Box Orange a
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser no 303 19 February 1987 Page Heartbreak Ridge is the wish fulfilment fantasy of a disappointed man. The man is Clint Eastwood, so the fantasy is pretty inflated. Yet for all its length (two long, long hours), it's a petty, pathetic film.
Clint plays an ageing gunnery sergeant, Tom "Gunny' Highway. He's a boozer and a brawler who often lands in jail. This hasn't done his army career any good. He transferred from his old platoon into a tame office job, and he's bitter. He dearly wants to get back to the action.
Gunny at first seems to be a parody, and the film itself almost tips over into parody of the broadest kind. Yet we're meant to take it straight, and it's so tasteless that you can't laugh — you just feel disgusted.
Gunny isn't just a drunk and a brawler; he's also a foul mouthed homophobe. He's obsessed with anal sex, and with homosexuality. Every threat he utters concerns what he means to shove up somebody's arse? He's a nut. Yet Eastwood presents ¡this crazy obsessive as the epitome of maleness, as a throwback to when men were men. Gunny is plastered with bravery medals to underline his -heroism.
Gunny may be grey-haired and ageing, but he's presented as the toughest thing going. Not once, not twice, but three times we have to endure the sight of Clint beating younger adversaries twice his size and strength.
Transferred back to his old platoon, Gunny finds things have changed. The new Major is a rule-book, red-tape type from military academy, who hasn't had the 'privilege' Jo combat. He despises Clint's type, and hints that Clint is old and washed up.
But Clint sets him straight. He is ¡given a small patrol to organise. This recon patrol is supposed to form the vanguard of an attack but, as Gunny «discovers, the men are demoralised ¡and slack, and have been the butt of jokes, Till now. Gunny sets out to make real men, i.e. replicas of himself, out of them. The group are presented as lazy no-hopers, and surprise, surpise, they're mostly black or Hispanic, i.e. Gunny's ideas of degerates. But Gunny believes he can turn even these "ladies' into fighting men.
If ever there was a movie cliche, the turning of a sloppy bunch into real fighting men by discipline and strictness is one of them. The picture really sags at this point. Gunny is so gung ho that he seems pathetic. And the men laugh at him. They don't just knuckle under either. They plan to have him beaten up. When this fails. they give in, but they still jeer at him. He doesn't break their spirits.
The patrol improve to the point of beating the Major's group. But the The Grenad because pletely was tod the US But combat group Major doesn't play fair. He's a spoilsport. Even when the chance of a real war comes along, he's still trying to tie Gunny up in red tape.
Real war is what Gunny yearns for after 'a tie in Korea and a loss in Vietnam' • And the US invasion of Grenada comes along in answer to Gunny's prayers. Gunny has been a true commie-hater all through, so it comes as a surprise when the invasion is presented merely as an outing to rescue stranded Americans, rather than a beating for the commies.
fact that the Americans in a had to be rescued after and : the US had invaded is comignored. It's as if Eastwood 3 embarrassed to admit what was up to in Grenada. for all that, he presents the in Grenada with pusto. His slay every commie in their path, and since these all turn out to be Cuban soldiers, this makes Gunny happy. Only one or two Grenadians appear, as civilians. These are shown being marched off at gunpoint by US troops.
Gunny's men supposedly prove their worth as men. Yet when they get into trouble, they call in an air strike, and lie low till the choppers have blasted the daylights out of the enemy before emerging. They take a hill, but they have so annihilated the enemy by superior fire power that it's a victory of technology, not of men over men.
Rambo was a fantasy of using superior technology to refight and win Vietnam. This film is supposed to be reality, and it just looks silly. The glee Gunny feels is embarrassing. It's as if the US was so desperate to assert itself that it had to trumpet its victory over tiny Grenada as proof of its invincibility. It's like a human treading on a flea and saying, 'I beat You' . The odds are hardly equal.
But to Gunny, it proves his men are men, and he can retire happy, knowing his tradition will be carried on.
Yes, it's as bad as that, and worse, 100. The film shows Gunny trying to win back his ex-wife. He buries himself in "Vogue' and other women's magazines to try to understand where he went wrong. When he spouts some of this drivel, she bursts out laughing, incredulous. She tells him she left because he wasn't what she wanted and that, for him, the army always came first, anyway. This would seem to be proved when he leaves her flat on the dance floor to rush back to the platoon when the red alert is called. But no. She's waiting for him at the end, waving her little flag.
Gunny has to be presented as invincible, even with women, and even when the logic of the film points the opposite way. As for the scene where a waitress eyes Gunny, licking her lips in anticipation — well!
Mouth and eyes are distant memories for Gunny - all he has left are slits through which he spits insults and shoots contemptuous glances. The film shows that cursing and insults thrive in the Marines' hierarchical system - the Major insults Gunny, Gunny insults his men. It's a vile and oppressive system.
Gunny's voice is curously strangled. He issues his threats and commands in a hoarse, grating whisper. This is hilarious in combat, as it's unthinkable that he could be heard. But belief has to be firmly suspended anyway.
Gunny is meant to represent America as Eastwood wants it to be - strong and masculine against the "degeneracy' of commies, gays, blacks and hippies. He's keeping the torch alight, and passing it on. He's trying to send Reagan a message to do the same.
Eastwood obviously feels his roughness is diminishing with age. and that his appeal to women is too. So he's made this film to prove that he hasn't lost his grip. But he protests too much.
He protests his straightness 1o0 much too. If you want to present. yourself as heterosexuality incarnate, then you shouldn't force your platoon to train barechested (for no good reason) or suck so contentendly on a huge phallic-looking Cuban cigar. It just might plant a few doubts in people's minds! WHAT IS your mental when you hear or read the *Protestant working class?
Blinkered, bible-thumping bigots, who may call themselves British but live in the 17th century - not. our sort of people at all?
The Protestant community gets a very bad press in Britain. The recent Daily Express poll on attitudes to Ireland [see Press Gang] found that 55% of those questioned believed that Provisional Republican leader Gerry Adams MP is a 'force for evil', but a full 70% think the same of lan Paisley.
There is much justice in the impatience that British people feel with the political and religious bigotry of Northern Ireland's Protestants - though in fact it is much more recently than the 17th century that people like Paisley have played leading roles in mainstream British politics, during the religious uproar around the 1902 Education Act, for example, There is less justice in the left's attitude to the Protestant workers. Bigots they are, and supremacists too, most of them. But, like the Northern Ireland Catholics, they are victims of the unholy mess that Britain and the Irish bourgeoisie (green, orange, and green-white-and-orange) made when they so messily partitioned Ireland in 1922, failing utterly to establish a framework within which Ireland's Protestant minority and Catholic majority could live peacefully together.
It is nonsense to see the Protestant workers as akin to the grossly privileged whites of South Africa. Northern Ireland's Protestant workers live in slums and are exploited. Their main privilege has been a better chance of a job in an economy which suffered mass unemployment even in the boom The Steelchest, Nail in the Boot, and the Barking Dog' (the title is made up of the nicknames of shipbuilders) was a very valuable documentary precisely because it depicted the ordinariness of the Protestant workers in the Belfast shipyards. The people interviewed could have been workers at Cammell Lairds, Liverpool, or the defunct Glasgow shipyards — or dockers in London, Liverpool, or Southampton.
The film avoided any discussion of the social framework, or of the Catholic-Protestant relationship. But it was something that needed doing to present the Protestant workers at the shipyard as what they are — our people, ordinary working people who struggle against poverty, high accident rates, and the fatigue of grinding labour.
The film should be shown at leftwing gatherings where Ireland is being discussed. The political background, and the relationship of the Protestant workers to the Catholic community, can be filled in. But this film fills in another side of the picture in Northern Ireland - the one that is usually absent from British left-wing discussion.
Scan page 10
DISCUSSIC