Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Women and class struggle

Socialist Organiser no. 304, 26 February 1987 · scan p. 10 · about 586 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Jane Ashworth's article on women and socialism misses several important points. The first concerns an issue which she raises throughout the piece but does not adequately resolve.

She hits back at sections of feminism and at the left generally, at a trend which I for one find disturbing (and oppressive). Jane discusses the inversion of the personal/political slogan, and states that it has changed to mean that outside power relations inevitably occur within personal life.

This has always been part of the meaning of the slogan. The real change of meaning is to state that the political is personal, i.e. that the political arena has shifted into personal life.

The implications of this are serious for all women active in politics, giving women one more shove into the realms of emotionality and away from objectivity.

There is a trend within feminism which asserts that women and men (because of both "nature" and "nurture") are irreconcilably different. This trend identifies women's values as innately superior to male values. After all, such feminists argue, women did not start two world wars, invent the nuclear weapon, do not rape and do mother children.

To my mind this analysis finds against much of the evidence. Women supported as well as suffered fascist dictators, and there are no doubt women who would perpetuate atrocities given the material resources to do so.

Most women do mother children but many do not, and many more would not, given the choice. Mothering is a burden for many women, as well as a joy. Our capacity to bear children is a major factor in our daily oppression and our availability as childcarers benefits both men and capital. (Which is not to imply that society should not be changed to meet the needs of childcarers).

Rape is not a women's crime, and men increase their property rights over us because of it. Male violence is a complex issue within feminism, despite efforts to oversimplify it, As well as being an obvious facet of patriarchy, male sexual violence is related to concepts of property, materialism and class.

It is not enough to say that women are superior to men because men rape and women don't. Rape will not end with capitalism which is one of the reasons why demands for women's liberation must not be subsumed into ATH YORKSHIRE WOMEN AGAINST CLOSURES T000 BY PARSHIRE TAGAINS T Miners' wives lobby NUM conference the class struggle. Any analysis of women's oppression cannot be based on patriarchy or capitalism alone, one paying lip service to the other, but must explain the supporting connections between the two.

Thus a radical feminism, engaging primarily with patriarchy and defining class as just another oppression, does not provide a satisfactory way forward.

These points have been raised many times by socialist women, but when left women are labelled misogynist and attempts are made to silence them, the point is clearly not getting through.

To argue that women's values are superior to men's, and to express women's values in terms of non-aggression, mothering and caring is to effectively silence many women, who reject those values as potentially oppressive. I speak here not only for women on the left defending so-called "male" political positions, but also for the millions of women trying to escape from Victorian values everywnere.

None of this however should imply that women must fight alongside men for the overthrow of patriarchy and capitalism, as I feel Jane suggests. SHORT VASSOCIATION Will VICK

----- pull-quotes -----

YOU YOU STAND BY US

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 304

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →