How far will Gorbachev go?
Socialist Organiser1987 1987-02-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
STALIN DIED in March 1953— the tyrant who had ruled the USSR for almost three decades. In 1939, Leon Trotsky had rightly said that Stalin's political regime was in some ways more oppressive than Hitler's Nazi regime in Germany.
Almost immediately after Stalin's that?, what became known as the set in. The frame-up trial of Jewish doctors which Stalin had been preparing was cancelled by his successors. The innocent victims, whose conviction and annihilation was to have been the signal for a vast increase in Stalin's campaign against the USSR's Jews — officially it was a campaign against "Zionism' — were released.
A new liberalism flowered. Writers could be critical, especially about the past. Stalin's chief henchman, Beria, was killed, and a new leading team emerged._ By the mid "50s, after a series of struggles and manoeuvres behind the walls of the Kremlin, Nikita Khrushchev emerged as the new dictator.
Khrushchev had played a central role in the slaughter of millions in his native Ukraine in the '30s by government-inflicted famine and by the executioner's bullet. But he was a benevolent dictator. He had loathed Stalin's regime of terror, and considered his own survival, when so many top Stalinists of the '30s had perished at the tyrant's whim, a matter of accident or luck.
Khrushchev
At the 20th Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in February 1956, Khrushchev delivered a 'secret' speech which denounced Stalin and much that he had done. At the 22nd Congress in late 1961, he returned to the subject and added much new detail to the chronicle of horrors.
But neither in 1956 nor in 1961 did Khrushchev attack any of the fundamentals of Stalinist rule. He insisted upon the leading role of the Party' which is the bureaucrats' jargon for their monopoly of power;
and he was careful to praise Stalin's "positive role' in the fight in the '20s against 'the Trotskyists' - that is, in the war against the working class during which the bureaucratic elite personified and led by Stalin established its dictatorship over the USSR.
Khrushchev employed bureaucratic "liberalism' to ease PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. 01-639 7965 Latest date for reports: first post Monday or by phone, Monday evening.
Editor: John O'Mahony. Typesetting: Upstream Ltd (TU).
Published by Socialist braarkser qoan812B SI ANA.
Printed by East End Offset (TU), London E2.
PHE FIE the Post Office.
Socialist: Duganise* things for the top bureaucrats whom Stalin had ruled with the caprice of a half-mad tyrant, slaughtering them casually. By the end of that entire period - when Khrushchev was overthrown in a Kremlin coup in 1964 — that had become plain. The Tuling bureaucrats - the USSR equivalent of the ruling class in Briworking class — had normalised and 11.1 who also live by robbing th stabilised their rule, not renounced it.
Under Stalin, the only retirement was to the GPU gravepits, but now it became possible for bureaucratic leaders - even in disgrace, like Khrushchev himselt — to retire to country houses and end their lives in comfort. The central guiding maxim of the Khrushchevites was expressed in the words of Nikita the Good himself: "Spontaneity, comrades, is the danger. Fight spontaneity" • This was bureaucratic jargon for: "Watch the working class"
Workers
Though the liberalisation did not much affect the working class, there_ Polish workers on strike, Augu: was a danger that it would - a danger that the easing of the terror would trigger a working-class drive against the bureaucratic regime. As far as we know, it didn't, in the USSR, though there is evidence that strikes occurred and were bloodily repressed, and that there were revolts in the early '50s in the labour camps. Up to 10 million slave labourers, at any one time in Stalin's era, were imprisoned and often worked to death in these camps.
The reform era did help to trigger workers' risings in East Germany (1953), Poland (1956), and Hungary (1956). And when it did, the reformers slaughtered the workers of East Berlin and of Budapest. They would have slaughtered the Poles if the Polish reforming Stalinists had not managed to keep a precarious hold on the workers' movement, which they later slowly stifled and repressed.
Khrushchev's "thaw' disoriented many socialists into thinking that the bureaucracy was reforming itself. So it was - but not out of existence.
And the East German and Hungarian workers learned at great Gorbachev: the reforming Czar cost that though Stalin was dead and repudiated by his successors, nevertheless Stalin's spirit lived.
And Stalin's spirit lives still. It will be a shame if the very feeble "liberalisation' of the latest emperor of Stalin's dynasty takes anyone in.
Of course it would be wonderful if the foul bureaucratic dictatorship melted away. It won't. It will have to be smashed and overthrow by the workers and farmers, and by the many nationalities oppressed by the Russian-chauvinist ruling bureaucracy.
Stagnant
Last week's assault by KGB plainclothes thugs on a peacetul demonstration in Moscow shows how little credence can be given to Gorbachev's gestures.
What is Gorbachev really trying to do? The USSR's economic system is stagnant, inefficient, and in many ways moribund. The bureaucracy stifles the economy because it stifles the people.
They have lost out heavily in the They have lost heavily in the last two decades In the economic competition with the USA, Western Europe, and Japan.
Just as in the *50s Khrushchev needed to end the reign of terror for: the bureaucrats, today Gorbachev needs to unblock the passes of the bureaucratic system and clean the cobwebs from the window. He needs to tone up the bureaucracy, to introduce some semblance of initiative, competition, and plain speaking. The rest is public relations work for the West.
Gorbachev cannot seriously believe it when he talks of withdrawing all USSR troops and bases abroad. He has not even got out of Afghanistan - he has only offered to do so on conditions that he knows will not be fulfilled.
The permanent threat of USSR invasion was decisive in derailing Solidarnosc's drive for power in 1980-1, and Gorbachev will know that. Reagan is vile, with his contras, his US troops on Nicaragua's border, and his sponsored death squads in El Salvador. So is Gorbachev, with his napalm in Afghanistan and his occupying armies in Eastern Europe.
Renovate
The fundamentals of bureaucratic rule in the USSR are one-party monopoly of power, bureaucratic control of the means of production and communication, and the repression of all independent working-class initiative or organisation. For certai Gorbachev has nO ntention changing any of that Like Khrushchev, his guiding po ciple is "Fight Spontaneity" and like Khrushchev he will use as much force as necessary and possible to beat down the workers of the USSR and Eastern Europe.
The real significance of the present liberalisation is that it may prove impossible for the bureaucracy to suppress "spontaneity' . The moves on top may activate or give openings to the workers and to those in their tanks who have organised the nuclei of independent trade unions - people like Klebanov and Nikitin.
It is the working class which will renovate the USSR and Eastern Europe - not the liberalising tyrants. The British press is probably at its worst when it comes to the Irish question. The standard picture we are presented with is of hopeless, inexplicable conflict with 'our boys' holding the ring while the mad Irish fight it out among themselves for reasons no-one quite understands.
The latest atrocity will be recorded in all its horrific detail and usually attributed to the IRA. Paisley's rantings are reported and we are left with the impression that this man is just crazier than the usual Irishman who rather likes the sound of his own voice. The political conclusion which is usually drawn from all this is that the troops must stay in there for the foreseeable future. But it is just as logical from the above 'analysis' to draw precisely the opposite conclusion: something along the lines of "what the hell, bring our boys home, let the paddies fight it out among themselves."
The "what the hell" line has been espoused by the Daily Mirror for many years now - a source of considerable emotional sustenance for those on the left who nurture the conviction that a mass movement can be built around the slogan "Troops Out!
I imagine that the "exclusive" in last Tuesday's Daily Express, "Pull our troops out of Ulster say 61%" will be seized upon bv the single issue troops out fantasists as further proof that a combination of war-weariness and unconscious anti-imperialism among the British public may yet spawn a mighty mass movement.
"Nearly two-thirds of people living in mainland Britain would like to see British troops pulled out of Northern Ireland an exclusive Daily ExpressMORI poll reveals today" . MORI interviewed a total of 1103 adults in 74 constituency points around Britain in January.
22% of those questioned favoured an immediate withdrawal, 39% wanted to see a phased withdrawal— compared to 31% in May 1984, when the last poll on the subject was commissioned. 35% thought that maintaining the troops was "costing the British tax payer too much"
But before the Troops Out Movement and the Labour Committee on Ireland rush to the printers with bulk orders for fresh membership cards, they should note something else about the Express poll:
"When they were asked where in a fist of priorities facing Britain they would place the Irish question, the answer, possibly quite predictable, was that none gave it priority."
And there was a three way split on what should happen when the troops are pulled out: 29% wanted the six counties to remain part of the UK.
Another 29% wanted to see an independent Ulster and 27% wanted to see Ulster united witht he Republic Coincidentally, a couple of week earlier Frank Chapple (remem im?) wrote in his 'Frankly in the Dail lanes the British in must learn so sogether shouldn't stand in their was The fact that "what the hell" ap pears to be gaining ground among British public opinion and in the pages of the right wing press is surely just another manifestation of the press's traditional lack of serious — or even honest. - coverage of the conflict or of concern for the fate of the people of Ireland.
Postscript.
The News on Sunday to be launched this Spring, promises to campaign for troops out of Ireland from a socialist standpoint. Let's hope so.
The last thing the Irish need is a *"left-wing" version of the ' what the hell line.
February
Scan page 4
TIE
----- pull-quotes -----
sign ententiales do pit necessarily reflect the views of