Different feminisms
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
reviews 'Is the Future Female?' We are all feminists now. Even the staid Sunday Telegraph carries a survey on feminism today, featuring new "Tory feminists' But what sort of feminism? According to Lynne Segal, "the feminist writing which is now most popular in this country, which is always listed among the best-sellers in progressive literary magazines, is a new form of radical feminism.
Mostly from North America, where it is known as "cultural feminism' , it celebrates women's superior virtue and spirituality and decries 'male' violence and technology. Such celebration of the 'female' and denunciation of the "male' , however, arouses fear and suspicion in teminists who, like me, recall that we joined the women's movement to challenge the myths of women's special nature"
Lynne Segal demolishes the new feminist theories on their own chosen terrains. Rape is not a conspiracy by all men to keep all women in subjection and fear. "This explanation of rape ignores the absence of reported rape in some societies and provides a very strange analysis of power relations in general *If sexual coercion really were the ultimate and characteristic instrument of men's power, it is hard to see why women would not long ago have acquired the physical skills and equipment to "disarm' rapists -unless we assume women are both blind and stupid".
Pornography is not the "theory" for which "rape is the practice" . Indeed, pornography has boomed as male domination has weakened. Anti-pornography legislation and direct action supported by some feminists are likely to strengthen the moralistic right wing.
Peace is not specially 'female", nor war specially 'male'. Women have often supported, and fought or wanted to fight, in wars. "It was through appealing to the symbols and values of women as mothers and housewives that women of the Chilean right played the decisive role inside Chile preparing for the fascist na True Stories is featherweight coup of General Pinochet in 1973...
At best, argues Lynne Segal, the project of nourishing a separate 'women's culture' is "toothless liberalism" Worse: dissolving women's oppression today into timeless generalities about male aggression, some new feminists entirely dismiss the material gains for women that have been made. They resort to the politics of despair and mysticism; they reproduce the ideas of rightwing thinkers who argue that the brutality and competitiveness of capitalist society are the inevitable result of unchangeable human or male) instincts, Such despair could help right wing politicians in a drive to take back women's gains.
Why, when feminism has spread so widely, are so many feminists so disoriented? Theoretical socialist feminism is in disarray both practically and theoretically; the new radical feminism has overwhelmed it even among socialists.
Lynne Segal's answer is that "Political engagement 'with and "against' men, whether in the Labour Party, the trade unions, the autonomous black, anti-nuclear, ecological, anti-racist or other progressive social movements and groupings of the lett, is the umbrella strategy feminists need to pursue" She sees Ken Livingstone's politics as "the only hope for socialism".
Yet this coalition-of-interestgroups type of socialism has nurtured precisely the sort of feminism which Lynne Segal criticises.
*Feminist Review' of which Segal is an editor, organised a round-table last year in which Elizabeth Wilson put it sharply: "One disturbing aspect...is the way in which some radical men have taken up the question of pornography. Half of those on the left who think they are sensitive to feminism have taken up the pornography issue without being aware that it is one on which socialist feminists disagree. Ken Livingstone, for instance, can say that Andrea Dworkin is the most wonderful feminist living as if there had been no debate at all about her book". (Andrea Dworkin's book 'Pornography" is one of the best-known expositions of the sort of ideas that Segal criticises).
Elizabeth Wilson herself does not have much of an alternative: she is a Morning Star Stalinist. The real lesson from Lynne Segal's book is the failures of the Marxist left.
We talk a great deal about the importance of theory for revolutionary politics. Probably the most serious Appealing to the values of motherhood?
effort at revolutionary theory for 40 years was the debates and researches of socialist feminists in the 1970s.
Dozens of talented writers turned to Marxist ideas to find answers. They came looking for bread and the organised Marxist left, on the whole, offered them stones sectarian boneheadedness or passive mimicry. It is about time that the left emerged from the sterile alternatives of condemning all feminism as a 'diversion' from the real' struggle, or mindlessly cheering 'women's autonomy? A soap covers
----- pull-quotes -----
Lynne Segal. (Virago, £4.95).