Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[by the Tsar, was regarded by all The…]

Socialist Organiser no. 305, 5 March 1987 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,452 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

by the Tsar, was regarded by all The Russian revolution, Russian revolution was The Russian revolution, Russian revolution was radicals and socialists in Europe which began seventy 1917, transformed the hope and inspiration to opportunities were lost: they occured, week by fought for by Lenin and revolution and the the other leaders of the revolutionary socialist The Russian by the Tsar, radicals and The Russian empire, ruled over which began seventy as the citadel of the most brutal years ago, in March reaction.

A powerful and extremely bureaucratic state ruled over a society modern world. It that was, for the most part, barely out of the Dark Ages. Millions of opened up the people lived in terribly backward possibility of a conditions in the countryside, while the Tsar regarded himself as a completely new tepresentative of God on earth, society, not just in By the turn of the century there was a small industrial working class, Russia but across the grouped together in huge factories — world. In fact the many of which were owned by foreign firms, or funded by the State.

A socialist movement was to develop the regime in Russia among those workers.

But the early Marxists had to com- today, or in similar pete with other political movements.

The most powerful of these was a societies, is a far cry movement called the 'narodniks' or from the socialism "populists' , whose different groups came together at the beginning of the century as the Social Revolutionaries.

The populists were based upon the small class of intellectuals, but hoped revolution. But the mass of the people against the Tsar. to be able to inspire a revolt by the degeneration of the Athough they spoke in terms of 'the people , in fact they looked mainly to ing the young working class, so that it the peasantry, hoping that the old would play the maximum role in the system of rural 'communes' could democratic revolution while also form the basis for a new, socialist, preparing later to overthrow the new society. They saw no special role, capitalist class, and bring about a therefore, for the industrial workers. socialist revolution. Following Marx, they believed that the working class Example could create a new society based on grass roots democracy and rational, The basic approach of the democratic planning human populists in the second half of the need, rather than profit. But first, an 19th century was to try to mobilise industrial capitalist society would the masses by example: they carried have to develop out daring assassinations of reac- There were disagreements among tionary leaders. Tsar Alexander II the Marxists, and in 1903 the RSDLP was assassinated, and Lenin's elder split into two wings, apparently brother was involved in an attempt to about organisational structure. The kill Alexander III. But the assassina- majority at the part of the contions left the masses cold. ference that voted on the question Marxists began to organise before - many delegates had already walkthe turn of the century, founding the ed out) or 'Bolsheviks' , were led by Russian Social Democratic and Lenin, one of the most gifted Marxist Labour Party (RSDLP) in conditions thinkers and organisers. The minoriof severe repression. The Marxists ty, or 'Mensheviks' , were to harden argued that Russian society was out into the right wing over the years changing: the growth of industry, to come. and the expansion of the market into The point of conflict in 1903 was the countryside, heralded a new form over whether to have a tightly of society: modern capitalism. They organised party, as Lenin argued, or argued that the Tsarist state and the a looser grouping. But shortly the Russian aristocracy were an obstacle political differences were to get much to the development of capitalism, bigger. and that Russia i was heading for a In 1905, a revolution broke out in revolution which would destroy the Russia. It began when a crowd of Tsarist state, introduce West starving workers, taking a petition to European-style democracy, and the Tsar, were mown down by allow the free development of troops. Thousands of workers, all capitalism. over Russia, struck; by the autumn Within that framework, the Marx- the movement was reaching general ists put their resources into organis- strike proportions. not inevitable. And the not inevitable. And the revolution itself was a millions of workers across the world.

This week, Socialist Organiser begins a series of articles on the Russian revolution, describing events as week. As an introduction, this week we look at the background to the movement in Russia.

A new form of democratic workers' organisation made its appearance: the council of workers' deputies, or soviet. This was a body composed of elected workers' representatives which took control of the workers' districts. It was like a workers' parliament — although far more democratic than any parliament that has ever existed.

The 1905 revolution was defeated: in December the Soviet Executive were arrested, and although strikes and demonstrations continued, the Tsar's regime survived. But the revolution was like a laboratory in which different revolutionary ideas were tested: after 1905, the political differences between various groups were clarified.

The main revolutionary force in 1905 was the working class. The great Polish socialist Rosa Luxemburg analysed the significance of the 'mass strike' as the dynamic force in the revolution, arguing that the powerful German labour movement should learn from the Russian experience.

Strategy

But this posed important questions for socialist strategy. The Marxists had thought that Russia was too backward, the working class too weak, for a revolution to do more than open the way to full-scale capitalism and capitalist-type democracy - yet the driving force for the revolution was not the capitalists who would benefit from it, but the exploited workers. How was this contradiction to be resolved? The answer to this question deepened divisions among the Marxists.| The Mensheviks stuck to the rigid view that the revolution was and would be capitalist, or bourgeois, and so the capitalists (or their political representatives, the liberal intellgentsia), would lead it. The revolution would result in a liberal government based on a British-style parliament. The Marxists should develop independent working class organisations like trade unions and defend workers' immediate interests, but it would be madness and utopianism to try to make the revolution more radical.

The Bolsheviks argued that the Armed workers in Petrograd 191 liberals were weak and feeble and had no revolutionary vitality - they were a pale echo of the bourgeois revolutionaries of the great French revolution. The whole capitalist class was utterly compromised with the Tsarist state, and could never lead a revolution to overthrow it.

The Marxists should ally not with them, with the huge class of peasants. This alliance of workers and peasants would overthrow the Tsar and introduce a radical, democratic republic - what Lenin called the "revolutionary democratic dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasanty". And that worker-peasant revolution in Russia could link up with international socialist revoluThe peasants - who were no socialists, but on the contrary wanted to have their own patches of land -so outnumbered the workers that they workers would not be able to win socialist CaSHes. But workers should fight to make the revolution as radical as possible.

Rosa Luxemburg had a view quite similar to this.

A third argument was put forward by Leon Trotsky. At that time a supporter neither of the Bolsheviks nor of the Mensheviks, he had been President of the St Petersburg Soviet. Trotsky agreed with Lenin that the bourgeois liberals were feeble, and that the workers and poor peasants provided the revolutionary dynamic to the revolution.

But the peasantry, although big in numbers, could not act as an independent political force. Within the alliance, the workers would lead -or there would be no alliance, and the peasants would follow the capitalists instead. The workers would be central to the . revolution, and the workers' soviets would take on the responsibility of state power. The workers would "stand before the peasantry as the class which has emancipated it".

Power

Once in power, the workers could not stop at democratic measures alone, or give political power to the liberals. A workers' government, supported by the peasants, would have to take sides in class struggles — and nationalise industry under workers' control, for example. The workers would have to go beyond the bourgeois limits of the revolution and transform it into a socialist revolution.

Russia itself oculd not support a new socialist society, which requires a high level of industrialisation and economic development. But Russia was tied in with the international capitalist system.

Scan page 7

i Russia

----- pull-quotes -----

YEAR OF R EVOLUTION

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 305

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →