Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Win the student vote for Labour

Socialist Organiser no. 304, 26 February 1987 · scan pp. 5–8 · Jane Ashworth · about 3,658 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Socialist Organiser no 304 26 February 1987 Page 5 The student movement is in a dire state. The national anti-loans demonstration held last Saturday had a turn-out of only about 20,000 compared to almost 40,000 in 1985 and 1986.

Labour Students conference comes at the end of a miserable year for the organisation which runs NUS., NOLS have failed to provide an effective political leadership to unite students to fight the Tories and reactionary college authorities.

NOLS itself remains adamantly opposed to allowing working class, part-time students to join the organisation and to increasing part-time student representation at NUS conferences. It refuses to allow those students most hit by the Tories to have a proper say in what should be their natural orgamsaurons.

NOLS, through NUS, has failed students, particularly those Further Education students without a grant, and it has failed the activists by not providing a strategy which can involve the mass of students in l an outgoing political campaign.

Failed

NOLS National Committee has failed to run the organisation in a manner which befits a socialist student group. The NC has only met three times in a year and as usual there are delegates who have been ruled out for no reason other than the fact that they are opposed to the curTent bureaucratic, right wing leadership.

It is an essential part of running a socialist youth movement to ensure that the rules encourage participation, that there are adequate forums for debate and discussion and that campaigns are planned with the maximum input from those who are car rying them out.

But the "Democratic Left" leaders of NOLS and NUS have not run NOLS like that. In fact, in repeated debates, Rob Minshull, the National secretary has complained of them being a waste of time. There have been no real open forums, and worst of all, no campaigns.| Running NUS with its 1.25 million members from a NOLS membership of about 8,000 should give us the opportunity to ensure a huge youth vote for Labour. But beyond trying to get students to run the necessary electoral registration campaigns absolutely nothing has been done, The youth vote can be won by organising political activity which looks like it has the chance of winning. While the "Democratic Left" are right to encourage links with Red Wedge this is not a substitute for political campaigns.

Disillusionment with past Labour governments is the key factor we have to overcome and NOLS and NUS could play a part in combatting their scepticism by arguing, for answers to the problems that youth face and convince them to fight with us for the policies we want.

What NOLS is heading for is a passive election campaign, where we argue Kinnock's line on defence and little else.

Unfortunately, arguing for right wing policies, refusing to run campaigns and playing it quiet in the hope of wooing the SDP will not build NOLS and will not return the maximum possible student vote for the return of a Labour government.

The future for NOLS is bleak; not many people belong to it; it has not done anything to build itself; and to compound that, no-one trusts a word its leaders ever say.

NOLS members should take it in hand before it is too late. At the head of the agenda must be action to put a stop to the present system of "guided democracy" under which the manipulators on top cynically rig all conference votes by unjustly ruling saddamna - In addition to the three main slates, certain individual candidates were promoted by other groups. Militant sympathiser Ray Apps received 34,000 votes (7.3% of the total) and Paul Astbury 31,000 (7,.1%), and Briefing supporter, George Lindfield, 6,000 (1.8%).

The analysis of the 'performance" of the various slates in the NCC elections demonstrates that (as in the NEC elections) votes cast for candidates not included on any of the slates are completely wasted.

Even though the votes cast for the candidates on the CLPD/Campaign Group/LLL slate were sufficient on this occasion to ensure a decisive victory over the Forward Labour runnerup, the low percentage (26%) of the average total votes cast for the CLPD/CG/LLL-backed candidates indicates that, given better organisation on the right, they could have been outvoted without much difficulty.

Indeed, in the Women's Section the right wing candidate, Dianne Hayter, received 110,000 votes from CLPs (29%). Had she stood in the Constituency Section she might have won there too.

If comrades sympathetic to Militant and Labour Briefing believe that it is important who is on the NCC, they must reconsider whether they would wish to split the vote again next time.

(All figures taken from the Record of Voting published by the Labour Party).

This is an abridgement of an article in thia months CI DA Rollatin.

Scan page 6

MILHIM, secretary of the General of Palestinian Students, talked to ist Organiser about the situation anon, on the West Bank, and RIMA Union Social in Leb about the objectives of the PLO.

What is the background to situation in Lebanon?

After the evacuation of the PLO in 1982, there was a period of about nine months, when for the first time in years — since 1976 - the Lebanese state came into existence again. The army was very prominent, and oppression was very intense.

In February 1984, there was a major, mass uprising among the Shiite population of Lebanon, more or less headed by the Amal militias. On the popular level, people supported the Amal uprising because it freed them from the oppression of the Israeli army and the Deuxieme Bureau, the Lebanese intelligence. Also historically, the Shi'ites - although the largest single sect - have always been the underdogs, politically, economically and socially - the most oppressed. They have had least share in the sectarian division of power in Lebanon.

After that, Amal started to develop better relations with Syria, and, to be sure, came under direct Syrian control and finance. They began to depend on Syrian arms. Smaller groups, like Hizbullah - and others: there are about twelve altogether -developed also, and grew, some standing with Amal policy, others against it.

Amal, since January 1985, became more and more obviously linked to official Syrian regime policy.

In April 1985, for the first time since 1982, Amal — helped by Syrian intelligence - attacked the camps which are under attack now (Burj elBarajneh, Sabra and Shatila). Then, too, there was a siege, a blockade, lots of attacks. Shatila was very badly hit. About 60% of Shatila was destroyed, I think, and all of Sabra. The siege was lifted: Sabra was not allowed to be rebuilt again; about 10,000 peple had to find an alternative place to live.

What is the relationship between Amal and pro-Syrian factions among the Palestinians? When Amal first started attacking the camps in April 1985, they said they weren't attacking Palestinians, but were attacking the pro-Arafat PLO leadership. All political groups in the camps, including those now established in Syria and the official leadership, immediately said this was not true. The refugees were being attacked as Palestinians, There is no direct link between under total Syrian control: arms, finance, is based there and has always been - started to have relations with Amal, but broke them when the camps were attacked.

Since the attacks in 1985 and now, there had been no direct military attacks on the camps. But what had been happening was that Palestinians, especially young males venturing out of the camps, would be immediately kidnapped at any roadblock, and sent to detention centres in Beirut or in the south, and in the great majority of cases tortured and killed. So that affected people because they could not get out of the camp and work.

So the camp population, and especially young males, were, if you want, 'hostages' inside the camp for the last year.

What does the PLO hope to about the current situation?

On an immediate level, the PLO is trying very hard to put international pressure on Syria, mainly, to lift the siege to get the basics in. Last year a very, very small amount of food got through into Burj el-Barajneh. Whatever was sent has already run out. Shatila still hasn't received anything, and the siege of Shatila has been going on for longer.

On a wider level, the PLO wants to solve the camp problem. And of course the PLO wants to solve the basic political problem - a settlement of the Palestinian problem, not only in Lebanon but as a whole.

Unless a general settlement in the area is found, things like the siege will keep happening every year. What do you think should be done for Lebanon itself? In so far as you can separate Lebanon's problema from the general conflict, what is the answer?

What theoretically might happen is a period of relative calm in which the different groups could arrange some sort of temporary relations that will make Lebanon work again. The Lebanese economy is now totally, totally shattered. In 1982 £1 sterling was about ten Lebanese pounds. Not it is 120. So the economic crisis is extremely serious.

There is very serious poverty on a scale that did not exist betore 1984.

In the longer term, the whole Lebanese issue, even if you wanted to separate it from the Middle East issue, cannot be solved by recreating the old state system, which was an artificial creation of the old colonial powers and has failed. It is not going to work again.

What's happening in the Israelioccupied territories on the West Bank?

Just two days ago, an alternative information centre in Jerusalem which produces a bulletin called "News from Within' , was raided by the army. The group consists of progressive Israeli Jews and Arabs, producing a monthly news bulletin. Four people were detained, two Arab women and two Israeli men. They haven't been charged yet, but they will probably be charged under a new law which says that a person who has any minimum contact with the PLO — even sharing a platform — has committed high treason and is liable to 6-7 years in jail. Or they will be changed under Israel's equivalent of the Prevention of Terrorism Act.

It is quite a significant event. It is the first time, really, that Israeli journalists have been detained and are probably going to be charged with high treason.

I think that what has been happening in the occupied territories has been increased oppression, and in a lots of ways much less subtle oppression than even a few years ago. Since the Labour Party came to office in 1984 (as part of a national government) the state has carried out an "iron fist' policy in the occupied territories. Oppression is very, very blunt now.

Bir Zeit university was closed two days ago after a demonstration in protest at what's happening in the camps. It's been closed indefinitely. Other universities have been shut. The army used water jets at Gaza University last month, likewise at Ramallah.

The Israeli state wants to destroy the PLO, and has tried to set up 'alternatives. How successful have they been?

Their first attempt to create an alternative leadership in the occupied territories was the so-called 'Village Leagues. All such attempts have so far failed. They will continue to fail. There's no way you can impose a political programme and a way of thinking — it's not just a leadership - on a people.

Recently, a poll was done on the West Bank - a scientifically done poll - where over 90% of the population said that they support the PLO. A lot of Israelis, and the Israeli state, are starting to realise that there is no way they can impose an alternative — neither they nor the Jordanian regime actually.

Israel tried again in 1982 to kill the PLO. Their attempts have definitely failed. The PLO has its weaker and stronger moments. But it's now at the point where it is alive and well again. Neither Israel nor any Arab regime Israeli police on the West Bank. will be able to eradicate the PLO, although it is a pain in everybody's neck.

Lots of people point to the growth of Islamic fundamentalism, including in the West Bank. How powerful is it?

Not on the West Bank. The Islamic groups are stronger in the Gaza strip rather than the West Bank. In the Gaza strip there is a growing Islamic fundamentalist movement. It's not very major yet. It ıs ıtself quite split - luckily, for someone ot my point of view.

It's split on different grounds. There's one faction in the Gaza strip who have been related to the Islamic Brotherhood in Egypt — who traditionally (in the 1950s) were related to the British, actually. They are well financed, but I don't think they'll manage to get anywhere. They are not part of the national struggle that's taking place.

There is also, to be fair, a more nationally 'progressive' movement in the Gaza strip. But there is not much of an Islamic movement in the West Bank, and I don't think that there is a danger (if you want to use such a word) there of a growth of a movenent. exist ities.

Scan page 7

The social base of the fundamentalist groups in Egypt seems to be very middle class. Is hat the case in Palestine?

Apparently in places like Bir Zeit, he fundamentalists come from the nost dispossessed social classes. More radical people - sympathsiers f the Communists of the PFLP, for xample - are more middle class, niversity-educated.

hat kind of organisations exist among West tion?

All Palestinian organisations are illegal. But all political organisations that exist within the PLO are found in the occupied territories.

What about trade organisations?

There is a growing trade union organisation. They function a bit like half-way between the French and the English system. They operate both on trades and political lines.

Unionisation has grown in the last ten years. Their problem is that although they exist and they are functioning, they are often illegal. According to the ILO, out of 137 trade unions, 112 are illegal. The ones that are legal are the ones that used to exist under Jordanian rule, before Israeli occupation.

What happens is that the unions set themselves up, but their offices get raided, the stuff gets confiscated, trade union activists have been put under arrest or deported.

These measures have mainly been used against trade union activists, probably because trade union officials haven't committed acts which are illegal. So measures are used where the person detained, deported or whatever, is never tried.

Are there many strikes?

Strikes are common on the West! Bank. There have been a number of strikes, mainly symbolic protests about wi nat is going on in Lebanon. Strikes often happen after land seizures, or the closure of trade union offices.

Trade unions have more of a double role, both for the workers and as political organisations.

The most oppressed workers are the migrants, who go inside the Green Line to work, legally, or generally illegally. They are difficult to organise. They need the protection of unions, and people are attempting to organise them; but they haven't succeeded yet.

Is there any possibility of ingful joint action with Jewish workers?

There have traditionally been links with groups like MATZPEN (Israeli Socialist Organisation). It would be to the advantage of both Arab and Jewish workers to have joint Victims of the Beirut massacres cooperation. Not within the Histadrut structure, which does not really allow Arabs from the occupied territories to join. But within a different structure, yes definitely.

People in the occupied territories pay between 25% and 40% of their income in 'defence tax'. But they're not eligible for unemployment or health benefits, or maternity benefits - they have no right to social securiWhat are relations like between different factions in the PLO? In 1983 there was a civil war between some of them. What's the situation now?

In 1983 there was a split within Fatah, the largest group, which resulted in a 'civil war' in the Tripoli area. Without Syrian intervention it would not have escalated into such a nasty military attack, and eventually a siege of Tripoli by the Syrian fac*ions.

The situation has improved a lot since. There hasn't been a Palestine National Congress yet, but there have been a number of meetings in Czechoslovakia and elsewhere, between all factions of the PLO. Last week there was the conference of the General Union of Palestinian Writers and Journalists in Algeria, where all political organisations were represented, and are represented on the new Executive Committee.

In a lot of ways, the extremely dilficult and sad situation we went through in 1983 and a bit later is more or less over. It's a matter of a few months, probably, before there will be solid unity again.

How do you assess the "peace process'?

There is no way that the whole Middle East crisis is going to be solved unless you solve the Palestinian problem, and this is becoming more and more obvious to everybody. Whether you are talking about Libya or Syria or whatever, the Palestinian question is central.

The PLO is pushing for an international conference on the Middle East, held under the auspices of the UN, attended by all permanent members of the Security Council, and all parties involved in the conflict, including the PLO.

So far Israel and the United States have refused to have the PLO involved in any internatonal conterençe. Obviously the PLO has to be represented.

But this would be an important step forward, even to promote discussion or different ideas about what can be done.

On a wider level, since 1974, all political organisations within the PLO have been asking for the establishment of an independent Palestinian state, the right of return for refugees — which we feel is very important.

A lot of people still feel that in the long run a democratic secular state, or a democratic non-sectarian state, is what is needed. It would be the most sound solution.

What do you mean by the difference?

A non-sectarian state would allow each community to continue its civil matters. Each community will be able to carry on civil affairs — marriage, divorce, etc., through religious bodies, rather than through state bodies.

The democratic secular state formula has been criticised for implying that the Jews are just a religious group, whereas in fact they are a nation.

I don't think a secular democratic state does imply three, religious groups. There is a Hebrew-speaking nation. I don't think anyone can deny that, or has denied it for a long time. The PLO is pushing for an independent state that will co-exist next to Israel.

Of course the Israeli state will have to be politically quite different in order to accept the establishment of a Palestinian state.

Speaking personally I think it is basically racist to say you can't have a united, democratic state. I think it is entirely possible for two peoples to coexist within the same state structure while keeping their own national/religious identity.

But there's been such a level of conflict over nearly 40 years at least. Is unity possible?

There has been conflict in 100.

But no one proposes to unite France and Germany in the same territory.

History has proved that people can live together. There has been conflict, but people can live together, especially as the Jewish and Arab cultures are extremely similar in a lot of ways.

But I think one of the problems with an immediate programme of a single state is that immediately, the Israeli Jews will reject it.

And that is why since 1984 the PLO has been saying, okay, let's drop this idea and think of something more practical — which is a two-state solution.

So unity would have to be volun tary?

Yes.

What is GUPS doing in Britain?

Generally speaking, GUPS is doing two things. First, like any other students' union, we deal with the problems of Palestinian students in Britain. There are fewer students in Britain now, since they changed the fees from £200 to £3,000. A lot of students have extremely serious financial problems.

There has recently been very strong anti-Arab feeling, on the official level and on the street level. This was especially so after the Libya raid. People were threatened with deportation and faced many other problems.

The role of GUPS is also to promote the Palestine issue among the British student movement - and also the trade union movement, which we feel is very important.

Our role is very important because there is so little coverage of the Palestinian issue in the British media. Often people don't know what is going on unless they go out of their way to find out.

There is a student conference on March 7 organised by ourselves and the Palestine Solidarity Campaign, to discuss various issues — academic freedom in the nccupied territories, women, trades unions.

We also want to debate the Palestine issue in NUS and NOLS. For the last God-knows how many years the Palestine issue has been cropping up at every NUS conference - but it has been extremely negative and unhelpful. It has been pushed on us by unimportant discussions, instead of discussing the Palestinian problem we've been discussing ridiculous things like badges. So we feel it is extremely important to have a proper debate.

The banning of Jewish societies has focused the whole thing wrongly.

At South Bank Poly, people didn't even consult with GUPS. Instead of having a proper debate on the Middle East, it has been diverted into something totally different — to our disadvantage. So we're pushing for a proper debate.

Scan page 8

Black sections and the YS

----- pull-quotes -----

these groups. One of the Palestinian organisations, Saiqa - which is

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 304

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →