Briefing and Livingstone: the truth
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no 304 26 February 1987 Page guaranteed defeat. Victory could have been achieved only through ringing into play the 30,000 rank and file Scottish supporters. But Roxburgh's capitulation to the rules of bourgeois democracy, and football, meant that they were left standing on the sidelines. By the way, mate, wanna join the SWP?"
A corpulent teacher domiciled in the vicinity of the ground provided a different analysis: "Even one of those bloody women primary school teachers must recognise that this tragedy is a direct result of abolition of the tawse. Only mindless dogmatists will now fail to understand the pressing need for a Scottish Assembly."
Whilst a battered and bloodied Scotland fled the field of battle in disgrace, Irish anti-imperialists, intoxicated by the pervasive anti-imperialist atmosphere, and by more bodily substances as well, staged a two-minutes silence in memory of fallen comrades: Moran, McCarthy and Lawrenson, booked for Englishstyle war crimes.
"Fianna Fail's victory in the Irish general election on the Tuesday, and Irland's decisive win at Hampden Park on the Wednesday - this is the living force of Permanent Revolution at work, comrades," commented a Socialist Action supporter after the event. Keith Spencer (SO 303) is wrong. Briefing did not lead the fight against Ken Livingstone's climbdowns. Instead it constructed pseudo-Marxist rationálisations.
Right from the start Briefing was a central part of the local government left, endorsing, supporting and justifying its refusals to stand up to the Tories. Briefing gloried in the allegedly socialist character of high rate rises and other ploys used by the Livingstones to try to avoid confronting the Tory government. That was what distinguished Briefing then from Socialist Organiser.
Breakaway
Briefing was set up as a breakaway from SO in early 1980. Briefing's initiators argued that Labour councils must raise rates to 'gain time' '. The majority on the SO editorial board said that rate rises meant running away from a fight and that if we ran away then we would never stand up and fight the Tories.
As early as July 1979 Ted Knight in Lambeth had proved us right by go987 10 ing from rate rises to a proposal for cuts. He was forced by the Lambeth labour movement to cancel those cuts. But those who would later start Briefing excused him: "when comrades such as those now leading Lambeth council feel obliged, under pressure, to make concessions..it is not because they want to: it is because... we lack the physical power enabling us to overthrow the whole system of big business...
The Briefing editors delighted to talk about the vast "struggle for power" in the future; but only to prove that before "the revolution", Labour had no choice but to trim, compromise and manage the system. But, of course, for the Livingstones, the trimming, compromising and managing was the whole game.
Briefing was launched as a Liv= ingstone fan magazine, centred round the GLC campaign. When Labour won the GLC election in 1981, Briefing's headline was "London's Ours!" - though, politically, it might have been more appropriate for County Hall to fly a flag saying "Briefing's Ours!"
Briefing followed Livingstone in the GLC's crucial collapse, on cheap fares in January 1982.
That collapse prefigured everything else.
It was too early for confrontation, said Briefing: for the time being •The task is to stay in office and add to our power by winning, first, the borough elections...'"!
As late as January 1983, Graham Bash, editor of Briefing then and now, reckoned that "The GLC campaign has been a success. The GLC is generally seen to be under the control of the left..." But the harsh truth was that the Briefing left was under the control of the GLC "left".
Usefulness
Of course Briefing and Livingstone did eventually part ways. But it was Livingstone deciding that Briefing's usefulness to him was ended, rather than Briefing fighting Livingstone that led to the rupture: Livingstone kicked Briefing away from him.
Today Briefing can posture cheaply as part of the serious left - but when it mattered, when it was a case of practical immediate questions of the class struggle they were only as 'left' as Ken Livingstone was: when it mattered, Briefing counted for nothing politically:
Anyway, the old Briefing has now been replaced by a new one, made up of a mish-mash cluster of small groups - International, Socialist Viewpoint, Chartist Minority - and a few "independents" It has no coherent politics. Of today's Briefing you could justly say, what Trotsky said long ago:
*] have never put a low value on small organisations merely because they are small...The mass organisations have value precisely because they are mass organisations. Even when they are under patriotic reformist leadership one cannot discount them. One must win the masses who are in their clutches: whether from outside or from inside depends on the circumstance. Small organisations which regard themselves as selective, as pioneers can only have value on the strength of their programme and of the schooling and steeling of their cadres. A small organisation which has no unified programme and no really revolutionary will is less than nothing, is a negative quantity"
(Leon Trotsky, Open Letter to an English Comrade, April 3 1936)GERRY BATES, Camden.
Scan page 11
Terry French at the 1986 TUC. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni, Report. NEXT WEEK IN S.O.: Terry French on his experiences in prison. It was denounced as 'unconstitutional by Peter Gilfoyle, the official appointed by Labour's leadership to run Liverpool Labour Party, but Labour Party members went ahead with a meeting last Wednesday to hear a report from Council leader Tony Byrne on the Labour Group's proposed budget for 1987. By On Channel 4 on Saturday night, Robert Kee interviewed a woman about rape. I only caught the last couple of minutes. She was telling him that in law, only vaginal penetration is rape. If a man forces his penis into a woman's mouth or backside it is not rape. It is a crime, but it is not rape. I was quite shocked - I didn't know that.
Robert Kee started on about the Bible and Adam and Eve, which 1 didn't quite get, but I think it was about the nature of sex. The woman corrected him and pointed out that rape is not sex. 'What kind of men raped women?" he wanted to know.
----- pull-quotes -----
relies on financial juggling
of rape Penny Newell