Thatcherism and Solidarnosc
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
another New York. finance whizzkid pleaded guilty.
Unfortunately they are being prosecuted not for drawing profits from the blood and sweat of the working class, but for ripping off other capitalists.
If they got their way. he said, "I would get Thatcher to send some battleships over there. She's good at that. We'll get her to blow Cameroons, Zaire and Zimbabwe to smithereens.
This outburst became the front-page lead story in the black newspaper "Voice' last week. Neil Kinnock should say that public support for Labour from Brian Clough will no longer be welcome until he apologises.
(Lebanon) back to the stone age. Along with Israel, they have turned it into an inferno of sectarian violence."
But there is more to the Lebanese 'inferno' than what the US and Israel have done to it. Indeed, although the US role in Edward Ellis may think Stoppard told the truth about Solidarnose in his play 'Squaring the Circle? Certainly I would agree that these societies are undemocratic and bureaucratically and incompetently ruled. And Stoppard did show us that. But that's beside the point.
My objection was to his motives. Stoppard is not sympathetic to the struggle by Solidarnosc's workers for rights. He is merely using the drama of their struggle to create anticommunist propaganda. Unlike intellectuals such as Kuron, who tried to make links with workers, Stoppard the bourgeois intellectual, looks down on them and uses them as a vehicle for his own views.
It was that, and the tone of his play that 1 objected to. It wasn't really Poland in the early 1980s that he was attacking. It was communism, socialism of any type. When he dragged Lenin's name into it, it was to imply that the great tradition of the Russian Revolution would inevitably lead to these scheming, desperate bureaucrats holding absolute power in a totalitarian state.
Stoppard can romanticise Solidarnose because he sees their struggle as doomed. He sees the Russian army, Reagan's 'evil empire" looming behind the Polish one. If the Poles can't beat the workers down, the Russians will come in to finish the job.
Example
He'd probably be a little less keen if Solidarnose had won and set a revolutionary example to the workers of Britain.
Literature doesn't come our of nowhere. If reflects the social structure in which the author is based Stoppard's play was written under a Thatcher government which is committed to robbing workers of hard won rights and to breaking up their organisations. Workers here might be tempted to organise in protest. So maybe Stoppard's play is saying; Hold on, you think things are bad here? Look at Poland! You've never. had it so good."
BELINDA WEAVER Islington