Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Wet Blunkett

Socialist Organiser no. 304, 26 February 1987 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,293 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

59% of Tory voters believe that a 59% of Tory voters believe that a Tory government would pay no Tory government would pay no attention to what they think. And attention to what they think. And 45% think that a Tory ad- 45% think that a Tory administration would not give peo- on would not give non. ple like them a better chance in life.

Working class Tory voters obviously have few illusions about the class interests that the Tories serve. Why do they still vote Tory? The same survey, by Marplan, indicates that 83% of Tory voters reckon that the Tories will "govern Britain strongly"

Labour's weaknesses are also highlighted by the poll. 36% of all voters think that Labour would listen to their views, while the Tories score only 19% on this question; 35% think that Labour would given people like them a better chance in life, and only 24% hope the same from the Tories.

Strong But on "governing strongly" the Tories get 56% confidence, and Labour only 26%, Neil Kinnock's line of trying to make Labour appear all things to all people will lose votes for Labour, not win them.

Jobs are, and have to be, central to Labour's message. Neil Kinnock talks about creating one million new jobs. But how? Labour's promises remain vague, and no wonder most voters don't believe him.

By cutting working hours? But Labour's nominal commitment to a 35 hour week has vanished from By restoring Tory cuts in public services, and expanding them? Kinnock has specifically refused to promise to restore Tory cuts.

Labour councils are supposed to provide a lot of the new jobs, but they have been told in so many words that they will not have their money from central government restored to 1979 levels, and they will not be bail: ed out from their huge debt burdens.

Since the Labour leaders now want an increase in military spending (supposedly to reassure voters that nuclear disarmament doesn't make Labour soft' on military matters), this can only mean that many Tory cuts in public services will stay, or that more will be made.

Support

Will a Labour government support workers who occupy their workplaces to fight cuts and closures, by underwriting continued production under public ownership and workers' control? Will it launch a big programme of training and re-training at trade union rates of pay?

No: even the notion, briefly floated last autumn, of a Labour government making nationalised industries restore jobs cut under the Tories, has been dropped after protests from the bosses. Renationalistion of job-cutting privatised enterprises like British Telecom has been postponed to never-never.

The only definite thing about Neil Kinnock's jobs programme is that it calls for keeping wages down. As Labour Weekly put it, "His message was that jobs would come first and the price to be paid might have to be restraint by some unions in pay bargaining.

This is no way working class votes, and certainly no way to beat unemployment.

Capitalism — the rule of profit -has to be replaced, not nudged, manipulated and cajoled, Under capitalism men and women do not control our own social life. We are tossed around by economic forces, of human construction but beyond human control — supply and demand, profit and investment, credit and liquidity.

The system knows no way to adjust to changes other than by the travail of trade wars, slumps and deindustrialisation.

Remedy

The remedy? We must of the means of product created and run them by atrol have ratic planning for need. We must replace the crazy patchwork of national rivalries with a co-operative international system. In place of the rat race, we must run society on principles of solidarity.

Struggle

The struggle for Jobs can be brought to completion only by the working class taking power in society. But we can start now with a fight for workers' control, for unity of the employed and unemployed, for a shorter working week, and for work-sharing without loss of pay.

We must start the fight against the Tories; and we will have to continue it against a Labour government that ties itself to managing capitalism. PO Box 823, London SE15 4 NA.

etest date forceparismin ost Monday pribi phom: Monday even ang ditor: Jolars OrMalrony(TU).

Published by Socialist Organiser, PO BRANARB. London S b 4M.

inted breast End olise HUl, London ER registered, askar newspepri he Postioffice. igned apacies corner pecessarky reflectinerviers o SocialistiOnganiser. Newspaper headlines, like those French "Golden Delicious" apples, are a constant source of disappointment. They look so crisp and tangey and green (the apples, I mean) and then you bite into them to find...soggy blotting paper.

Last Tuesday's headlines looked very tangey indeed: " 'Neil won't win' storm hits Labour" was the Express front page lead; "Storm over Kinnock 'to lose' " said the Mail.

What could all this be about? Apparently, David Blunkett had gıven an interview to that well-known journal of in-depth political analysis, Women's Own. According to the Express, "a row was waging last night after labour chief David Blunkett was claimed to have given his own party the thumbs down as election nohopes." The Telegraph put it rather more literately: "A leading left-wing ally of Mr. Neil Kinnock was involved in an embarrassing row over a prediction that Mrs Thatcher could win the next election."

This sounds like real dynamite, doesn't it? Unfortunately these journalistic apples turned out to be of the Golden Delicious variety. Nowhere, in any of the papers, could I find a single quote from Blunkett to justify the dramatic headlines and opening paragraphs. Plainly, Blunkett said something to Women's Own, and whatever it was, it must have hinted at less than 100% confidence in a Labour victory at the next election. But what the hell were his actual words?

After extensive investigations by my research team, I can reveal the truth. Blunkett said:

"If someone had said in 1979 that she could have three terms as Prime Minister everyone would have said it was impossible. Now it is not inconceivable that they will win the next election. If I had to put my last ES on the election, out of evangelical faith I'd put it on Labour, but my head tells me I might end up starving."

Well now, that hardly adds up to giving Labour "the thumbs down as election no-hopes" , does it? It's what every Labour supporter knows to be true at the moment, with the Tories leading by a couple of points in the opinion polls at a time when, to be confident of victory, Labour ought to be storming ahead. And any election agent will tell you that complacency is no way to rally the troops.

So why did Blunkett rush to denounce the Women's Own article as a "terrible and offensive distortion" instead of just pointing out that his words did not justify the lurid headlines? Maybe because he really was misquoted. But 1 doubt it.

Blunkett knows that his perfectly loyal and reasonable admission of doubt about Labour's prospects really amounts to a terrible indictment of everything Kinnock (and Blunkett himself stands for. Kinnock won the leadership on the "image" ticket. He's been steadily eroding the more radical aspects of conference policies (defence — so far — being the partial exception); he's expelled "undesirables' like Militant supporters, lowered the red flag and adopted the thornless rose. For Neil, respectability and slick packaging is everything. Policies (at least, socialist policies) are nothing. And yet, still Labour is lagging behind this terrible government, and victory seems far from certain. How can this possibly be?

Perhaps the answer is that people don't like soggy politics any more than they like soggy apples.

Scan page 4

LETTEI

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 304

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →