing it back, the gap between income and expenditure is €33 million.
This gap, it seems, cannot be bridged by any more of the clever tricks that have been used in previous Obvious te news nas sent snock waves though it has been obvious to people once again be avoided - and the By Pete Keenlyside meeting, laid down a clear policy for a budget. This was: no cuts in jobs or services; no rent increase; a rate increase around the level of inflation; an ama of creative accoullung measures; and a deferred budget if this should prove necessary, with a campaign to explain these policies.
Instead of working out how to implement this, certain leading elements in the Labour Group and Party are now running around trying to get these policies changed. What they now want is a rent and rate rise to meet the gap.
The figures they are talking about are rate increases of between 25% and 150% and rent increaces of hat Taken in isolation, all these points are true enough. But the City Council isn't being-run in isolation.
It is operating in a period of ever-increasing attacks on working class living standards and in the run up to an election.
Putting up the rent and rates will be a disaster in electoral terms. Working people will resent being made to pay for the Tories' cuts and it will cause demoralisation and confusion among party activists.
Lost
All we have gained from the Tories in recent years could be lost as a non-Labour seat in Manchester at the result. and the winnino of tha ana Even if workers are prepared to Fighting the Tories now is never an plained and the fight itself put off year after year.
Yet there is no other option that doesn't involve raising the white flag. The call for action from the Labour Group and the City Party, clearly explained and argued for, could even at this late stage win widespread support.
It could lay the basis for defeating the Tories at the polls and forcing an incoming Labour government to rescue Labour councils from the mess they are in.
The City Party in Manchester spent ten years trying to get a council leadership that was prepared to take on the Tories. We didn't fight all that time just to put the rents and rates up by record amounts.
If the Labour Group ducks this fight then it will be no better than the one that went before it. The City Party must maintain its present position on the budget and force the Labour Group to carry it out.
Socialist Organiser supporters will be fighting for this demand and we urge all other militants in the Manchester Labour Party to join with us.
----- pull-quotes -----
305.5 anchester's budget crunch
ISN By Jane Ashworth
to discourage this complacency. nester'