Sectarian to Briefing
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Socialist one ma "Worker arms go REAGAN'S Socialist Organisen SE HYPOCRISY Lebanon has been terrible, it is not clear at all that it has been a main contributor to sectarianism. What about internal factors in Lebanon?
What about Syria? SW doesn't even mention Syria's reactionary involvement in Lebanon.
The article is a crude, two-dimensional view of the conflict which by omission actually lies about the situation. Once upon a time SW aspired to be a serious Marxist newspaper, but these days it seems to be competing with Socialist Action to see which can be the more mindlessly "militant" and "anti-imperialist" J SOCIALIST Organiser gets sectarian every week.
No.301 called Socialist Action a "bilge-water-laden ship' sinking into swamp. No.302 accuses Labour Briefing of descending 'to earth with a dispirited ping' Maybe the truth is that Briefing and Socialist Action have got their feet on the ground, while SO is up in the clouds.
Patrick Blandford attacks Briefing for demanding that Labour fight for its own radical policies, and makes great play with the fact that a Briefarticle Briefing has made it quite clear something about its policies, because it has a real record of struggle in the labour movement.
Briefing led the fight at close quarters against the sell-outs of local government careerists like Ken Livingstone, while SO was reciting 'perfect' policies on the sidelines, and by doing so it won itself standing, respect, and influence in the Labour left which SO will never win, KEITH SPENCER Oxford.
Scan page 5
The Palestinians and the Lebanese tragegy Clive crisis Pales • ANALYSISI Bradley loo in Lebanon tinians.
When the State of Israel was created in 1948, many Palestinians were dispersed from their land - many fled, and others were forcibly removed. They were never allowed to return. But no new Palestinian state was created: Palestine was first divided between the Palestinian Jews and the Palestinian Arabs, then in 1949 Jordan seized and divided the Palestinian Arab area. In 1967 Israel seized the Jordaniancontrolled West Bank, along with the Gaza Strip (and the Syrian Golan Heights and Egyptian Sinai) and imposed military occupation.
So the Palestinians were denied their own state. Many of them live scattered about the different Arab states, and many of these in refugee camps, poorly funded by the United Nations.
Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO), based primarily on the refugees. They were forced out of their main stronghold in Jordan in 1970 - when during 'Black September', , the regime of King Hussein subjected them to brutal repression.
Since then, the main base of the PLO has been in Lebanon. The presence of the refugees with their guerrilla armies has been one of the many ingredients leading to the breakdown of the Lebanese political system — and society - from 1974.
Palestinians and Lebanese alike were subjected to periodic military attack from Israel. Indeed, Lebanese refugees escaping Israeli bombardment, swelled the massive "belts of misery in the cities like Beirut.
Many of these, the most brutalised and dispossessed of all the Lebanese people, were members of the Shi'ite Moslem sect. (In the mid-seventies, they had a popular movement called the Movement of the Dispossessed).
The Palestinian presence, massive social inequalities, and the collapse of a delicate political system that discriminated against Moslems in is at the events behind the I the events b and the plight of the the plight of favour of Christians (most of whom are Maronite Catholics) all led.to the civil war's first outbreak in 1974-6. 40,000 people were the victims of that first period, which closed with the military invasion of Syria against the Palestinians and their Arab nationalist allies.
Syria has continued to occupy part of Lebanon. Israel launched a full-scale invasion in 1978, and an all-butgenocidal invasion in 1982, aimed at destroying the PLO presence. That took them to a long a bitter siege of Beirut that was to culminate with the withdrawal of Palestinian guerrillas, for a while, from the country.
Added to Syrian and Israeli armies of occupation was now a 'multinational force' including French, British and American forces - who devoted much effort to the bombardment of villages in an attempt to destroy the armed groups based there, particularly, in the summer of 1983, the villages of the Druze sect and its militias.
The multinational force withdrew in 1984; but Lebanon has still not been put back together. Simmering civil war has continued — between different Lebanese groups, and between different Palestinian groups. In 1983, Syria sponsored a murderous factional split in the PLO between Yasser Arafat's group and more hard-line factions.
The government of right-wing Maronite Amin Jemayal has little real authority. Syria controls big parts of the country; the Israeli-backed South Lebanon Army controls the south; and the rest is a patchwork quilt of different militia groups' power-bases. Pro-Iranian groups like Hizbollah (Party of God) have built support.
Amal (ironically 'Hope') has a long history of antagonism towards the Palestinian groups. There are many sources to this hostility, one of which is alleged to be the arrogance of PLO fighers over Shi'ite villages in the past. Certainly, in the perception of many Shi'ites, the Palestinians are the cause of all their problems: if the Palestinians went, the Israelis would leave them alone.
Full-scale attempts by Amal to destroy the PLO are therefore not new. In May 1985 Amal launched an A Palestinian in the ruins of Tyre, assault on Burj al-Barajneh, Sabra and shalla.
Sabra and Shatila wre the scene of horrific massacres carried out by Maronite militamen with Israeli complaisance, in 1982.
There are no easy solutions to Lebanon's agony. The conflict between the different factions is largely communal and sectarian - like a northern Ireland on an immensely bigger scale in a high state of communal degeneration.
Interference
Some things are, however, very clear. Outside interference has never done Lebanon anything but harm. Syrian troops should be withdrawn; Israel should cease its support for Lebanese groups. And • Ronald Reagan should keep out. The resumption of gun-boat diplomacy will make things worse. The United Nations 'Interim' Force in Lebanon has been utterly ineffective; the multinational force sent in after Israel's invasion in 1982 was a disaster. Further involvement must be resisted.
No resolution of the Lebanese crísis is possible so long as the wider problems of the Middle East conflict are ignored. The precondition for peace in Lebanon - though not in itself a sufficient condition - is the granting of the Palestinian people the right to their own state. The Palestinians don't want to be in Lebanon: they have been forced there.
Some sort of democratic and secular arrangement for Lebanon within a socialist Middle East is the real answer. That may seem a long way off: but anything less than a fundamental reordering of the whole region will be just tutile tinkering.
Last July, the Lebanese General Labour Federation anited Moslems and Christians in a general strike to protest at violence and economic crisis. It is a long way from that to a full-scale working-class political solution. But it does give reason for hope.
PLO The PLO have a right to struggle for their national rights, and should be supported. Their destruction will not help any moves towards peace in the Middle East. Amal's brutal attempt to destroy them is not just morally repugnant — it is politically reactionary. The labour movement internationally should do what it can to rescue the Palestinians from disaster. Money and food should be sent to the refugees. The PLO should be recognised as the chosen representative of the Palestinian people.
----- pull-quotes -----
that its own policies go way beyond official Labour Party pledges. And, more to the point, Briefing can do
After 1967, radical guerrilla movements emerged, united in the