Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[No substitute for building support for socialist ideas…]

Socialist Organiser no. 305, 5 March 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,715 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

No substitute for building support for socialist ideas in the workplace 1888 edition of the Communist Manifesto sums up the bedrock idea of working class politics. Yet quite different notions are current on the left in Britain today (and 'communism' is taken as meaning a police state like the USSR).

When it was abolished by the Tories, the Labour Greater London Council produced a booklet describing what it had done since being elected in 1981. It detailed many measures, often valuable, that the council had carried out for women, for ethnic minorities, for gays and lesbians, for the disabled and so on.

The words 'working class' did not appear at all. Yet the GLC is seen by many not only as something to defend against the Tories, but as a positive model for radical socialism.

A 'rainbow coalition' of different oppressed groups, together with peace, ecology and other movements, is presented as a modern replacement for old-fashioned 'class reductionism'.

The working class The working class is an oppressed group in capitalist society. It is also more. It is the basic exploited class:

the whole system lives from what is squeezed out of the working class.

The working class brought together, organised, disciplined and pushed towards unity by capitlaism itself. The central economic mechanism of the system, the exploitation of labour by capital, drives workers into a class struggle which even at routine levels is powerful enough to dominate social and political life in a country like Britain.

Only occasionally does that class struggle reach its full height, with mass strike movements mobilising the whole working class. But even sectional strikes often spread and generate solidarity. Even in normal times, when the working class is battered into inertia and ideological conformity by the relentless pressure of the ruling class, the organisations based on the working class, trade unions and workers' parties, exceed all other opposition and protest PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

3917965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone, Monday evening.

ditor: Jobs? Mahony Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU).

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA.

1 by Eart End Offser (TU), London E2.

Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. pasticles domon necessarily reflect the views of movements in scope and activity.

The working class has the power to overthrow capitalism, and the potential to make a new society. The working class is not only manual workers - it includes all those who are deprived of ownership and control of the means of production and have to sell their labour-power for a wage. Thus the working class already does all the technical and physical work of producing the wealth of societyonly it does so under the command of capitalists seeking profits.

The working class can organise production itself, according to its own rules, the rules of cooperation and solidarity. The working class has no class below it to oppress. In fighting to free itself it must also fight to abolish all class divisions.

It can free itself only by turning society upside down.

In turning society upside down, the working class can and must lead the fight against all special oppressions. No women have a greater interest in women's liberation than working class women; no black people have a greater interest in racial equality than black workers.

Autonomous movements Most of the time the working class is bowed down and disunited by the pressure of capitalist power. The labour movement is dominated by bureaucrats and better-off workers.

Women, black people, and other oppressed groups cannot wait until the whole working class moves. So they develop autonomous movements which fight their own struggles at their own tempos while also trying to win over the labour movement.

Socialists must support these autonomous movements: not to do so is effectively to support the sectionalism of the bureaucrats and better-off workers who dominate the labour movement in quiet times. An uncompromising struggle for the rights of the most oppressed is necessary if the workng class is to become confident and bold enough to free itself.

All that, however, is very different from encouraging sectionalism and autonomy as positive aims in themselves, or saying that women and black people and other groups necessarily have 'autonomous' perceptions and programmes which cannot be integrated into a classagainst-class programme.

That sort of autonomy leaves the socialist movement as nothing better than a coalition held together by horse-trading and agreements on spheres of influence. How could such a coalition overthrow centralised capitalist power? And if it could, what sort of socialism could it create? There could be no economic plan integrating the interests of all workers, but only a patchwork compromise -in other words, a reproduction of liberal-capitalist pressure-group We must fight for the unity of the working class in a way that does not stifle the struggles of the most oppressed; and wage the struggles of the most oppressed in a way that does not obstruct working-class unity. Recent years The miners' strike of 1984-5 was living proof of some basic Marxist ideas. The miners' struggle for an 'economics' based on human need, not profit, inspired thousands of workers. Women, black communities, and lesbian and gay groups mobilised; and the strike transformed the thinking of many miners on every aspect of life. And that was only one per cent of the working class in all-out confrontation with capitalism!

But the miners were defeated; and from that defeat has come the drift of the left away from class politics. No Marxist group, however good its strategy, can revive mass workers" struggle at will. But we can prepare, learn lessons, educate, sink roots: that is what we must do.

From the late 1950s and well into the '70s, Britain had one of the most powerful and confident trade union movements in the world. The question of how to deal with the unions dogged successive governments.

But after crippling the Tory government in 1972-4 the labour movement could find no political alternative but the Wilson/Callaghan Labour government. Increasingly, the end it reproduces the ideas of orthodox sociology, with a kaleidoscope of power and status relations, all expressed at individual level, obscuring the class struggle.

The 'vertical mosaic' A. Sivanandan makes the point in Race Awareness Training and the disintegration of the black struggle' commenting on recent official 'ethnic' policy. "The ensuring scramble for government favours and government grants on the basis of specific ethnic needs and problems served on the one hand to deepen ethnic differences and foster ethnic rivalry, and on the other to widen the definition of ethnicity to include a variety of national and religious groups - Chinese, Cypriots, Greeks, Turks, Irish, Italians, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs, until the term became meaningless (except as a means of getting funds).

" This 'vertical mosaic' of ethnic groups, so distinct from the horizontal of class politics, then becomes even more removed by the politics of the left councils who, lacking the race/class perspective which would have allowed them to dismantle the institutionalised racism of their own structures, insitutionalised ethnicity instead."

The trend here is towards the Americanisation of British politics. In the US, ethnic identities have long been a powerful counterweight to class identities. Radical impulses can readily be directed away from class channels towards community, citizens' , or pressure-group politics. The result: a weak labour movement, little political culture, no workers' party even of a reformist and bureaucratic type, little questioning of the fundamental institutions of private property. Yet Americanisation is, in effect, promoted by some on the left in Britain as the radical new wave of socialist politics. Turn to the working class Socialist Action preaches the rainbow coalition' , saying tht the working class in Western Europe has not been even a potentially revolutionary force for many decades and will not be for a long time to come. Socialist Worler and Militant increasingly build themselves as sects, distant both from rank-and-file workers and from autonomous movements. A large part of the left has abandoned the working class.

Yet there are no short cuts. No regroupment or campaign in the Labour Party can substitute for the hard, siow work of building support for socialist ideas in the workplace.

Those who preach other strategies are not following an easier or newer path to the same goal of working class socialism. They are substituting a different goal.

Scan page 4

GRAFET Vigil for AIDS victims, Trafalgar Square. Photo: Simon Grosset. Making profits from AIDS lan McCalman's recent letter suggesting that membership of the Orange Order should not be regarded as an adequate criterion to justify expulsion from the Labour Party has clearly raised the hackles of some of Glasgow's professional "anti-imperialists" and opponents of religious bigotry.

At the February meeting of the Glasgow branch of the Labour Committee on Ireland, a resolution was passed for submission to the LeI Annual General Meeting declaring that membership of the Orange Order should be regarded as incompatible with membership of the Labour ParOne cannot help but be surprised that all those Scottish miners, who only yesterday were the vanguard of our class during the miners' strike are now to be treated as pariahs and eiected from the Labour Party. But, February 1987 Price sup An Agreed Process IDA monthly magazine it now turns out, they only fought the Tories because they were "forced to do so"

I can only assume that it is my capitulation to British imperialism which blinded me to the fact that Letti these "agents of the ruling classes" (sic) would really have preferred collaborating with their mistress in Downing Street, rather than going on strike for over a year.

Another argument was that Sam Campbell (who last year publicly described Catholics as "the enemy" and called for the closure of Catholic schools and the withholding of television license fees) only said out loud "what they all think" - How the Glasgow LCI thought-police gathered the evidence for this sweeping claim was, alas, not revealed.

And it is indeed difficult to understand how people who are so knowledgeable about the Orange Order that they know "what they all think" can effortlessly toss out equations between the Orange Order and the National Front/BNP, or declare members of the Orange Order to be agents of the ruling classes.

STAN CROOKE Glasgow

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 305

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →