Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Women and socialism

Socialist Organiser no. 303, 19 February 1987 · scan p. 10 · about 1,678 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

VES cial Women against Pit Closures march through Birmingham. Sarah Man's article "Femocracy or Feminism" in the last SO (302) is hard to reply to, partly because she attributes to SSiN positions which we do not hold in order to kneck them down, and partly because Sarah seems to think that we are attacking all women involved in We attacked a thin layer of activists on the left, amongst other things. We attacked them because they claim to speak for all women; now along comes Sarah Mann to claim — no, to take it for granted without spelling the claim out - that everything we say about a thin layer of "Femocrats" is ipso facto an attack on all women. No it isn't.

Nor are we atacking all women who call themselves feminists - not by a long way. Instead we are attacking a particular method and a series of beliefs that are developing in the National Union of Students. We say that this development is to the detriment of the struggle against sexism and for women's liberation and equality in the here and now and that it is also detrimental to the struggle for socialism..

Misogynist Before trying to answer Sarah's points in detail I would like to take issue with the labelling of me as a misogynist. I would resent it, if it didn't make such a change from the usual abuse. Never before have I been called a self-hater. Usually, the insults are the opposite - too bigheaded and pushy to be a proper woman. But there you go, it never has been easy for a woman to say what she thinks without her sexual identity and psychological welfare being called into question.

But the meat of her argument is more important than the throw-away insults.

Autonomy

Sarah says SSiN doesn't support women's autonomy. Yes we do! At the last NUS conference in December 1986, we proposed the constitutional autonomy of the women's conference, positive discrimination in the NUS Executive elections, the right of the women's conference to submit its policy for debate at full conference and to table one debate for discussion at the NUS Easter conferences.

It would have been more straightforward of Sarah to have explained that SSiN was against the women's conterence electing the women's officer of NUS because of incumbent accountability problems. The women's officer will be a member of the NEC. This body is genuinely accountable; it is elected at Easter and its Report and Plan (which explains how the Executive intends to implement mandates) are discussed in some detail at the December conference, For the women's officer to be elected by and accountable to the women's conference but to be carrying out the mandates of both that conference and full conference is absurd. It is likely that the full conference and the women's conference will have conflicting mandates both on women and other subjects.

Everyone knows this is a worry. To gnore the big problem and see the ssue only as a token and symbol for women's advancement 303 19 bunnld he tn he comnletelv irre asnansi ble and not only to the NUS. The resultant chaos and conflicts would do the cause of women no good at all.

One solution to get around the problem was that the full conference decisions on women would go to the women's conference in the form of the Report and Plan for acceptance. Nothing was proposed about conflicting mandates in other political areas - unless reading between the lines of the successful motion reveals a tight interpretation of the statement that the women's conference shall only discuss matters of specific concern or special interest to women. SSiN could not tolerate that. We believe that the full conference must be able to run its own women's campaign and that there must also be the autonomous camnaien too. To keep the channels of accountability clear we proposed the women's officer be elected by full conference.

It is quite reasonable for people to object, to say that it is better for the women's committee to have a sabbatical - even though she couldn't really take part in full Execs - than to have men voting for the women's officer. That is a legitimate position. But to accuse SSiN of taking our position because it would better the chances of our candidate for the position is unreasonable. And it is stupid if Sarah looks at the figures for the last election of the women's committee — elected by the women's conference - when Michele Carlisle of SSiN topped the poll.

Caricature

Sarah's method of caricaturing SSiN continues for the rest of the article. She quotes me as saying "Objective arguments don't matter much either. It is impossble to win. The rules of their game forbid debate...there is no doubt that some women cry "sexist' when politically challenged."

But she then goes on to explain that what I am really saying is that "women haven't got the political expertise to argue their own case. But Father than fade into the background after all, that would be a wholly passive act of behaviour!) they tant and rave at men, winning their arguments only on the grounds of making the male sex feel guilty".] And from there she launches forth to tell us that most meetings are male dominated and accuses SSiN of not knowing it!

This is odd. Does she think that SSiN says women should fade into the background? And if not, why mention it? But really that has very little to do with anything. Is Sarah saying that we are wrong and no women hide behind sexism to avoid political debate? Or is she saying that it doesn't matter because women are oppressed? I don't know what Sarah means but I could do without the lecture about how some men treat outspoken women.

Twist Another appalling twist is her argument concerning sexual harassment. She amalgamates my arguments with those of the Tories and tells us that most women are frightened of revealing cases of harassment and accuses SSiN of laying the blame for sexual harassment at women's feet.

I don't know how she arrives at such a position. We don't accuse women of causing sexual harassment. We have circulated model guidelines on dealing with sexual harassment to many colleges because NUS hasn't done it. But again, Sarah should stick to the piont. Either I am lying and no woman has claimed sexual harass ment to score points or she must say that if I am right and it has happened, whether or not she condones it.

Sarah must also reply to the second substantial point I made: that there is a body of opinion which says that men are guilty of sexual harassment because the woman says so. Does Sarah think that this is true and if so where is her critique of the arguments the left have always used regarding court cases. In particularly the position that habeas corpus is progressive and that special provision must be made for women so that they have a fair trial on an equal basis to the accused - not one where the judgement is pre-determined by sexist assumptions.

Another strange attribution VICTORY TO THE MINERS Stap the Batt Jane Ashworth SSiN is the claim that we don't think the issues of rape and abortion are relevant to middle class women or that working class men do not have power over working class women. You have no reason to think that. Please look at our model motions for NUS conference which say precisely that they do, and please remember that Michele Carlisle is the NAC student organiser.

Sarah refuses to address the real point I was making — that a new current, a variation of radical feminism, therefore democracy. Believing. this 'truth' means all those who disagree are necessarily sexists — or not willing to give up their male power and listen to women.

The theoretical underpinnings of femocracy are hard to locate but much is rooted in radical feminism. The central argument is that men are the enemy. The old phrase that the personal is political has been twisted. From its original liberating insight it has come to mean that the political is person, i.e. the power relationships in the outside world are necessarily the case within individual relationships.

The task then becomes to create political blocs to compete for power and lifestyles which are free from presumed power and concomitant oppression.

Consequences

But this is wrong. The consequences are dire - it could lead to the Americanisation of British politics. We need to build a working class consicousness which is aware of sexism, which fights for the whole class and the oppressed who are not proletarian. Implicit in that is the acceptance of the need for autonomy to win that fight, to change our movement, to make it genuinely habitable for women.| It is true, and Sarah Mann admits: it, that socialism is the only society in which women's liberation will potentially be realised. But she seeks to balance (and counter) that truth with another one: there will be no socialism without women's liberation. Absolutely right, Sarah!

So we have to integrate and coordinate the working class (men and liberation - a struggle which sometimes parallels and sometimes intermeshes with the general class struggle. Neither struggle should be conducted in such a way as to rule out the irreplaceable linking up of the Unity Both the day-to-day class struggle now and the winning of socialism require female-male working class unity. Men can and will be won to fight for women's equality (which also means special positive discrimination methods here and now).

The antics we describe as "Femocracy' can only work against both female-male unity in the broad class struggle and against malefemale unity in the fight against. women's oppression. That's the issue, Sarah.

THE CASE FOR

----- pull-quotes -----

replies to an article that appeared in last week's SO

John Harris, Phot

women) struggle for socialism with an ongoing struggle for women's

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 303

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →